Exam deck Flashcards
Dispute Resolutions are based on:
Power (money/ better lawyers)
Rights (what does the law recognize)
Interests (What are the parties concernes & What is motivating the conflict)
The types of dispute resolution
- Negotiation (w/out lawyers)
- Negotiation (w/ lawyers)
- Mediation (facilitated by neutral)
- Early neutral eval (neutral evaluates rather than facilitates)
More types of dispute res
Judicial settlement conf (FRCP 16: A judge can give/ ask about mediation during the pretrial conference and give his evaluation of each party’s case in order to bring the parties to settlement)
- Summary jury trial (brief hearing in front of jury that reaches an advisory verdict) (Lawyers may ask jurors questions about why they reached their verdict
- Arbitration [non-binding] (Arb that ends in an award that can be rejected in favor of a trial) (Sometimes, if an award is rejected but the rejecting party does not do better at trial, that party can be made to pay other’s court costs)
Even more res types
Binding Arbitration (just like it sounds) Admin. adjudication (administrative law courts with ALJs that hear cases between the public and an agency Private trial (A public judge allows the parties to select a private judge... private judge uses a public courtroom, hears the case, and issues findings of fact etc.) Public trials (both bench and jury) Online dr
Motives behind ADR movement
- Saving time &money
- Using “better processes- more open
- Achieving “better” results - outcomes that servve the “real needs” of the participants
- Enhancing community involvement in dispute res.
- Broadening access to justice (if someone can’t afford a good lawyer)
- Protecting turf for oneself, an institution, or a profession
Characteristics of arbitration
- . Can be binding or non-binding
- Not regulated and does not require cert.
- Based on contract
3 types of arb
Labor management (national labor relations act (NLRA) Commercial (Federal Arb act - FAA) International NY Convention (and FAA)
7 key elements of the arb agreement
- Consent
- Institution & Rules
- Scope of the dispute
- Seat of arbitration (what geographical place the arb happens)
- choice of law
- procedural law
- national court that will aid and annul - Language
- Medhot of appointment, number of arbs, & qualifications
- Choice of law
- Contract
- Arb agreement
Separability doctrine
- Allows vacation of arb award where there was corruption, partiality, or other misconduct by the arb, or where the arb exceeded the scope of his or her authority
- Any challenge to arb must be brought against the arb provision specifically (not the larger contract)
- The arb provision is treated as a separate contract
- Did the party’scontract challenge mention the arb provision specifically?
- Any challenge to the validity of the agreement as a whole is for the arbitrator to decide
Defenses to enforcement of arb agreements
- State (common) law defenses found in contract law
- Fraud
- Duress
- Mistake
- Lack of capacity
- Unconscionability (the contract is so one-sided the court will not enforce it)
Characteristics of unconscionability
- It would be unjust to enforcement the agreement due to imbalance
- Either procedural or substantive
- Procedural
- Oppression through unequal bargaining- Surprise hidden in terms
- Substantive
- Harsh or one-sided (i.e. cost of arb, confidentiality provision)
Fraud may be shown only by:
Clear and convincing evidence-
Materially related to an issue in the arb
Nor have been discoverable by prior due diligence
Non-statutory ground for vacating (an arb award)
- Manifest disregard for the law (award contradicted clearly controlling law)
- Award is contrary to public policy
- Award is arbitrary & capricious (given to sudden changed in behavior/mood)
- Award is irrational
New York Convention
- An intn’l treaty that seeks to overcome judicial hostility to intn’l arb of commercial dispute
- Establishes presumptive validity (party rejecting enforccement of the agreement has the burden of showing that the arbitral clause is not valid)
- Annulment of an arbitral award is governed by the law of the seat of the arbitration
Negotiation
-No 3rd party… simply bargaining
-