Exam 3 Flashcards
Credit
transactions in which goods are sold, services are rendered, or money is loaned in exchange for a promise to repay the debt at some future date
Unsecured Credit
a service was rendered or good sold and the consumer or debtor promises to pay for the service or good later (upon receiving a bill)
garnishment
make employer pay creditor part of debtor’s wages
attachment
seize debtor’s stuff – assets, bank accounts
A debt is “secured” if it is backed either:
by a pledge of another person (in addition to the debtor) to pay or
by a contract giving the creditor an interest in property (collateral) that helps ensure financial confidence
Security Devices:
- Surety or Guarantor
- Lien
- Mortgage
Surety/Guarantor
a person who agrees to be liable for the debt of someone else. (i.e. ththe guarantor will pay the debt if the debtor fails to pay it)
Sureties and guaranty contracts must be
written (not oral).
Artisan’s lien (also called a “possessory lien”)
Basic idea – if you fixed something for a customer, and your customer didn’t pay the bill, you can hold onto that thing you fixed until the customer pays.
Two essential elements of Artisan’s lien (also called a “possessory lien”):
- possession by improver/provider of services of goods that they improved/provided services concerning; and
- a debt created by the improvement to goods or provision of services concerning the goods
lien
is a security interest in personal property available to businesses and individuals by statute and common law
–Statutes provide a procedure for foreclosing the lien (foreclosure), to allow the lienholder to sell the collateral after a period of time if the debtor fails to pay
Security interest
an interest in personal property obtained by a creditor to secure payment or performance of an obligation (i.e. a property interest in the collateral)
Collateral
the property that secures the loan.
What might be collateral for a loan?
Anything the debtor owns that has value…goods, stock, patents, stocks, bank accounts, accounts receivable, inventory…anything
Lien on personal property: 2 steps
- Attachment: So the lien is enforceable against the debtor
- Perfection: So the lien gets in line ahead of other creditors who may take an interest in the collateral
Step 1 – Attachment:
So the lien is enforceable against the debtor
Attachment Requires:
- An agreement signed by debtor that grants the debtor a security interest in the collateral (must describe the collateral),
- Value from the creditor to the debtor, and
- Debtor owns the collateral
Step 2 – Perfection:
So the lien gets in line ahead of other creditors who may take an interest in the collateral.
–Special rule for security interest in cars – in most states, the lien must be noted on the title
Mechanics’ Liens
Statutory systems permit one who furnishes labor or materials to improve real estate to claim a lien on the real estate until they are paid.
Mortgage:
A mortgage is a security interest in real property given by the owner (mortgagor) as security for a debt owed to the creditor (mortgagee).
Example: bank loans you $ to buy your house, and you give bank a mortgage on your house.
— A lien on land
— Must be written
If the debtor does not pay, the bank can use a judicial process to foreclose on the property and sell it to satisfy the debt
Mortgage: If the debtor does not pay, what can the bank do?
- the bank can use a process (usually through the courts) to foreclose on the property (cut off the debtor’s property rights in the property)
- and then sell the property to satisfy the debt
- In most places, if the sale doesn’t cover the whole debt, the debtor still owes the bank for the remaining amount (the deficiency).
- Usually, the debtor has a “right of redemption” – can pay the full amount of the debt/interests/costs within a certain period of time to get the property back.
- – Sometimes even after a new buyer has bought it.
right of redemption
Usually, the debtor has a “right of redemption” – can pay the full amount of the debt/interests/costs within a certain period of time to get the property back.
— Sometimes even after a new buyer has bought it.
What is bankruptcy?
An organized judicial procedure for insolvent debtors and their creditors to sort things out.
– There are various versions: Creditors are usually going to end up getting less than the debtor owes them.
Why do we allow bankruptcy?
The Constitution provides for it
–The bankruptcy laws are contained in federal statute, commonly called the Bankruptcy Code.
Chapter 7 bankruptcy
is liquidation
gather up assets, sell them, use them to pay debts owed to creditors
Chapter 11 bankruptcy
is reorganization (get a court-endorsed plan of reorganization for how much and when creditors will be paid by a debtor business going forward)
Types of Bankruptcy
- Straight bankruptcy (liquidations)
- Reorganizations
- Family farms and commercial fishing operations
- Consumer debt adjustments
Who starts a bankruptcy proceeding?
the debtor or the debtor’s the creditors
Petition:
All bankruptcy proceedings begin by filing a petition, either voluntary (filed by the debtor) or involuntary (filed by the debtor’s creditors, if certain requirements are met)
A voluntary petition
Filed by an individual person, partnership, or corporation to start that person or entity’s bankruptcy.
An involuntary petition
may be filed by creditors of a debtor in an attempt to reach debtor’s assets in lieu of payment on debts
- But no involuntary petition against ranchers, farmers, nonprofits, municipalities, banks, insurance companies
- And for anyone with more than 12 creditors, three of the creditors have to agree to petition for involuntary bankruptcy
Automatic Stay:
Filing a bankruptcy petition operates as an automatic stay, halting creditor action against a debtor or property.
– once the bankruptcy has been filed, the creditors are required by law to leave the debtor alone and let the bankruptcy process take its course
Automatic Stay: Once bankruptcy is filed, creditors must not:
Begin or continue judicial proceedings against the debtor
Act to repossess the debtor’s property;
Act to create, perfect, or enforce a lien against the debtor’s property;
Make dunning calls or
Send bills to the debtor
Chapter 7 Bankruptcy Overview of the Process:
- Petition (voluntary and involuntary)
- Automatic Stay
- Bankruptcy estate and exemptions
- Claims and Distribution
- Discharge
What is the purpose of a Constitution?
- Set up the structure of the government
2. Limit the government’s power
- Set up the structure of the government – Framers made 2 key structural decisions:
- Checks and Balances – 3 branches – each checks the power of the other two
- – Legislative – Art I, Executive – Art II, Judicial – Art III
- – Slows and weakens government - Federalism – distinction between federal government and separate state governments, and the relationship between them
- Limit the government’s power
- Balance federal government power versus state government power
- — Federalism
- Limit federal government power over individuals
- — Individual rights»_space;> Bill of rights
What is a “test case”?
A suit brought specifically for the establishment of an important legal right or principle.
- –The termtest casedescribes acasethatteststhe validity of a particular law
- —Test casesestablish legal rights or principles and thereby serve as precedent for future similarcases. –Stare Decisi
There are 2 big problems to wrestle with in setting up a government…
- Tyranny by the Minority: Some small number of people control the lives of everyone else.
(An inherent problem of monarchy.) - Tyranny by the Majority: The laws created by the majority of people extinguish key freedoms of some smaller group of people
(An inherent problem of democracy – which is why there are some structural safeguards against it.)
Tyranny by the majority:
Potential problem with majority rule – those with majority opinion could dominate and mistreat those with minority views
—Colonists had experienced this as well – particularly sensitive to the problem of tyranny against a religious minority
Tyranny by the majority: Framers made some structural decisions to combat it:
- Bicameral legislature with Senate (2 senators per state) and House (number of reps based on number of people).
- Electoral college (meant to ensure representation from less populated areas and smaller states).
- And…test cases, combined with the Bill of Rights and relative difficulty of amending the federal Constitution, are significant brake on tyranny of the majority
Commerce Clause –
Congress has the power “To regulate Commerce with foreign nations, and among the several states.”
Foreign Commerce (business with foreign nations):
Federal government has the EXCLUSIVE power to regulate foreign commerce (trade embargoes, tariffs, etc.)
Interstate Commerce (business between states)
- State governments cannot pass regulations that interfere with commerce that crosses state lines.
Federal government can regulate commerce that passes between states - “Affectation doctrine” – Federal government can regulate any activity that affects interstate commerce – not just those persons engaged in interstate commerce.
Commerce clause –Application:
Wickard v. Filburn (1942)
- Facts: Federal regulation of wheat production to stabilize wheat prices during WWII. Small farmer challenged it on grounds his crop was not placed in interstate commerce at all (consumed on the farm).
- Question: Is the regulation a permissible exercise of federal legislative power?
- Rule/Result: Regulation is permissible under Commerce Clause as regulating commerce among the states. Regulation upheld.
- Analysis: Rationale was that the farmer’s use of part of his own crop as feed then freed another part of the crop to be used in interstate commerce.
CONSTITUTIONAL LAW: BILL OF RIGHTS – 4 points from your book:
- Basic constitutional rights are not absolute
- Limitation tends to depend on the nature of the competing right or policy
- Part of the point is protection from tyranny by the majority
- They are interpreted over and over in court cases to apply in various contexts
What does the First Amendment protect?
5 freedoms…
- Speech
- Press
- Religion
- Assembly
- Petition
Freedom of Speech
- includes protection of expressive conduct or actions – symbolic speech
- Expression in art is protected.
- protects minority viewpoint from being silenced by majority
- – very often protects speech that expresses view to which many are opposed.
First Amendment Limitations:
Protection has never been afforded to certain classes of speech
- False, lewd, obscene, profane, libelous speech is not always protected
- – “Obscene” judged by “average person, applying contemporary community standards”.
- – FCC limits times when “indecent” or “profane” language can be aired.
- “Fighting words” – words that “inflict injury or tend to incite an immediate breach of the peace” are not protected by First Amendment.
- *Level of protection depends on kind of speech**
Fighting words
words that “inflict injury or tend to incite an immediate breach of the peace” are not protected by First Amendment.
Strict Scrutiny Test (first amendment)
a law that restricts political or noncommercial speech is constitutional only if the restriction is necessary to fulfillment of a compelling government purpose and is the least restrictive means available to achieve that purpose
Citizens united v FEC
- Very important and controversial case from 2009 about political speech by corporations.
- Before the case: corporations could speak politically only through political action committees (PACs) which were limited and subject to regulation.
- After the case (spoiler alert)…corporations are permitted to use unlimited treasury funds for political ads, and may spend unlimited amounts on “independent expenditures” – i.e. spending that is (at least nominally) independent of the candidate
Commercial speech
speech that proposes a commercial transaction (e.g. ads)
- If the commercial speech is misleading or seeks to promote illegal activity, then it gets no First Amendment protection
- – Regulation is ok if it advances a substantial government interest, and is no more restrictive than necessary.
Is it permissible for a news outlet to publish “leaked” top-secret information?
Yes! Pentagon Papers case – NY Times v. US (1971)
Second Amendment:
A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security for a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed
Fifth Amendment – takings clause
nor shall private property be taken for public use, without just compensation
Eminent Domain
the government can take private property for public use if it pays “just compensation”