Exam Flashcards
What is arnsteins ladder of participation?
It is a typology of 8 levels of citizen participation and no participation. Citizen participation is a process which provides individuals with an opportunity to influence government decision and has long been a component of the democratic decision-making process. For illustrative purposes, the eight types of participation are arranged in a ladder pattern with each rung corresponding to the extent of citizens power in determining the end product.
What are the 8 levels of participation
- Citizen control - Geniun Participation
- Delegate power - Geniun Participation
- Partnership - Geniun Participation
- Placation - Geniun Participation/ higher level of tokenism
- Consultation - Tokenism
- Informing - Tokenism
- Therapy - Non-participation
- Manipulation - Non-participation
What is manipulation and therapy on the ladder of participation?
Levels of non-participation that have been contrived by some to substitute for genuine participation. The real objective is not to enable people to participate, but to enable power holders to educate or “cure” participants.
What is informing and consultation on the ladder of participation?
Levels of tokenism that allow have-nots to hear and have a voice.
When they are proffered by power holders as the total extent of participation, the citizen may indeed hear and be heard but under these conditions there lack power to ensure their views will be heeded by the power. When restricted to these levels there will be no follow throguh hence no assurance of change to the status quo.
What is placation on the ladder of participation?
Higher level of tokenism
Ground rules allow have-nots to advise, but retain power holders the right to decide
What is partnership on the ladder of participation?
Enable them to negotiate and engage in trade-offs with traditional power holders
What is delegate powers and citizen control on the ladder of participation?
Have not citizens obtain the majority of decision making seats or full managerial power
What is the tragedy of the commons?
A term used to describe a situation in a shared resource system where individual users acting independently according to their own self-interest behave contrary to the common good of all users by depleting or spoiling that resource through their collective action.
What is a real-life example of the tragedy of the commons?
Grand Bank Fisheriers
Fishing grounds off Newfoundland. For centuries the area was described to have an endless supply of cod fish. In the 1960/70’s advances in fishing enabled huge catches of cod. Following a few seasons, ths fish population dropped dramatically, forcing fishermen to sail out further. By 1990, the cod population was so low Grand Bank fishing industry collapsed. Scientist doubt it will ever recover.
What is the tragedy in the tragedy of the commons?
The tragedy is that no one can win. The destiny of the tragedy is inevitable, a human cannot escape the perpetual conflict over natural resources.
What is the paradox in the tragedy of the commons?
Paradox is that short-term profits or gains have detrimental long term consequences that are destructive to all who share interests in the commons.
Personal gain vs collective - if its a common shoulder we all have equal accesss?
What is first order change?
- Ameliorative: minor shifts within the existing structure
- Alters, rearranges and replaces the perceived problem
- Example: Counselling the homeless to address homelessness
What is second order change?
- Transformative: Change of the system itself
- Does not assume existing structure is correct
- Example: Address homelessness through changing the systems that put them at risk
List the different approaches to social change?
- Community Coalition
- Alternative Setting
- Community Development
- Consciousness Rating
- Social Action
- Organizational Consulting
What is community coalitions?
- A community issue is addressed through the collective actions of a range of community representatives
- Increase resources, diversity, healthy communities
What is consciousness rating?
The activity of seeking to make people more aware of a personal, social or political issue
What is social action?
- Action toward social reform
- Identified specific obstacles to the empowerment of specific groups
- Creates a constructive conflict to these obstacles through non-violent means
- Involves power and conflict
What is organization/community consultation?
- Professionals working as consultants to make policy, structural or political changes
- Second order change
- Any of the following: Needs analysis, focus group interviews
What is community development?
- Concerned with increasing community resources
- Both tangible (health facilities) and intangible (social capital)
What is alternative settings?
- Are those spaces which provide a different space for community engagement, interaction, and critically for needs to be met.
- Provides support mechanisms or service options to the individuals outside the ‘mainstream’ provision.
- Self help, community gardens, health buses
What is a context?
- Refers to all facets which influence an individuals experience
- Influences us and we influence it
What is a worldview?
- A view or perspective on the world or the universe
- Reflected in our beliefs and assumptions
- Shape how we view society
- Shapes our behaviours
What is modernism?
- World is ‘knowable’
- Empirical methods adopted to test and defeine thruth
- The process enable fallible beliefs to be rejected and objective thruths to be identified
- Value free
What is a dominant culture?
- A group who maintain a relative position of power over others
- Unearned privilage
- Holder power and resource over other
- Offered opportunitys others are not
What is the social “other”?
- Those who are not apart of dominant culture
- Position of disadvantage
- Denied access
- Determained by dominant culture