Exam #4 Flashcards
Public Accountability (4)
1) Freedom of Information Act(FOIA)
- Exceptions: national security, confidential info., comm./financial info, criminal investigation
2) Government Sunshine Act
- Except: Rulemaking
3/4) Reg. Flexibility Act + Small Business Regulation Enforcement Fairness Act
Blurring of Boundaries between Government and Industry
1) Enabling Legislation
- Delaware Corp. Code: General incorp., Ultra Vires, Intercorp stock ownership
2) Fuel/Recipe
- Lobbying = 1st amendment
- Revolving Door = working @gov then corp over and over
Kefauer - Harris Amendments
- Enabling Legislation
- Preg. women drugs, born w/ no limbs = Created clinical trials
- Clinical bias + Publication bias
FDA Modernization Act
- Enabling Legislation
- Direct-to-Consumer Drug Ads
- U.S. only country
- Off Label detailing, Guidelines
Non Prosecution Agreements(NPA) / Deferred Prosecution Agreement(DPA)
- Enabling Legislation
- Merck’s Vioxx agreement
Revolving Door Examples
- Scott Gottlies = FDA = Pfizer
- Steve Hahn = FDA = Moderna
- Robert Califf = FDA = Google Health = FDA
- Alex Azar = HHS = Eli Lily
- Julie Gerberding = CPC = Merck
- Curtis Wright = FDA = Purdue
Title VII of Civil Rights Act
1) Protected Classes
- Race + Gender + Religious age + Elderly + Disability + Sexual Orientation + Transgender
2) Procedure
- EEOC
Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC)
1) File EEOC Claim
2) EEOC Action/ EEOC No Action
3) File Lawsuit
4) Remedies
- Reinstatement, Lost Wages, Compensatory Damages, Punitive Damages
Intentional Discrimination
1) PI Makes “Prima Facie” Case
- Protected Class, Qualified, Rejected, Non-Protected Class hired
2) Employer offers valid reason
3) PI Prove “Pretext”
Unintentional Discrimination/Disparate Impact
Firemen Test, women couldn’t pick up a 200 lbs person and carry it so they had to change it
Religious Discrimination
1) Sincerely held religious beliefs
2) Reasonable Accommodation
- Sabbath, Dress code, Prayer schedule, food/dietary
Sexual Harassment
1) Quid Pro Quo
- “This for that”
2) Hostile Work environment
- Multiple instances + Unwanted sexual advances/instances
- Roberts v. Mike’s Towing
Roberts v. Mike’s Towing
- Sexual Harassment: Hostile Work Environment
- Sextratary + Kiss + Hug
Title VII Retaliation
- Moralez-Cruz v. University of Puerto Rico
Moralez-Cruz v. University of Puerto Rico
- Got her year extra year of tenure research published revoked because she didn’t report her colleague smashing a student and said it was unprofessional
- She sued saying it was sexual harassment
- Still lost because wasn’t right
Title VII Defenses
1) Business Necessity
2) Bonafied Occupational Qualification
3) Seniority Systems
4) After acquired evidence of misconduct
5) Lack of Discriminatory Motive
- Dees v. United Rentals
Dees v. United Rentals
- Title VII defenses: Lack of discrimintory motive, he was just shit at his job and never changed the batteries so he was fired after many warnings
Americans with Disabilities Act
1) Reasonable Accommodation unless undue hardship
- Physical/Mental impairment + Substantially limits 1 or more major life activities
- Ex: Obesity + Alcoholism + HIV Status
Affirmative Action
1) Federal Law Permits, but does not require
- CA + TX + FL + WA = Illegal
Labor Law: What events sparked the laws?
1) Haymarket
- Chicago 1800’s
2) Homestead
- Bad Steelwork condition + Strike + Killed all the strikers
3) Pullman
- Strike
4) Great Depression
Labor Law: National Labor Relations Act
- No Unfair Labor Practices
A) Cannot stop unionization
B) Cannot discriminate against members
C) Cannot retaliate against members
D) Engage in good-faith bargaining
Labor Law: Impose
1) Strike
2) Company can replace
3) If not replaced, must hire you back
Labor Management Reporting & Disclosure Act
- Service Employees International Union v. National Union of Healthcare Workers
- Put into place because the mob ran most the unions and people we’re afraid to speak against the mob, so gave an avenue to speak to the government instead
Sherman Antitrust Act: Section 1
1) Agreements in Restraint of trades
- Pack of dogs
2) Horizontal Restraints
A) Price fixing = Per Se
B) Group boycott = Per Se
C) Market Allocation = Per Se
D) Trade Association = ROR
3) Vertical Restraints
A) Territorial Distribution Agreements = ROR –> Quality Control
B) Resale Price Maintenance Agreement = ROR –> Product Reputation
Rule of Reason (ROR)
1) Purpose
2) Market-ability to implement
3) Effect on competition
4) Availability of less restrictive means
Sherman Antitrust Act: Section 2
No Monopoly/Attempt Monopoly
1) Monopoly Power
- Dominate Share + Relevant Market + Anti Competition Coduct
2) Attempted Monopoly
- Anti Competitive Conduct + Intent to exclude + Dangerous possibility of success
Ex: Weyerhauser v. Ross-Simmons
3) International Monopoly
- Dominate market share + Transact in + outside U.S. + Substantial effect on U.S. market
Clayton Act: Section 2
A) Price Discrimination…Except
- Bulk, Price Discount, Market Fluctuation
Clayton Act: Section 3
A) Exclusionary Practices
- Exclusive Dealings
- Tying Arrangement = Batson v. Live Nation Entertainment