Exceptions to the Warrant Flashcards
What are the exceptions for making an arrest without a warrant
- PC that the person has committed a felony and is in public
1a. Or if you are in your home and you give them consent - The person is committied a misdemeanor and you have PC to believe they won’t be apprehended unless you arrest them immediately OR they will cause harm to people (have to see it)
2a. The person has committed a misdemeanor in officers presence
T or F: A custodial arrest is reasonable if the officer has PC of criminal violation
True (even for traffic violations)
United States v Watson
Facts: Informant told police that D had a stolen credit card and setup a meeting with D so police could observe. D was arrested and found the credit cards
Holding: Police had PC to believe that D had committed a felony, so warrantless arrest was okay
T or F: Can deadly force be used to prevent the escape of a felon if they don’t think it’s necessary to prevent the suspect from escaping AND PC that they pose a threat to others
No
What are deadly force requirements
Necessary to prevent escape AND PC that they pose a threat to others
What are the Factors of the Graham Balancing Test for deadly force
- Severity of the crime
- Whether suspect poses an immediate threat to officers or others
- Whether D is actively resisting arrest or attempting to evade arrest by flight
Scott v Harris
Facts: D was driving “erraticly” through the streets driving away from cops
Holding: Deadly force was justified
Counter: Using the graham balancing test you could argue that he doesn’t meet factors of Severity of crime (this was a traffic violation) or posing a threat to others
What are the exceptions for the Warrant requirement
- arrests
- Stop and Frisks
- Search Incident to Arrest
- Plain View and Plain Touch
- Automobiles
- Exigent Circumstances
- Special Needs
- Consent to Search
Can an officer immediately after knocking and announcing and not hearing any response in 10 seconds storm in?
No, it has to be within a reasonable time
What is a purpose of the Knock and Announce rule
protects against needless destruction of property
protects individuals privacy interest
Gerstein v Pugh
Facts: D was arrested without a warrant and help for a month before PC screening
Holding: holding someone for 30 days was a violation…NEED PROMPT screening
After arresting someone without a warrant, police need to go to magistrate to determine if there was PC
Payton v New York
Facts: Police had PC to believe D committed a murder but no warrant. Police knocked and announced and got no response, so they used a crowbar to open the door
Holding: Unconstitutional, exception to the warrant requirement for public arrests DOESNT extend to arrest in the home (absent exigent circumstances)
If officers don’t have a warrant and knock and announce at your hotel room and you don’t answer, can they bust in?
No - Payton v New York rule
If a suspect lives with a 3rd party or is a visitor at a 3rd parties home, will an arrest/search warrant suffice
YES
Terry v Ohio
Courts use a balancing test to determine what is reasonable. Need reasonable suspicion that criminal activity is afoot or RS that the person is armed and dangerous
When can officers stop someone
When there is RS that criminal activity is afoot
When can officers frisk someone
When they have RS that they are armed and dangerous
What is a the downside of a stop and frisk
it can impact minorities greatly, because it gives alot of discretion to the officers
Pennsylvania v Mimms
Bright line Rule: Ordering people out of their vehicles
Holding: Officers in a course of a legal stop of automobile have an AUTOMATIC right to order someone out of their vehicle
Can officers in the course of a legal stop of an automobile, order the passengers out of the vehicle?
Yes; officer safety is a concern
Officers (can or cannot) perform a frisk of a passenger, when the driver has been lawfully detained?
Can, if they have RS that the passenger is armed and dangerous