Family Law Flashcards
Ceremonial (Statutory) Marriage Requirements
license & solemnization (ceremony)
Marriage License Requirements
- capacity to marry/meet minimum age requirement (most states - 18, if under 18 most states allow with parental consent)
- waiting period between license application and date of issuance or ceremony (most states require waiting period between license issuance and ceremony)
- premarital medical testing - some states mandate but cannot be condition for issuing license
- Expiration date - varies from 10-30 days
When marriage license WILL NOT be issued
- Bigamy
- Consanguinity
- Sham
- Incapacity (incapable of understanding act, one or both under influence, lack of consent due to duress, fraud)
Solemnization Requirements
- Most states require at least 2 witnesses
- Most states require an officiant
*file license with appropriate gov office
*proxy marriage - a stand in at the ceremony (military deployment)
Common-law Marriage Requirements
Abolished by most states.
1. parties agree they are married/consent
2. cohabitation
3. conduct - holds themselves out in public as married
4. Legal/Mental capacity - of age, not too closely related, understands
Intent is evidenced by words in the present tense - “we are married”
No states have minim time period of cohabitation
Heartbalm Action
Civil suit for money damages based on the damage jilted party’s reputation - ABOLISHED in most states, assume it is on exam
Historically included:
- breach of promise to marry
- alienation of affection
- seduction
- criminal conversation
3 ways marriage can be terminated
- annulment
- divorce
- death
Annulment
Judicial decree that voids a marriage as it having never been valid
2 Types of Annulment
- Void Marriage - treated as if it never happened, not legally recognized
- Voidable Marriage - valid until judicial decree dissolves marriage
Grounds for VOID marriage
Grounds:
- prior existing marriage
- incest
- mental capacity
Grounds for VOIDABLE marriage
Grounds:
- age
- impotence
- intoxication
- fraud
- duress
- lack of intent
Equitable Distribution of Property in Annulment
party can request equitable distribution of property, spousal and child support, custody, attorney’s fee and other costs related to dissolution of marriage
Defenses against VOID Marriage
only defense is to deny existence of the impediment → makes it voidable
Defenses against VOIDABLE Marriage
equitable defenses of:
1. unclean hands
2. laches
3. estoppel
Putative Marriage/Spouse Doctrine
party who participated in a ceremonial marriage and believes in food faith that marriage is valid may use a state’s divorce provisions even if the marriage is later found to be void (meant to protect innocent spouse)
- adopted by most jurisdictions
Divorce
A legal dissolution of marriage;
can be No-Fault or Fault divorce
Most states have residency requirement (at least one party must be resident of the state)
Length of residency varies and may depend on whether:
- couple married in that state OR
- grounds for divorce happened in that state
Grounds for NO-FAULT Divorce
Marriage is irretrievably broken and there is no prospect of reconciliation
Irreconcilable differences must exist for a specific period of time prior to the filing of divorce action
1/2 states require parties to be separated for period of time
Most states have abolished traditional defenses to divorce.
One spouse who wants to reconcile cannot prevent dissolution
Grounds for FAULT based Divorce
Mainly used to determine support, most jurisdictions retain some fault-based grounds, some have removed it completely.
- Adultery (had opportunity and the inclination)
- Cruelty (course of conduct, makes cohabitation unsafe/improper; most juris look for physical harm, only some allow emotional abuse/cruelty)
- Desertion (one spouse voluntarily leaves marital home, permanent; some juris find desertion when spouse forced out and fear of harm if return)
- Habitual drunkeness (frequent intoxication causes impariment in marriage; alcoholism not required)
- Bigamy (knowingly entered into prior legal marriage; most juris ground for annulment & divorce)
- Imprisonment (specified period of time)
- Indignity (negative behavior, renders spouses condition intolerable/life burdensome; majority of states DO NOT recognize)
- Institutionalization for insanity (no reasonable prospect of discharge/rehab)
Defenses to FAULT based divorce
must be affirmatively pleaded
- Recrimination - both spouses commit a marital wrongful act of like conduct
- Unclean hands - common, P’s own behavior is in question
- Connivance - gave consent to participate in marital wrong
- Condonation - forgave, knowledge of wrongful act, resume marital relations (at CL, once forgiven, cannot be grounds)
- Collusion - both parties have conspired to fabricate grounds for divorce (rare since there’s no-fault divorce)
- Provocation - misconduct due to something other spouse is doing
- Insanity - does not know diff between right/wrong, can’t understand
- Consent - consented to desertion/adultery
- Justification - one spouse leaves because of other’s misconduct
- Religion - will fail in ALL jurisdictions
Limited Divorce
legal separation where parties live apart, allowing courts to determine support/prop division
widely recognized, rarely used
Separate Maintenance
Party asking for support even though parties live together
Finalizing Divorces
once granted, many states do not finalize until certain period has elapsed
Mediation
Requires neutral court appointed mediator who is unbiased and not connected with either party.
Mediator can assist with child support, custody, visitation, parenting time
Result = settlement agreement submitted to court, if approved, incorporated into final divorce judgment
Community Property
only 9 states use, minority
Requires EQUAL division of marital property
Equitable Distribution
Most states use
fair distribution of marital property, not necessarily equal
Marital Property
most states - ALL property acquired DURING marriage
some states - all property owned by either spouse
burden of proof is on party asserting property is nonmarital
- gifts between spouses are marital property
- increases in the value of separate property resulting from either spouse’s effort is marital property
- improvement due to marital property funds is also marital property
In most states, property acquired by one spouse after separation but before divorce decree is marital property.
Nonmarital Property (Separate Property)
- Property acquired before marriage
- Gift and inheritance
- Property acquired after divorce (some states - after separation)
- Property excluded by valid agreement
- Any award or settlement payment received for CoA/claim that accrued BEFORE marriage, regardless of when payment received
- Property that party has sold, granted, conveyed for value in good faith before date of final separation
- Property that was mortgaged/encumbered in good faith before final separation
Factors for distribution of marital property
- length of marriage
- prior marriages
- age
- health
- earnings/earning potential
- liabilities
- needs of both spouses
- contributions to education or career advancement of other spouse
- needs for future acquisitions
- income, medical needs, retirement of both spouses
- value of any separate property
- Economic circumstance of each spouse at divorce
- Custodianship of minor children
- standard of living
- homemaking, child rearing services
Professional License or Degree - marital property or not?
Majority - not distributable, but can affect alimony or distribution of marital assets
Spousal reimbursement
court may reimburse a spouse for amounts that spouse contributed to the other spouse’s education (“cost value approach”)
Retirement / Pension Benefits - marital property or not?
considered marital property and subject to equitable distribution if acquired during marriage
Courts look at CURRENT value of pension, not future value
TIMING OF PENSION important - it is often both marital/nonmarital because it started prior to marriage and the portion that accrued prior to marriage is nonmarital
Personal Injury Claim Proceeds - marital property or not?
If CoA occurred during marriage → marital property (even if proceeds are received after divorce) *some states
Separate and marital allocation approach (depends on nature of award)
- pain and suffering, disability → SEPARATE property of INJURED spouse
- lost wages, income, medical expenses, if award attributable from time of accident ot the end of marriage → marital
- lost wages, income, medical expenses, if award attributable after termination of marriage → separate
- consortium losses → SEPARATE property of NONINJURED spouse
Goodwill of business - marital property or not?
Refers to reputation/clientele of professional practice - Considered marital property if it is developed during the marriage, must be part of business and independent of the individual *some states