Exam 3 Flashcards
Exsanguination
Bleed out
Fundamental wrong Animal Rights
Animals are resources/ property
Rights view
What does it mean to have rights?
What is a right?
How do you get one?
Intrinsic value
Values of a individual/ own sake as an end
Moral value
Extrinsic value
Valuable as a means/ tool
Has a use
Ex.fan
Egalitarian (Intrinsic Value)
We are all equal
“Everyone has the same intrinsic value”
Right to respectful treatment
RECOGNIZE intrinsic value
“One must act accordingly”
Rights trump utility
Crime and punishment
Ex. Wrong to kill rich pawn collector
Subjects of life
More than sentience
Sentience
Conscious/alive
Desires/preferences
Beliefs (moral responsibilities, right/wrong)
sense of time/ memory & expectation
ABOUT HUMANS
What is NOT the fundamental wrong in animal rights?
Pain and unhappiness
Counter-intuitive objection to animal rights
They (animals) have equal moral rights
Us as humans have the same level as respects as animals
Animals do not have the same rights as humans but the same strength to respect is the same.
Human belief on animals
Reply:
We believe humans are more important than animals.
Our responses are different when comparing humans and animals
We have different responses, emotions and beliefs it makes a HUGE difference
Reply: intuitions might be mistaken
Objections to animal rights: animals do not have intrinsic value
Reply:
Reply: why not?
What do animals not have that we do have?
Animals are not rational
No language
No beliefs
No sense of time
Objections to animal rights: animals do not have intrinsic value
what is the problem??
Problem of marginal cases
Humans on the margins
Speciesism
Normative ethics
Making moral decisions
How do I decide the right thing to do?
Deontology
“Deon” duty/obligation
Right and wrong not determined by consequences
About past/present & not future
Specify what it is about the ACTION
Obligation 1
“You should study for your exam.”
Moral?
Desire dependent or not?
NOT moral
Desire-Dependent
If you want a good grade. If you want to pass the class then you should study. (Desire)
“If you want x then you should y.”
Meaning of IF
Hypothetical/ conditional
“If you want x then you should y.”
Obligation 2
“You should tell the truth.”
Moral?
Desire dependent or not?
Is Moral
Not desire-dependent
Categorical
“You must tell the truth.”
Cannot be rejected
Rejection to desire
“I don’t want that.”
Reject desire/obligation
“Should” is rejected
Moral motivation
Moral action
What puts you in motion for next step
Desires are motivating