EXAM 2 Flashcards
Postmodern/ social constructionist/ language based models
- Cultural groups develop through conversation
- Individuals/ cultural groups perceive reality differently
- Therapists: no one ‘correct’ reality
- Collaborative, conversational
- Client-directed outcomes
- Non pathological
- 2nd generation
Collaborative language systems
- change process is dialogical > problems dissipate through conversation
- Therapist:
A. Not knowing stance, non expert
B. Embrace client reality: trust
C. Ask conversational questions
D. Listen responsively: affirmation, encouragement, honor
Dominant narrative
- Language used by family to create a story or explanation of problem > tries to explain origin of problem or persistence in family
- How family operates
- How family understands its issues
- What is preventing family from feeling capable in resolving current problems
Solution focus process
ABC
A. Language of family conveyed to therapist
B. Language of family therapist as therapist questions what family says
C. Collaborative language therapist and family co-create
1. Therapist: elicit family dominant narrative
2. Identify exceptions to problems
3. Identify alternative narratives> gaps in dominant narrative
4. Co-create new narratives that utilizes strengths and weaknesses
5. Future focused, goal orientated, brief
Solution focused: techniques
- Miracle questions: “over the course of the night, a miracle happens, and your problem is gone. What’s different for you, feelings, thoughts, behavior?
- Scaling questions: scale from 1 to 10, how would you rate X about your family?
- Exception question: when is there a time you’re not fighting?
- Coping questions: what keeps you going when you’re struggling?
- Compliments to family/ feedback: help reduce anxiety, helps bring conversational tone, reinforces strengths based approach
- Formula first session talk: between first and second session, ask client “observe and describe what happens in your life that you would like to keep happening?”
Solution focused therapy
- Embrace client reality > shift reality to hidden opposite > problem talk to solution talk
A. Ex. Couple who come in, frequently quarrel > shift: draw attention to times when couple does not quarrel, what is different about those times - Solution focused therapy > possibility therapy: shift client attention away from problem to absence of problem, add spiritual component > add strengths
- Techniques from hypnotherapy
- Collaboration: no need for history taking
- Nonpathologizing: no need to understand cause of problem
- Change through dialogue: multiple solutions and no ‘right’ solution
- Directive with solution: client chooses goals, client capable and has ability to construct solutions
Narrative therapy
- Must bring in historical oppression (language, culture, persecution, gender/ses inequities)
- Nonpathologizing:
- No directives > hear clients story > change through conversation
- Deconstructing questions (separation of problem from individual) + unique outcomes = conversation
- Multiple realities
Narrative therapy goals
- Develop new narrative
- New dominate beliefs > respond and cope to current/future issues
- Deconstruct then reconstruct new narrative
- Getting at “why” of problem is elusive, multiple truths
Narrative therapist
- Active listening and questioning
- Facilitates family story, identify dominant beliefs
- Externalizations problems
- Strengths based and empower
Narrative techniques
- Externalize and reframe new narrative using different language
- Ex. “Our son is very rebellious” (parents)
- when rebelliousness takes over, what does it make him do? (Therapist)
Narrative techniques: Tree of life
- Roots
- Ground
- Trunk
- Branches
- Leaves
- Fruits
Limitations of collaborative language systems: social control
- Social control issues
A. Ex. Parent who disciplines child w/ belt
-welfare authorities involved: remind client action is illegal, invite alternatives, goal to end welfare involvement
-citizens protest: therapist cannot approve of behavior > report if mandated,
-if behavior objectionable (not dangerous/ illegal) use deconstructing questions, “ was the method of discipline working? Was child really listening to you?” > open other avenues of conversation
Limitations: strongly held therapist values and beliefs
-normal family development
- Listening nonjudgmental
- If client has abhorrent ideas > how does it happen that this worldview makes sense to the client?
- Rigid set of “correct” life stages not in alignment w/ nonpathologizing stance
- May discount all notions of development
- Norms and stages tempered with respect for clients perceptions/ multiple interpretations
Collaborative language therapy techniques
- Curiosity: open mind, genuine interest, asking questions
- Respect for clients resources: clients goals, client ability to solve problems, clients language
- Engaging questions: invite client into shared discovery
- Affirming/ conveying hope: frequently pointing out clients progress, hard work, courage. Therapist interprets client action in positive ways
- Reflect: therapist shares own thoughts/reactions with client on ongoing basis
- Solution focused/ exceptions: when is client not experiencing problem
- miracle question: “what if you woke up one morning and problem was gone?”
- scaling questions: rate intensity of problem on 1 to 10 - Narrative/ deconstructive questions: questions about larger social/cultural issue.
- Narrative/ Externalizations: problem apart from person
- “how is anorexia terrorizing you?”
Collaborative language therapy: diversity
- No issue is raised that is not raised by the client
- Cultural competency may risk reinforcing stereotypes > reduce therapist focus on individual
- Cultural competency assist therapist in understanding history of marginalization/ discrimination
- Focus on social justice and cultural diversity > cultural/ ethnic groups, women, class > narrative therapist raises issue when not directly raised by client
Transgenerational family therapies
- Attend to dynamics across more than two generations
- Attend to how the past affects the present
- No interest in individual pathology
- Focus on family across generations develop patterns of behaving/ responding to stress that prevents healthy development and lead to problems
- Client focus on understanding how certain patterns develop and change the way they resolve past issues and interact with families
Bowen family systems therapy
- Mentally ill individuals caught up in patterns of family fusion > they are symptom bearers for the family rather than characteristically flawed or ill
- Differentiation of self: ability to maintain strong sense of self while maintaining connection with strong emotional system
- I can use opinions and advice of others, but make independent decisions
- it is a process, not a personality trait - Differentiation of thinking from emotion: making decisions about behavior rather than reacting to intensity of emotional system
- Fusion: without autonomy, individuals fused with others, unable to think for themselves
- opposite of differentiation - Life difficulties arise because individuals ruled by emotion and depend on others good will
- Think while under emotional strain, not feel
- Anxiety basis of all symptomology
Bowen: triangles
- Smallest stable unit of a system: emotions
- One or both of individuals brining third person into relationship
- Third part of triangle may be work, hobby, issue
- All systems form triangles
- ex. Parents in argument, child interrupts to tell story, story avoids argument > after may be more calm to resolve issue - Rigid triangle: problem, the same issue, person, problem > severe and prevents system from dealing
- ex. Drugs/alcohol, affair
Bowen: nuclear family emotional process
- Typical family patterns of dealing with stress on order to reduce anxiety
- useful if moderate and flexible
- Harmful if used severely or exclusively
- If mild, emotions can calm down, thinking available
- If heated, difficulties thinking of alternatives
-“I couldn’t think clearly” - Patterns to reduce anxiety
A. Conflict: resolve healthily or with mental, emotional, physical violence
B. Symptom: physical, emotional, mental, social
-headache, stress headache, chronic back pain
-depressed/ anxious, cancer
-alcohol abuse
C. Distancing:
-mild: agreed upon time out
-moderate: keep from becoming anxious, keep from developing intimacy
-extreme: divorce, cutting off oneself from others
D. Triangling: one or two people reducing anxiety by involving third person
Bowen: healthy families
- Functional, neither healthy nor unhealthy
- Balance needs for autonomy and intimacy over time and across situations
- Functional families in crisis: pull together, assist emotionally, gradually redifferentiate > higher states of differentiation
- Enmeshment normal when:
A. Couple engaged/ married
B. Children first born - Families move through life stages without undue difficulty
- Flexible with conflict
Bowen: goals
- Differentiation of self > problematic behavior not focus
- Detriangulation of harmful rigid triangles
- Calm emotions
- Changes in triangles and differentiation = symptom removal
- Therapist as one member of a triangle
- Modify relationships