family law Flashcards
define marriage
civil contract b/w two people with capacity to consent
what constitutes consideration for a marriage contract to be valid?
mutual exchange of promises is sufficient consideration
how can a marriage contract be modified or terminated?
only with state intervention
what are the two types of marriage?
- ceremonial marriage
- common-law marriage (most jxdns have abolished)
what does a ceremonial marriage require?
- license
- solemnization
what are the requirements / parameters most states impose for a marriage license?
- age requirement (all)
- waiting period (many)
- medical testing (some)*
- expiration of license (range)
- even in those states requiring premarital medical testing, a marriage license cannot be denied on the basis of the results
age requirement for a marriage license in most jxdn
18 years old
most jxdn also allow marriage for people under 18yo provided that the party has parental consent
range of marriage license expiration (in # of days)
varies from 10 - 30 days after issuance
when will a license NOT be issued?
- if a party is already married to someone else
- if the parties are too closely related (by blood or marriage)
- if the marriage is a sham or induced by fraud
- if the parties are incapable of understanding the act of marriage
under which constitutional clause must all states and the federal government recognize a same-sex marriage legally entered into in another state?
full faith and credit
characteristics of a solemnization
solemnization is a formal marriage ceremony
- 2+ witnesses (most jxdn)
- officiant (judge, person of the clergy, or political official) (most)
- marriage license must be filed
- proxy marriage may be allowed (some)
requirements for a common-law marriage
CCCC
- CAPACITY to marry (legal and mental)
- CONSENT (parties agree that they are married - must show evidence of present intent to be married)
- COHABITATION (no min. time period)
- CONDUCT (hold themselves out to public as be married)
some states also require a min. time period to be domiciled in the state in order to recognize a common-law marriage
what is some of the evidence a court will consider in determining whether to recognize a common-law marriage?
- common children
- joint debt or assets
- title to property
- bank accounts
- insurance forms
- tax returns
etc…
will a state that does NOT recognize common-law marriage on its own still recognize a common-law marriage from another state?
yes (full faith and credit)
EXCEPT if the state has a strong public policy against recognizing the common-law marriage
what is a heartbalm action and what did heartbalm actions historically include?
civil tort actions for money damages based on broken engagements or infidelity
historically included:
1. breach of promise to marry;
2. alienation of affection;
3. seduction;
4. criminal conversation
*NO LONGER RECOGNIZED - assume these actions have been abolished unless stated otherwise
the marriage relationship provides a right to _____ for the marital or family relationship under the Constitution
privacy
court will generally not get involved while marriage / family unit is intact
what are the three ways by which to terminate a marriage?
- annulment
- divorce (dissolution)
- death
what is an annulment?
judicial decree that VOIDS a marriage
what is the main difference between an annulment and a divorce?
annulment voids a marriage and declares it as having never been valid
divorce terminates a valid marriage
when is annulment available as an option to terminate the marriage? (two types)
when the marriage is
1. VOID ab initio - as if it never happened; judicial decree NOT required
or
2. voidable - valid until a party seeks annulment; requires judicial decree
annulment:
grounds for void marriage
- bigamy (prior existing marriage)
- incest
- mental incapacity
annulment:
grounds for voidable marriage
- age
- impotence
- intoxication
- fraud, misrepresentation, duress, coercion, force
- lack of intent
annulment \ void marriage:
in cases of a prior existing marriage (bigamy), when there is a first marriage and a second marriage, which of the two marriages is considered void?
second marriage
UNLESS the impediment (first marriage) is removed (some states - Enoch Arden rule)
annulment \ void marriage:
in cases of a prior existing marriage, who has the burden?
party trying to prove the first (prior existing) marriage has the burden
annulment \ void marriage:
what constitutes mental capacity (so as to render a marriage NOT void)?
parties must be lucid for the moment of marriage contract
parties must be able to understand the duties and responsibilities to which they are engaging
annulment \ voidable marriage:
when can an underage party no longer seek annulment?
when they reach the age of majority and continue to cohabitate with their spouse
annulment \ voidable marriage:
who can seek annulment on the basis of age?
a party who is
(a) under the age of marriage consent AND
(b) did not seek parents’ consent
OR
parent of the minor child can seek annulment
annulment \ voidable marriage:
when can a party / couple seek annulment on the basis of impotence?
when one party is naturally and incurably impotent
UNLESS the other party knew about the impotence prior to marriage
annulment \ voidable marriage:
when is intoxication a proper ground for annulment?
if either party was incapable of contracting (at the time of marriage) due to alcohol or drugs
UNLESS the parties continue to cohabitate after the marriage – functions as a ratification
annulment \ voidable marriage:
when is fraud grounds for a voidable marriage?
- if it goes to the essence of the marriage
- if it was in existence at the time of the marriage (can’t be about future facts)
- if the parties immediately ceased to live together once the fraud was discovered
annulment \ voidable marriage:
examples of insufficient grounds for fraud that justifies an annulment
- spouse lied about wealth
- spouse has poor morals
- spouse has bad habits
- spouse has bad temper
NOTE: jxdns differ as to whether a false claim of pregnancy amounts to fraud that justifies an annulment
annulment \ voidable marriage:
when is a marriage voidable for lack of intent?
- parties had no intention of being married and somehow got past the licensing stage
- examples: sham, joke, marriages of limited purpose (e.g. purely for immigration)
EXCEPTIONS:
- if marriage has since been consummated, cannot be annulled
annulment:
available remedy after an annulment
court’s goal is to put the parties in the same position they were in before the marriage. parties still have some rights:
- the party SEEKING the annulment can request equitable distribution of property
- if state has a statute allowing courts to award spousal support in annulment, can also request spousal support
- many states w/o the statute will still allow temporary spousal support (during suit’s pendency)
defenses to annulment: void marriage
- deny the impediment
- other party can still pursue divorce action (type of action may impact spousal support and property distribution)
defenses to annulment: voidable marriage
equitable defenses:
- unclean hands
- laches
- estoppel
annulment:
what is the putative spouse doctrine and why would it be invoked?
purpose is to protect a party who is unaware of an impediment to their marriage that renders it void or voidable.
allows that party to use the state’s divorce provisions, even if marriage is later found void.
normally invoked to provide equitable relief to the party who believed in good faith in the marriage’s validity
define divorce
legal dissolution of a marriage
divorce:
what is one requirement that must be fulfilled prior to filing for divorce in most states?
residency requirement
- at least one party must be a resident of the state
- length of residency requirement varies: (a) from state to state or (b) whether the couple was married in the state and/or (c) whether the grounds for divorce happened in that state
divorce:
approximately how many jxdns recognize no-fault divorce?
all jxdns recognize no-fault ground for divorce
divorce:
what ground(s) for divorce do the majority of states recognize?
both no-fault and fault (most states are mixed-fault).
substantial minority of states recognize no-fault as the ONLY basis for divorce
divorce \ no-fault:
standard / requirement(s) for no-fault divorce
irretrievably broken and no prospect of reconciliation (majority jxdns)
couple must be separated for a given period of time before filing divorce action (50% jxdns)
divorce:
why would you pursue fault grounds if no-fault is so widely available?
presence of fault is mainly used to determine support like alimony
divorce \ fault:
grounds for fault-based divorce
how many and which of these are available, if any, depends on jxdn.
- Adultery
- Cruelty
- Desertion
- Habitual drunkennes
- Bigamy
- Imprisonment
- Indignity (not avail. in most jxdn)
- Institutionalization
bigamy is ground for what type(s) of marriage termination?
annulment AND divorce
divorce \ fault:
when is adultery a proper ground?
what are some common defenses to adultery?
if charging spouse can show opportunity and inclination by the other spouse (to have voluntary sex with someone else)
circumstantial evidence OK
DEFENSES:
recrimination, unclean hands, connivance, condonation, consent
divorce \ fault:
when is cruelty a proper ground?
which defense(s) is commonly seen in cruelty cases?
course of conduct that makes cont’d cohabitation unsafe or improper
- physical harm req. (most jxdn)
- physical or emotional (few jxdn)
DEFENSES:
recrimination, unclean hands
divorce \ fault:
when is desertion a proper ground?
what are some commonly asserted defenses to desertion?
one spouse voluntarily leaves marital home w/o cause or consent, with INTENT to remain away permanently
(some jxdn) - also rec. if one spouse forces the other one out AND there is fear of harm if other one returns - “constructive desertion”
DEFENSES:
recrimination; unclean hands; consent; justification
divorce \ fault:
when is habitual drunkenness a proper ground?
what are some commonly asserted defenses to habitual drunkenness?
frequent habit of getting drunk (not necessarily alcoholism) causes impairment in the marriage
DEFENSE:
assumption of the risk
divorce \ fault:
when is bigamy a proper ground?
one party knowingly entered into a prior and existing legal marriage before entering into the current one
grounds for divorce and also annulment (VOID)
divorce \ fault:
when is imprisonment a proper ground?
if the imprisonment period meets a specified period of time
divorce \ fault:
when is indignity a proper ground?
it’s usually not a basis (maj. jxdn)
divorce \ fault:
when is institutionalization a proper ground?
if no reasonable prospect of discharge or rehabilitation
divorce:
defenses to divorce
8 defenses
- only apply to fault
- must be affirmatively pleaded
- RECRIMINATION (both spouses commit a marital wrongful act of like conduct) and UNCLEAN HANDS (used when P’s own behavior is in question)
- CONNIVANCE: P gave D consent to participate in marital wrong
- CONDONATION: knowledge & forgiveness AND resumption of marital relations w guilty party
- COLLUSION: not really relevant bc no-fault is available
- PROVOCATION
- INSANITY: lacks capacity to know diff b/w right and wrong
- CONSENT (desertion, adultery)
- JUSTIFICATION (desertion): left home bc of other party’s misconduct
*RELIGION is NOT a defense to any marital wrong
divorce:
what is limited divorce?
parties live apart but still considered legally married
court determines property division & support
widely recognized but rarely used
divorce:
what is a separate maintenance action?
decree of support for a party but does not authorize them to live apart. still considered legally married.
divorce:
what is the interlocutory period
time between the divorce being initially granted and finalized. neither spouse can remarry during this period
divorce:
what can a mediator assist with?
child support, custody, visitation, parenting time, etc.
division of property:
community property
MINORITY
- equal distro of marital property
- only 9 states (in W, SW + Wisconsin)
division of property:
equitable distribution
MAJORITY
requires fair and just distribution of marital property
division of property:
what is NOT considered marital property
- acquired before marriage
- acquired after separation
- gifts (except those b/w spouses), inheritance
- excluded in pre- or post-nup
- sold for value in good faith before the date of final separation
- mortgaged or encumbered in good faith before the final separation
- award or settlement payment received for cause that ACCRUED prior to marriage
division of property:
how are increases in the value of separate property treated?
if increase in value is due to either spouse’s efforts, then marital property
(e.g. if both spouses contribute to mortgage payments, each entitled to an equitable value in the increase of the home)
if improvement due to marital property funds (e.g. salary after marriage), then also = marital property
division of property:
burden of proof
party claiming something is NOT marital property has burden of proving that it is separate
division of property:
what might courts take into account when deciding how to distribute marital property?
- length of marriage
- prior marriages?
- economic circumstances of each spouse
- income, medical needs, retirement
- contributions to education or career advancement of one spouse to other
- needs for future acquisitions
- value of any separate property
- reduction in value of marital property by one spouse (dissipation or fraud)?
- custodianship of minor children
division of property:
how are retirement benefits treated?
equitable distribution - can be both marital and nonmarital property if started accruing prior to marriage, divided proportionately
current / present value only (not future)
division of property:
how are personal injury claim proceeds treated?
- pain, suffering, disability: separate (injured)
- consortium: separate (non-injured)
- lost wages, income, medical expenses: marital
division of property:
how are stock options treated?
treated as marital property if acquired during the marriage (even if it won’t be exercised until after divorce)
division of property:
how are equitable distribution payments transferred between spouses taxed?
equitable dist. payments transferred b/w spouses are NOT treated as taxable income
division of property:
how can a property division be modified, and under what circumstances?
property divisions are non-modifiable once they occur.
changes in circumstance are not considered WRT property division. but may have an impact on spousal or child support obligations.
define spousal support
the obligation of one spouse to provide financial support to the other in the form of income
also known as maintenance or alimony
spousal support:
what factors are considered in determining the amount of support?
- financial resources of both parties
- std of living during marriage
- time needed to find a job / complete ed
- duration of marriage
- contributions to marriage (e.g. sacrifices to enhance earning capacity of other spouse)
- parties’ ages and health
- marital misconduct (many jxdns preclude this as a factor; some consider adultery in particular when determining support)
- children (future responsibilities)
spousal support:
what does the party seeking modification have the burden to show?
party seeking modification must show that there has been a significant and continuing change in circumstances in either:
* the recipient’s needs OR
* the payor’s financial abilities (voluntary income reduction does not count)
spousal support \ modification:
what factors may affect modification?
- death (estate usually not obligated)
- remarriage (payor: court may modify; recipient: court may terminate)
- retirement (some deny mod., some grant mod., some consider reason for ret.)
-
cohabitation
* how long?
* jointly contribute to HH $?
* both support children of other?
* how much do they support each other?
* held out to be married, and for how long?)
court jxdn:
what is usually the residency requirement range for SMJ?
6 weeks - 2 years
* AND full faith and credit applies if one spouse is a res for that period of time
what are the equity powers granted to matrimonial courts?
- divide property
- order divorce or annulment
- issue orders re child custody
- order spousal and child support
- award atty’s fees
- enforce separation agreements
etc…
what is a split domicile?
when court has jxdn over one party but not the other
what is an ex parte divorce? when is this option available to the court?
an ex parte divorce would only allow the court to determine marital status.
available when court doesn’t have PJ over both spouses (only one). such a court cannot issue orders on property division, spousal support, or child custody or support
when is a collateral attack on jxdn available, and what must the D show?
D spouse can attack an ex parte order for lack of jxdn
can show that P spouse was not domiciled in the divorcing state
what rights to indigent parties have in matrimonial court?
no right to legal counsel
but court CAN award atty’s fees and costs if one party is indigent
child support:
usually until what age?
what are the exceptions?
usually until 18 yo
three exceptions:
* if child is in high school full time when they reach age of majority, can be extended until they are 19
* if child’s physical or mental condition requires support past age of 18
* through college (depending on state) BUT contingent on child complying w reasonable parent demands
child support is entirely separate from which rights?
visitation rights: visitation cannot be denied because the payor failed to pay child support