Expectations and monetary policy Flashcards
In general, when talking about the question of unemployment, decrease in the policy rate and long-term interest rate how do they operate?
do not operate in a vacuum
The Response of Output to a Monetary Expansion: Predictions from 10 Models
output will increase for some time in response to a monetary expansion
–> the size and the length of the output response is large
IMF, OECD: definition
The IMF (International Monetary Fund) and the OECD (Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development) serve distinct roles but often work in tandem to promote economic stability and growth worldwide
models to predict the response of monetary expansion
3 are used by central banks
4 are international organizations (IFRM and OECD)
Should uncertainty about the effects of policy lead policymakers to do less?
yes, uncertainty should lead policymakers to exercise caution and potentially do less
Does the Fed know the exact value of the natural rate of unemployment ?
No, Fed does not know any of these things with certainty
What is the natural rate of unemployment?
The natural rate of unemployment is the level of unemployment that exists when the economy is at full capacity, not influenced by cyclical factors.
Why is it important for the Fed to consider the range of responses from different models when adjusting policy rates?
The range of responses indicates uncertainty about the effects of policy changes, which can significantly impact economic outcomes
What potential risks are associated with making aggressive policy rate changes based on uncertain outcomes?
Aggressive changes can lead to unintended consequences, such as excessive inflation or further economic instability, if the predicted effects do not materialize.
How does uncertainty in economic models affect the decision-making process of policymakers?
Uncertainty can lead policymakers to adopt more conservative approaches to avoid risks associated with unpredictable outcomes
What is a safer alternative for policymakers when faced with uncertainty about economic responses?
A safer alternative is to implement smaller, incremental changes to policy rates rather than large adjustments.
–> fine tuning
Multiplicative uncertainty: definition
type of uncertainty where the effects of certain variables or parameters can compound or multiply, leading to a broader range of possible outcomes
This uncertainty should lead policymakers to be what ?
- cautious
-to limit the use of policies
The higher unemployment or the higher inflation.. the more ?
the more active the policies should be
Fine-tuning
refers to the practice of making small adjustments to economic policy measures with the goal of achieving specific targets, such as constant levels of unemployment or stable output growth
Why are the effects of macroeconomic policy uncertain (another reason) ?
the interaction of policy and expectations
Methods of optimal control
to determine the best possible way to influence a dynamic system over time to achieve a desired outcome. It involves selecting a control policy or strategy that minimizes or maximizes a certain objective, often subject to constraints.
Why have economists moved away from the methods of optimal control in macroeconomic policy?
Economists have shifted their perspective, realizing that the economy is fundamentally different from a machine, as it involves strategic interactions among people and firms that respond to both current and expected future policies.
What are the new way of the thinking about macro policy ?
game theory
game theory : definition
a game between the policymakers and “the economy” more concretely, the people and firms in the economy
Game theory is not what ?
not a “entertainment”
–> It’s a strategic interaction between players
who are the player ?
- policymaker
- people
- firms
Why do governments refuse to negotiate with hostage takers?
To deter hostage taking by making it unattractive; negotiation would encourage future incidents.
What happens if a government negotiates after a hostage is taken?
It undermines their policy, leading hostage takers to expect negotiations and increase hostage situations.
What is the best policy regarding negotiations with hostage takers?
Governments should commit not to negotiate at all to prevent hostage taking
pi = pi e - alpha (u- un)
pi e = expected inflation
u = actual unemployement rate
un = natural unemployment rate
alpha : the coefficient of the effect of unemployment on inflation and expected inflation
What is the relationship between inflation and unemployment according to the derived equation?
Inflation depends on expected inflation and the difference between actual unemployment and the natural unemployment rate; higher unemployment leads to lower inflation, while lower unemployment leads to higher inflation
Achieving zero inflation and an unemployment rate equal to the natural rate, what does it show ?
not a bad outcome
–> would seem the Fed can do even better
What is time inconsistency in the context of the Fed’s policy?
Time inconsistency occurs when the Fed can improve outcomes by deviating from its announced zero-inflation policy, leading to higher expected inflation and ultimately higher actual inflation.
How can the Fed achieve better outcomes regarding inflation and unemployment?
The best policy is for the Fed to commit credibly not to lower unemployment below the natural rate, which helps maintain zero inflation and natural unemployment.
How can a central bank credibly commit to its announced policy?
- idenpendance of currently elected politcians
- give incentives to the central bankers to take the long view
- appoint a “conservative” central banker
What are some legal measures a central bank can adopt to prevent time inconsistency?
Legal measures include defining a simple monetary rule, such as maintaining a constant money growth rate, or implementing a hard peg to foreign interest rates.
independent central bank: definition
a central bank where interest rate and money supply decisions are made independent of the influence of currently elected politicians
What are the advantage when a central bank is independent ?
makes it easier for the central bank to resist political pressure to decrease unemployment below the natural rate of unemployment
If the bank focus on a long term view it what are the advantage ?
take into account the long run cost of higher inflation
–> long horizon : f ocus on achieving stable, sustainable economic outcomes rather than aiming for quick, short-term results
appoint a “conservative” central banker what does it mean ?
is someone who has a strong preference for keeping inflation low, even if that means sometimes accepting higher unemployment
Advantage of conservative central banker ?
When the economy is at the natural rate, such a central banker will be less tempted to embark on a monetary expansion. Thus, the problem of time inconsistency will be reduced.
What were more the trend for central bank the last two decades ?
Central banks have been given more independence from governments
Central bankers have been given long terms in office
Inflation and Central Bank Independence (Across OECD countries): impact
the higher the degree of central bank independence, the lower the rate of inflation.
What immediate effect do tax cuts have on the economy?
Tax cuts lead to lower taxes today, which increases demand and may boost output in the short term
What is the long-term consequence of tax cuts that are not offset by reduced government spending?
They result in larger budget deficits and the potential need for tax increases in the future
Why might politicians find tax cuts tempting if voters are shortsighted?
Politicians may cut taxes to gain immediate voter approval, knowing that shortsighted voters may not consider future consequences like increased debt.
How might shortsighted voter behavior influence election-related economic policies?
Politicians may increase aggregate demand before elections to lower unemployment and stimulate growth temporarily, aiming to win voter favor.