Exam:) Flashcards
Demarcate the study field of forensic pathology.
Forensic pathology entails the study of the effects of
1. Trauma.
2. Injury.
3. Unnatural diseases on the human body.
Describe the six (6) circumstances under which deaths are seen as unnatural and state at least one example to illustrate each of the circumstances.
- Deaths due to violence and the consequences of the injuries that result in death (cases of homicide, suicide, or accidents).
- Deaths resulting from external physical factors that impact on the body (when individuals die in a vehicle accident).
- Deaths resulting from the effect of a chemical substance (when individuals die as a result of poisoning).
- When an anaesthetic was administered or the person had a surgical procedure shortly before death (all types of anaesthetic (local or general).
- When a person dies suddenly without pre-existing illness or if the death is unexplained.
- Any death, including deaths that would otherwise be classified as being “natural” where it is suspected that the death was due to an act or neglect to act by any person including medical staff.
Describe the role of forensic pathologists when they attend death scenes.
- Pronounce/confirm the death.
- Determine the manner of death (Natural, Accidental, Homicidal, Suicidal, Undetermined).
- Determine the time of death, also known as the Post Mortem Interval, through studying the post mortem changes (Rigor mortis, Hypostasis, Cooling, Decomposition, Insects which start a life cycle on the body).
- Obtain clues and information at the scene to clarify what occurred at the scene of death.
Provide a detailed explanation of Nysten’s Law.
2 – 4 hours after death: The first signs of RM become visible in smaller muscle groups in the eyelids, facial muscles, neck, and lower jaw.
4 – 12 hours after death: RM develops throughout the body. The order wherein it develops after the smaller muscle groups in the stated order is the wrists and ankles, knees, elbows and hips.
12 - 36 hours after death: The maximum peak of RM is reached within 12 hours and persists (remains constant) in the body for approximately 12 - 36 hours depending on circumstances.
Over the course of the next 12 hours: RM gradually disappears again in the same order it appeared; thus RM disappears in the small muscle groups first. This period is also known as Secondary Relaxation/Flaccidity.
Discuss the guidelines forensic pathologists will follow during their objective search of death scenes.
- Forensic pathologist must make sure all photographs have been taken and sketches made.
- Looking for signs of a struggle is important, for example broken objects, overturned furniture, broken branches.
- If an obvious weapon is present: Note the position of the weapon in relation to the body as this clue may be important to determine whether it was suicide or homicide. Handle weapons with extreme care.
- If no obvious weapon is present at the scene: Homicide should be suspected. The forensic pathologist can also assist in determining the most likely weapon by studying the wound characteristics.
- To assist the investigative process with an opinion about the cause (may appear to be due to a gunshot wound, stab wound, or blunt force trauma to the head) of death and the manner (natural, accidental, suicidal, homicidal, or undetermined) of death.
- The position of the body should be noted and whether the rigor mortis and hypostasis match this position.
- Clothing should be examined with care: Tears, missing buttons, blood stains, and gunshot residue should be observed. Take note of buttons fastened incorrectly/awkwardly. Take note whether wounds were inflicted through clothes or on bared skin.
- The amount of blood at the scene should be noted: The average person has 4.7 – 5.5 litres of blood inside the body. The amount of blood at the scene may indicate that the location where the body is found is a secondary dumping site for the body.
- Preliminary examination of body: Look for self-defence wounds. Paper bags should be placed over the hands for possible biological material under the nails. The body should be transported to the mortuary in a clean white sheet and washed body bag to avoid cross-contamination.
- The forensic pathologist should look for signs of sexual assault, such as removed underwear.
Explain what rigor mortis is and indicate the period of development under normal circumstances including the manner in which it spreads through the body.
Rigor Mortis (RM) is a period of rigidity in the muscles, that follows after the period of flaccidity.
It occurs as a result of the formation of lactic acid in the muscles and causes the body to stiffen and limbs to be locked “in place”.
Under normal circumstances, the period of development, which is also known as the “march of rigor mortis”, is as follows:
(1) 2 – 4 hours after death: The first signs of RM become visible in smaller muscle groups in the eyelids, facial muscles, neck, and lower jaw.
(2) 4 – 12 hours after death: RM develops throughout the body. The order wherein it develops after the smaller muscle groups in the stated order is the wrists and ankles, knees, elbows and hips.
(3) 12 - 36 hours after death: The maximum peak of RM is reached within 12 hours and persists (remains constant) in the body for approximately 12 - 36 hours depending on circumstances.
(4) Over the course of the next 12 hours: RM gradually disappears again in the same order it appeared; thus RM disappears in the small muscle groups first. This period is also known as Secondary Relaxation/Flaccidity.
Factors that the onset and persistence of rigor mortis is subject to.
- Environmental Temperature (If it is extremely hot, RM develops and disappears within 9-12 hours. If it is very cold, RM lasts for 3 - 4 days).
- In malnourished and severely underweight individuals, RM sets in more rapidly, while in individuals with a high body mass, RM will slow down.
- The onset of RM is accelerated in individuals who engaged in strenuous physical activity immediately before death (e.g. a gym workout).
- Any disease which raised the body’s temperature before death accelerates the onset of RM (e.g. infections which caused fever).
- Rapid onset of RM is indicative of possible brain hemorrhaging, epileptic seizure before death and strychnine poisoning.
Deduce the criminalistic value of rigor mortis.
- The pathologist can estimate the time of death because RM develops according to a predictable timetable, which is also known as Nysten’s Law.
- The pathologist can, by studying the posture of the body, determine if there was movement of the body. If a body is found in an unnatural position, movement of the body may be assumed after RM had developed .
Explain the importance of the pugilistic posture in forensic pathology.
- The Pugilistic Posture occurs in bodies that were charred in a fire.
- Exposure to severe heat causes coagulation of the muscle protein, which results in the contraction (stiffening and shortening) of the muscles.
- The body would assume this posture even if death occurred before being exposed to the extreme heat source.
Explain the significance of Cadaveric Spasm in forensic pathology in detail.
- It is a very rare phenomenon.
- Also called Instantaneous Rigor Mortis, Cataleptic Rigidity, or the Death Grip.
- Occurs when the tense muscles at the time of death, retain their tense state immediately after death and persists into the period of RM.
- Most often observed in the isolated muscles of the arm and hand.
- If CS occurs, an object being clenched in a hand, will be very difficult or mostly impossible to release from the hand.
- Manipulation of the muscles in cases of CS would be impossible.
- Cadaveric Spasm has been documented before under the following circumstances:
(a) If a victim is thought to have committed suicide, and the weapon is grasped so tightly in the hand that it is not possible to remove the weapon.
(b) Homicides where buttons, hair or pieces of clothing (e.g. a pocket torn off a shirt) are found grasped tightly in victims’ hands.
(c) Drowning and mountain accidents where stones, grass and branches are found grasped tightly in victims’ hands.
(d) Car, airplane and train accidents where victims are found grasping onto objects (e.g. steering wheel, seats, cell phones etc.).
(e) Deaths on the battlefield in wartime.
Explain four (4) differences between rigor mortis and cadaveric
spasm in detail.
- Rigor mortis can be used to estimate the time of death because it develops according to a predictable timetable, which is also known as Nysten’s Law whereas Cadaveric Spasm has no period of development (rigidity in specific muscles is immediate).
- Rigor Mortis can be manipulated by force (e.g. a hardened/stiff/rigid arm can be pushed into a different position) whereas Manipulation of the muscles in cases of Cadaveric Spasm would be impossible.
- Rigor Mortis occurs as a result of the formation of lactic acid in the muscles and causes the body to stiffen and limbs to be locked “in place” whereas Cadaveric Spasm is a very rare phenomenon.
- Rigor Mortis occurs in smaller muscle groups in the eyelids, facial muscles, neck, and lower jaw, the ankles, knees, elbows and hips whereas Cadaveric Spasm occurs in isolated muscles of the arm and hand.
Explain what hypostasis is and state the period of development.
Hypostasis is described as the purplish-red discoloration of the most dependent parts of the body (lowest points) after the heart stopped beating, where blood settles/pools in the blood vessels under the influence of gravity.
The Period of Development is as follows:
(1) 1 – 2 hours after death the first signs will be noticed.
(2) 4 hours after death hypostasis will be well developed.
(3) 8 – 12 hours after death hypostasis will reach a maximum peak.
(4) After 12 hours, hypostasis will fixate due to the coagulation (clotting) of the blood.
Describe the period of development for cataleptic congestion.
(1) 1 – 2 hours after death the first signs will be noticed.
(2) 4 hours after death hypostasis will be well developed.
(3) 8 – 12 hours after death hypostasis will reach a maximum peak.
(4) After 12 hours, hypostasis will fixate due to the coagulation (clotting) of the blood.
Discuss the fixation or non-fixation of livor mortis.
- Whether or not hypostasis is fixed can be determined by the so-called Blanching Test, which entails that the thumb of the observer is pressed on the livid area (where the blood pooled) for approximately a minute and ten released.
(a) If the area becomes pale after the thumb is removed, the hypostasis is not fixed, whereas if the area remains purplish-red the hypostasis is fixed.
(b) However, after 12 hours the blood coagulates and hypostasis becomes fixated (does not change); thus if a body is found with hypostasis development and pale patches that do not match the position the body is found in, it is assumed that the body was moved after 12 hours into a new position. - Include the Period of development of Hypostasis.
Discuss the criminalistic value of hypostasis.
- Because there is a predictable period of development, it can be used to estimate the time of death.
- It is helpful to determine movement of the body when hypostasis development does not correspond with the position the body is discovered in.
- The colour of hypostasis can be indicative of the cause of death:
(a) Cherry-red hypostasis is usually observed in cases of carbon monoxide.
(b) Pink hypostasis is usually observed in cases of cyanide poisoning and deaths as a result of hypothermia (cold temperatures).
(c) Brown hypostasis is typically seen in cases of nitrate poisoning.
Explain what the blanching test entails and describe what the forensic pathologist who uses it can deduce.
The Blanching Test entails that the thumb of the observer is pressed on the livid area (where the blood pooled) for approximately a minute and then released.
The pale patches illustrate the areas of the body that were in contact with the surface (blood vessels under pressure due to weight of body) when hypostasis developed.
Provide a detailed discussion of the significance of algor mortis in forensic pathology.
- During algor mortis the body temperature lowers until it matches environmental temperature.
- Three distinct periods of algor mortis are identified:
(a) The Initial Phase or Temperature Plateau when the temperature remains relatively stable for 30 minutes to three hours.
(b) The Intermediate Phase in which the body cools rapidly and at a relatively linear rate.
(c) The Terminal Phase when the rate of body cooling slows as the core temperature reaches the environmental temperature. - Several factors can influence the rate at which a body cools down:
(a) The difference between body temperature and environmental temperature - the greater the difference between the temperature of the body and the environment, the faster the cooling rate.
(b) The body will cool down faster if the surrounding area is well ventilated or humid.
(c) Clothing will isolate the body and slow the rate down.
(d) Body weight. - After the body has cooled down to reach environmental temperature, the cooling rate is no longer useful to estimate the time of death.
- The post mortem interval cannot be accurately estimated during the first three to five hours after death due to the effect of the actual body temperature at death and the length of the temperature plateau following death.
Clearly distinguish between autolysis and putrefaction in forensic pathology.
- Autolysis, or Aerobic Decomposition, which begins immediately after death is not visible to the naked eye and is also known as the fresh stage of decomposition. Putrefaction, or Anaerobic Decomposition, is the process of decomposition that is visible to the naked eye.
- During autolysis, the cells inside the body begin to leak enzymes into the surrounding tissue, and the bacteria, which are still living in the intestines, begin to consume the internal organs. Insects have a very keen sense of smell and will be attracted to the body because of these chemical processes.
- Putrefaction is separated into the bloating phase, the decay phase, the post decay phase, and the dry stage.
Describe the main events during each of the four (4) phases of putrefaction.
- The Bloating Phase: The first noticeable sign is 2-3 days after death when a greenish discolouration appears on the lower abdomen. This greenish discoloration spreads over the entire abdomen soon and later the entire body. The tongue and eyes may also protrude. This bloating process continues for approximately 5–6 days.
- The Decay Phase: Lasts for approximately 11 days.The body takes on a wet appearance as fluids start to drain from the natural body orifices and the sweat pores. The internal organs have broken down (also known as Liquefaction), which produces the fluids which drain from the body. The drainage of fluids is called Post Mortem Purging.
- The Post Decay Phase: Begins around the 12th day after death. Most of the flesh would have been consumed (by insects or other animals) or have decomposed. Therefore, this phase is also known as The Start Of Skeletonisation.
- The Dry Stage: Begins approximately 3 to 4 weeks after death. It involves the decomposition of the dry remains, usually the bones, nails, hair, cartilage, and dehydrated skin. Specific insects start a life cycle on the remains. Other 27 insects like house moths will also start a life cycle on the dry tissue of the mummified body and the hair.
Explain how insects and other animals who use human remains as a source of food may complicate post mortem findings.
- Cockroaches and ants produce post mortem injuries to bodies when using the body as a source of food.
- Terrestrial animals like rats, dogs and cats choose to eat soft exposed tissue around the eyes, ears, lips, and genitals. Moreover, they tend to choose to eat areas of the body where the skin is already broken; thus, wounds sustained ante mortem (before death) will be enlarged.
- Bodies disposed off in water are also used as a source of food by aquatic animals. Leeches in particular attach themselves around the eyes which produce lesions that resemble a black eye.
- Turtles, crabs, and fish eat tissue around the eyes, nose, ears, and genitals, as well as around ante mortem wounds where the skin is already broken.
Name and discuss the factors that may influence the rate of decomposition.
- Sepsis (severe infection throughout body) before death may cause faster decomposition.
- The hotter and more humid the environmental temperature, the faster decomposition will occur.
- Optimal temperature for accelerated decomposition is between 25 and 38 degrees Celsius.
- In bodies with multiple external open injuries, decomposition is accelerated.
- A body in open-air will putrefy faster than one which is buried or submerged in water.
- If the temperature of the body is low, the onset and rate of autolysis will be retarded, while higher temperature caused by fever or high levels of exertion prior to death, will accelerate the rate and onset of decomposition.
Explain what Casper’s dictum entails.
“Casper’s dictum” states that a body decomposes twice as fast in open air than a body submerged in water; and eight times faster than one buried in soil.
Discuss two (2) post mortem phenomena that may arrest the progression of putrefaction.
- Mummification
(a) Should not be confused with the deliberate mummification of bodies by the Egyptians, because it is a natural process.
(b) In a dry atmosphere, a body may lose fluids so rapidly (dehydrate), that it dries out before normal decomposition can proceed as discussed.
(c) The rapid elimination of fluids from the tissue, circumvents the process of bacterial putrefaction.
(d) In such instances the skin shrinks and is converted into a parchment-like mass of skin which surrounds the bones – mummified tissues are rigid and hard.
(e) The natural mummification process takes approximately 6 to 12 months to conclude; but in extreme conditions the time can be rapidly reduced.
(f) Mummification persists for decades, and even centuries; therefore, the body goes into a state of preservation.
(g) External marks on the skin, such as strangulation marks, remain preserved in the skin which becomes like leather.
(h) As a result of the shrinking of the skin, large tears/splits may occur in the groin and neck-area, which mimic injuries sustained before death and may lead to misinterpretation. - Adipocere
(a) Under moist conditions, body fat (triglycerides in particular) converts into a substance which is described as soapy, waxy, greasy, cheese-like.
(b) The process of conversion is defined as The Saponification Of Body Fats Into Grave Wax or corpse wax, and the colour is typically off-white to grey.
(c) Adipocere can persist for decades, even centuries; therefore, the body goes into a state of preservation.
(d) Burial ground which is acidic, where enough moisture is present, and oxygen absent (exposure to oxygen inhibits adipocere), can result in adipocere.
(e) Types of soil where bodies may develop adipocere are peat bogs (characterised by acidic soil), which are wetlands where dead plant material accumulates; for this reason, such bodies are also called Bog Bodies.
(f) Similar to mummification, it allows for the preservation of marks and injuries on the skin.
(g) The phenomenon is most pronounced in body parts which contain more fat, such as the cheeks, buttocks, and breasts of women.
(h) Adipocere is also more common in women, toddlers, and obese individuals, because they have more body fat.
(i) It is seen as a complicating factor because once it sets in, it becomes very difficult to estimate the post mortem interval.
(j) Depending on environmental conditions, adipocere may be observed as early as five weeks after death; however, as a rule the presence of adipocere is usually an indication of a post mortem interval of at least three to six months.
The manifestation of adipocere in buried bodies depends on a variety of factors such as?
- The geographical location of the burial site.
- The season of the burial.
- Vegetation surrounding the burial site.
- Depth of the grave.
- Insect infestation before burial (a body that is accessible to insects is unlikely to form adipocere).
- The composition of a coffin, if used.
- The chemical and physical soil properties.
Describe the complete lifecycle of the most common insect that invades human remains in South Africa.
- Blowfly” is a colloquial name used to describe a number of flying insects in the Diptera family and comprises of mainly bluebottles, greenbottles, and houseflies.
- The most common blowfly which invades human remains in South Africa, is the bluebottle.
- Eggs may even be deposited on the living if they are weakened or injured severely and cannot move to chase the blowflies away from them. Each fly can deposit up to 300 eggs. The eggs hatch within 12 - 24 hours in optimal environmental temperatures. The eggs hatch into maggots that use body as a source of food.
- The maggots go through three phases (called Instars) during an eating frenzy:
Instar 1: maggots grow to 5mm long within 1.8 days.
Instar 2: maggots grow to 10mm long within 2.5 days.
Instar 3: maggots grow to 14 -16mm long within 4 to 5 days. - After instar 3 (in other words 4–5 days), the maggots become too heavy to hold on to the body and fall to the ground; at this stage they have grown to 17mm long and have reached maturity.
- They now migrate in a pre-pupal phase to a suitable site (usually the soil around the body); they stop feeding; and develop into pupae within 34 approximately 4 days.
- In favourable conditions (warm temperatures), an adult blowfly emerges from the pupal phase within 6 to 8 days. In less favourable conditions (cold temperatures), the pupal phase can last the entire winter.
- The blowfly which emerges from the pupal phase is ready to start the whole cycle from afresh within 2 days after emerging from the pupal phase.
List the legal procedures that apply to post mortem examinations in South Africa.
- An autopsy is performed by a forensic pathologist appointed by the Department of Health.
- An autopsy is performed at a mortuary of the Forensic Pathology Service of the Department of Health.
- The criminal investigator who is in charge of an investigation is allowed to attend an autopsy.
- An autopsy is performed with the express request of a criminal investigator or on instruction by a magistrate.
- The permission of family members is not required to perform an autopsy, and they may also not deny the procedure.
- An autopsy is performed as soon as possible.
- An unidentified body remains in the freezers at the mortuary for 30 days, after which the municipal council under whose authority the mortuary is, has to ensure a pauper’s burial takes place for the deceased.
Describe the procedure that is followed during a full post mortem examination.
- All autopsies start with a description of the deceased’s physical characteristics (external examination first), which includes documentation of age, height, weight, sex, nutritional state, muscular development, scars, and tattoos.
- Injuries are documented, including the amount, size, characteristics, shape, course, direction, depth and location of injuries.
- Organs are removed for separate examination and dissection.
- Abnormal sized organs are weighed.
- Laboratory specimens are taken for further analysis (e.g. suspected poisoning).
- Abnormal collections of fluid are measured (e.g. blood collected and measured in chest cavity if deceased bled internally).
What are the types of Low-Level Socio-Moral Reasoning?
Motivational Factor 1: Limited Consequential Thinking.
Motivational Factor 2: Individualism.
Motivational Factor 3: Interpersonal Relationships.
Outline Motivational Factor 1: Limited Consequential Thinking.
- It demonstrates high concern for the fear of punishment.
- It demonstrates little concern for “right” vs “wrong”.
- Attitude: “It’s only a mistake if you get caught.”
- Fear of consequences is equated to the desire to avoid punishment.
- This early conventional stage is referred to as “good boy” or “good girl” orientation.
Outline Motivational Factor 2: Individualism.
- “Right” vs “wrong” is defined in terms of personal needs and interests.
- Obeying society’s laws and rules is secondary to self-protection and self-preservation.
- For instance, those who cannot afford a meal might steal food. Although they understand that they are breaking the law, hunger has a stronger influence on their decision making.
- Juveniles who adopt a stealing lifestyle and are convinced that it is the only method of survival.
- The interactions with society and other humans are key in determining their mind processes and awareness.
- The mind is not an activity of the brain, but a self-organising process that arises from bodily processes.
Outline Motivational Factor 3: Interpersonal Relationships.
- “Right” vs “wrong” is defined in terms of protecting the needs and interests of the people one cares about most.
- A gang mentality prevails.
Attitudes include: - Youth offenders who don’t look out for themselves, nobody else will.
- Respect has to be earned through aggression.
- Only the present matters as they have nothing to lose.
- The weak will be exploited in every possible way.
- The group is needed for protection and emotional support.
- The system treats them unfairly and discriminates against them.
- Material things are what life is all about.
What is Poverty?
Poverty is the extent to which an individual does without resources. These resources include financial, emotional, mental, physical and spiritual support systems.
What causes some young people who live in economically impoverished environments to engage in low-level socio-moral thinking?
- Young people who grow up feeling impoverished, perhaps owing to family violence, may find themselves in a chronic pattern of deep emotional pain that directly influences their current and future actions and behaviour.
- Emotional poverty is perpetuated through experiences of rejection, abandonment or abuse is likely to elicit additional feelings including shame, fear and anger.
What are the 2 domains of empathy?
- Affective empathy: encompasses an emotional response that manifests in feelings of concern for another individual.
- Cognitive empathy: one’s ability to understand another person’s frame of reference and not being blinded by one’s own point of view.
What has a greater likelihood of promoting pro-social behaviour?
A foundation of feeling loved and valued, and a sense of belonging have a greater likelihood of promoting pro-social behaviour and the capacity for empathetic involvement and high-level socio-moral reasoning.
What is Neuroplasticity and what does it entail?
For a youth to change from low-level socio-moral reasoning to high-level socio-moral reasoning will need a process called Neuroplasticity, which entails the ability of the brain to change its’ structure in response to experiences.
What are Thinking Errors?
Thinking Errors is an example of low-level socio-moral reasoning, which involves young people attempting to alter their reality to avoid taking responsibility for their actions.
What are other common thinking errors?
Other common thinking errors include telling lies, justifying or coming up with excuses for behaviour.
3 common Thinking Errors.
- Assuming: A young person may assume he/she knows what another person is thinking or feeling, and will often act before verifying the facts. “He looks at me like he wanted to fight so I…”
- Blaming: A young person justifies his/her negative behaviour as being due to someone else initiating the incident. “It’s not my fault, he started it!”
- Minimising: The young person will attempt to make what he/she did seem less bared. “I barely touched him! That didn’t hurt.”
What are the 3 levels of Crime Prevention?
- Primary Prevention.
- Secondary Prevention.
- Tertiary Prevention.
What is Primary Prevention?
Primary Prevention is proactive and relates to the steps that are taken to prevent youth misbehaviour and crime before they occur.
What is Secondary Prevention?
Secondary Prevention refers to interventions in the lives of youths or groups identified as being in circumstances that predispose them to misbehaviour.
What is Tertiary Prevention?
Tertiary Prevention deals with juveniles who have already committed crime.
Name the features of the Primary Prevention of crime.
- The role of the FAMILY as primary socializing agent.
- The role of MENTORS in the prevention of youth misbehaviour.
- The role of MEDIA in primary prevention.
- The role of the POLICE in primary crime prevention.
- The role of the GOVERNMENT AND SOCIETY IN SOCIAL UPLIFTMENT.
Discuss the role of the FAMILY as primary socializing agent (Primary Prevention)
- Everything that happens in the family system has a considerable influence on the future of the child: Because of economic and social factors, families are often unable to function as adequate support systems. Adequate social support networks, which instils a sense of belonging, enable children to accept responsibility.
- Primary prevention projects aimed at improving the ability of families to support children should be a priority: Empowering parents by instructing them on aspects such as basic care of infants, child development, the disciplinary needs of children and conflict resolution is the most basic preventative measures.
- Any form of parent effectiveness training as well as family skills training can be beneficial: Parent training should be aimed at instructing parents on the demands and responsibilities associated with raising children. How to set clear expectations, nurture children and improve interaction to promote bonding within the family context.
- An effective proactive strategy for preventing youth crime would be to offer programmes aimed at reinforcing and internalizing positive individual traits such as discipline, trustworthiness, self-respect and responsibility.
- NICRO – offer two parenting programmes. The goal of these programmes is to promote positive parenting and to curb child abuse and neglect. They assist parents to raise children who are emotionally balanced, have high self-esteem.
- Youth-at-risk programmes such as Conquest for Life aim to enhance dialogue between the youth, parents, and community institutions such as schools.
- MomConnect - gives pregnant women and caregivers of children younger than 2 years the opportunity to register for free child-rearing advice.
Discuss the role of MENTORS in the prevention of youth misbehaviour (Primary Prevention).
- The increase in number of single parent and child-headed households led to many youths lacking positive role models.
- Mentorship programmes that encourage friendships with conventional peer can be viewed as a primary measure for preventing youth misbehaviour: A positive relationship with an adult is a major contributing factor. Children need to acquire resilience factors and this can be achieved by assistance of a mentor who assists the child in dire situations and shows them that they are loved and wanted, and that they are trusted by the mentor.
- Mentorship programmes can also be used in circumstances where youths are at risk of clashing with the criminal justice system.
- Big Brothers Big Sisters (BBBS) – offer peer counselling and tutoring. This leads to an improvement in the children’s self-esteem, feelings of self-worth, ability to trust, communication skills, as well as academic performance.
Discuss the role of MEDIA in primary prevention.
- Mass media can be used to address crime, and specifically youth misbehaviour: Educating the community about crimes and the prevention of crimes.
- SHOUT Trust – A campaign for a safer South Africa (2010): A crime fighting non-profit organization. Launched by Danny K and Kabelo Mabalane as a reaction to the murder of Lucky Dube. Musicians of South Africa should speak out on behalf of “an almost voiceless nation”. “We have a chance to turn the pages over. How long can we look at each other down the barrel of a gun?”
- Soul City: The impact of violence against women and how this can be prevented. Preventing alcohol-induced violence. They also work on the tertiary prevention level where the aim is to prevent victimization or the reoccurrence of crime.
- Crime-related information can reduce people’s fear of crime, enable members of the community to help themselves, raise awareness among the youth.
- The media can also be used to encourage the youth to report crime through the marketing of information lines such as 08600 10111.
Discuss the role of the POLICE in primary crime prevention.
- A good relationship between the police and the community is an important part of primary crime prevention.
- Community policing (a strategy that is based on a partnership between the police and the community to find solutions to community crimes) and sector policing (an approach where a police station area is divided into smaller, more manageable sectors) will never succeed if the youth do not trust the police.
- Adopt-A-Cop: Schools that are included each receive the service of 2 police officials (a detective and police officer). Both of these police officials liaise with the school and visit schools with the aim of reviving school safety forums and encouraging children to report crime. Improve local safety and security by implementing proactive initiatives to address factors that cause crimes in schools. Provide information sessions focusing on aspects such as safety precautions, bullying, gangsterism and drug abuse. Establish a relationship with the school and the children by attending events and becoming authority figures who are trusted by the children.
Discuss the role of the GOVERNMENT AND SOCIETY IN SOCIAL UPLIFTMENT (Primary Prevention).
- Community-wide social upliftment programmes focus on structural problems such as lack of adequate housing, education and employment opportunities.
- Growth, Employment and Redistribution Strategy (GEAR): Improving the socioeconomic situation in South Africa. The goals are to facilitate a new economic system that ensures a competitive and fast-growing economy that will create enough jobs for South Africans.
- The National Youth Development Agency (NYDA): To empower the youth (14-53 years) of South Africa on both a social and an economic level, aiming to reduce youth employments and promote social cohesion. To alleviate poverty, to focus on rural and urban development, to combat crime and substance abuse, and to prevent social decay among the youth.
- Limitless Youth Campaign – to instil a positive mindset in youth people on an emotional level and to assure them that they can be anything they want to be.
Name the features of the Secondary Prevention of crime.
- Homeless/Street Children.
- The role of the SCHOOL in the secondary prevention of youth misbehaviour.
Discuss Homeless/Street Children (Secondary Prevention).
- Ons Plek: A shelter for female street children in Cape Town. To prevent runaway girls from becoming street children. To provide a safe heaven for the street for new arrivals, while counsellors work on long-term solutions for their problems.
- Street-Wise Programme: Designed to address problems that street children may have to face and to help prevent them from becoming adult offenders. Accommodation is offered for a maximum period of 1 year, as the aim is to reconcile children with their families. Where reconciliation is not possible, such children will be referred to a youth care centre or other suitable accommodation.
- The Homestead Projects for Street Children: Services provided include aspects such as substance abuse counselling, school attendance support and family preservation programmes. Accommodates boys between 6-17 years who are traumatised and have suffered neglect, abuse and/or exploitation, children who have been living, working and/or begging on the streets.
- The Launch Pad: Provides shelter for drug-free youths between 15-21 years. To empower and provide life skills to traumatized youth with aspects such as anger management issues and inappropriate private sexual behaviour, working to improve their relationships with their families or guardians, developing their talent.
Discuss the role of the SCHOOL in the secondary prevention of youth misbehaviour.
- The school fulfils an important role as a socializing agent and also in the development of the child: Implemented policies and procedures should be developed to address problems at school. It is also important that the school rules are enforced fairly and consistently.
- The Safe School Project: Initiated by the government aimed at addressing safety in public schools. The provision of school environment that are conductive, to identity and assist those with learning difficulties, and to support those from broken homes, or those who live in poverty.
- THE NATIONAL SCHOOL SAFETY FRAMEWORK: To manage the school safety committees in South Africa with the aim of creating a safe and violence-free learning environment. The purpose of the school safety committee is to identify and manage threats of violence and risk factors in and around schools.
- The Department of Social Development (DSD): To gauge the nature and extent of violence in schools. Teachers, parents, the community and the SAPS should collaborate and use community policing forums to assist in the safe-keeping of schools. Coordinates an anti-gang strategy to alleviate gang-related school violence.
- Teachers are in an ideal position to identify key indicators or risk factors, which if not addressed can give rise to violence at the school.
Preventing Recidivism (Tertiary Prevention)
- It is important to manage juveniles in accordance with current legislation and international standards.
- To adhere to their rights as children and focus programmes on rehabilitation and reintegration.
Discuss the role of The Department of Correctional Services (DCS) at a Tertiary Prevention of crime level.
- Aims to provide offenders with needs-based programmes and interventions to facilitate rehabilitation and enable reintegration into communities.
- Offender development is a priority and include personal development and rehabilitation programmes addressing illiteracy, furthering education, teaching practical skills such as bricklaying and agricultural skills; as well as the inclusion of recreational programmes (sport).
- Programmes target offending behaviour by teaching life skills and focusing on anger management.
- Social work services and religious care programmes are provided.
- Social reintegration programmes focus on coping skills for handling challenges that the offender will face upon release.
- Facilitates restorative justice meetings (Victim-Offender Dialogues) in order to promote mediation and healing among offenders, victims,
Discuss the features of Preventing Recidivism (Tertiary Prevention).
- Khulisa: Aims to prevent crime, divert youth from the criminal justice system, provide alternatives to imprisonment, foster personal transformation for those who are in prison, and assist with transition back to society. Dare to Dream programme - Aims to help individuals escape from a life of poverty and crime. Silence the Violence - Focuses on the culture of violence ingrained in communities and belief systems.
- My Path: Aimed at individuals in need of personal development and behavioural therapy. It promotes the discovery of oneself as a physical, psychological, emotional, and social being. It helps offenders embark on a path of exploring who they are and helping to prepare them for re-entry into a positive and meaningful lifestyle. The focus is on replacing inappropriate beliefs, goal-setting, communication skills, improving relationships, and restorative justice.
What is Diversion?
A matter involving a child away from the formal court procedures in a criminal matter when there is sufficient evidence to prosecute the child. It entails those children in conflict with the law are kept away from the formal criminal justice system and ensures that they are successfully reintegrated into society.
What are the Objectives (what do we want to achieve) of diversion?
- Deal with a child outside the formal criminal justice system.
- Encourage the child to be accountable for the harm they have caused.
- Meet the particular needs of an individual child.
- Provide an opportunity to victims to express their views about the impact of the offence on them.
- Promote the reintegration of the child into his/her family and community.
- Reduce the potential for re-offending and prevent the child from having a criminal record.
- Promote the dignity and wellbeing of the child and the development of his/her sense of self-worth.
- Prevent the stigmatizing of the child and prevent the adverse consequences of contact with the criminal justice system.
In what ways can Diversion occur?
Diversion can occur in three ways:
1. Through prosecutorial diversion when a child has committed a Schedule 1 offence.
2. At the preliminary inquiry, through an order of the inquiry magistrate.
3. During the trial in the child justice court through an order of the court.
Criteria for diversion (what requirements should be in place to consider diversion).
- The child acknowledges responsibility for the offence.
- The child has not been unduly influenced to acknowledge responsibility.
- A prima facie case exists against the child (there is sufficient evidence to prosecute the child)
- The child and his/her parent/guardian consents to diversion.
- The prosecutor or Director of Public Prosecutions indicates that the child may be diverted in accordance with relevant provision of the Child Justice Act.
The Minimum Standards for diversion (what is the standards that a diversion programme has to adhere to).
- May not be exploitative, harmful or hazardous to the child’s physical or mental health, and may not interfere with the child’s schooling.
- Must be appropriate to the age and maturity of the child.
- May not exclude certain children due to a lack of resources, financial or otherwise, and also bearing in mind the circumstances of children in rural areas.
- Must be sensitive to the circumstances of the victims, and must involve the child’s parents/guardians.
- Must, where reasonably possible, impart useful skills, include a restorative element and promote the child’s understanding of the impact of the offence.
- Must be accessible to the child, structured in a way that is suitable to be used in a variety of circumstances and for a variety of offences, and measurable in terms of effectiveness.
Types of Diversion programmes.
- Life skills training.
- Mentoring.
- Family group conferencing.
- Outdoor programmes.
What are Dynamic Risk Factors?
Factors that can be changed, for example one can replace criminal role models with positive role models or mentors.
What is a Risk Factor?
A variable that predicts a high probability of offending.