Fact Pattern 4: Shareholders Flashcards
Do shareholders manage the corporation?
No. Directors manage the corporation. However, in a close corporation, the shareholders will run the corporation.
What are the characteristics for a close corporation?
- few shareholders; and
2. stock not publically traded.
How can management be set up in a close corporation?
Can be a board of directors, and run like a normal corporation. Or can eliminate the board and have shareholders run the business and appoint a manager.
What is a shareholder management agreement? What must be done to make sure it is binding though?
Sets up alternative management. Two ways to do this:
1. In the articles and approved by all shareholders; or
2. by unanimous written shareholder agreement.
Must put the agreement conspicuously on the front and back of stock certificates. However, if it is not done it will not invaliditate the agreement, it will simply make life easier.
Do shareholders owe the other shareholders a fiduciary duty?
yes, in a close corporation. A closed corporation is similar to a partnership and the duty is of utmost good faith.
What happens if there is oppression of minority shareholders?
Minority can sue the majority shareholders for breach of fiduciary duty. Courts allow this because a majority can deny any voice to the minority, fire them from employment, refuse to declare dividends, and refuse to buy minorities stock. Therefore, when discussing oppression of the minority, remember:
- Breach of fiduciary duty; and
- Inability to escape.
Can licensed professionals start a close corporation?
Yes. Lawyers, doctors, CPA, etc. can start a professional corporation, which must have P.C. or P.A. in the name.
Are shareholders liable for corporate obligation or shareholder torts?
No.
Can shareholders be liable for corporate debts?
No. The corporation is liable for its own debts.
What type of corporations can a plaintiff pierce the corporate veil?
Close corporations only.
What is required for a court to pierce the corporate veil and hold the shareholders responsible?
- They must have abused the privilege of incorporation; and
- Fairness must require holding them liable.
If the court wants to pierce the corporate veil due to an “alter ego,” what must it find?
- Shareholder abused the privilege of incorporation;
- Fairness must require piercing;
- Was the shareholder using the corporation like an alter ego of himself? I.E. paying personal bills, commingling personal and corporate property, etc.?
Then yes.
The main examination is what are the identities of interests.
What is undercapitalization as it applies to piercing the corporate veil?
Shareholders failed to invest enough money to cover prospective liability and it would be unfair to give them limited liability due to this underfunding.
What is a shareholder derivative suit?
A shareholder is suing to enfore the corporations claim, not her own personal claim. Its a case where the corporation is not pursuing its own claim, so a shareholder stops in to prosecute on the corporations behalf.
Hypo: S, a shareholder of corp. sues the board for breaching the duty of care or loyalty. Is this derivative?
Yes. Because the corporation could sue. The duties owed to the corporation have been violated.
If the shareholder wins the derivative suit, who is entitled to what?
The corporation gets the money from the judgment.
The shareholder plaintiff recovers costs and attorneys’ fees.
If the shareholder loses the derivative suit, who is entitled to what?
Shareholder cannot recover attorneys’ fees or costs. Shareholder can also be liable for the costs and attorney fees of the defendant, if the suit was without reasonable cause.
What are required for a shareholder to maintain a derivative suit?
- Stock ownership at the time the claim arose and throughout the suit;
- Shareholder must provide adequate representation to the corporations best interests;
- Shareholder must make written demand on corporation that the corporation bring the suit. In some states the demand is required and must wait 90 days post-demand to sue, others allow for shareholder to skip this step if the demand would be futile (suing board);
- The corporation joined as a defendant, even though it is the corporations claim, it is still a defendant.
Can the parties settle a derivative suit?
Only with court approval.
When will a derivative suit be dismissed by a corporation?
Upon an independent investigation that concluded that the suit is not in the corporations best interests. Court will examine the following in deciding whether dismissal is warranted:
- Those recommending dismissal were truly independent; and
- They made a reasonable investigation.
Who is allowed to vote in shareholder meetings?
Outstanding stock. Outstanding stock is the stock that are issued but not reacquired.