Evidence - Short Answer Questions Flashcards
- What is the definition of Relevance. (p7)
Key Word
TP/DACDP
EiR iihaT tPoD ati oCtt DoaP
Key Words:
Tendency prove / disprove anything consequence determination proceeding.
Relevance
Evidence is relevant if it has a tendency to prove or disprove anything that is of consequence to the determination of a proceeding. S7 (3) EA06
- What is the definition of Facts in issue (p7)
Key Words
PPEEO
DPSDRCBoP
PmP tEtE otO o
DmP tSwaD IRow hos CtBoP
Exam 2
Key Words:
Prosecution Prove Establish Elements offence.
Defendant Prove Succeed Defense Respect of Which Carries Burden Proof.
Facts in issue are those which:
• prosecution must prove to establish the elements of the offence or
•defendant must prove to succeed with a defense in respect of which he or she carries the burden of proof
- What is a witness (p9)
Key Words
PGEaCEP
PwgE aiatb CE iaP
Exam 2
Key Word
Person Giving Evidence Able Cross Examined Proceeding
Witness
person who gives evidence and is able to be cross examined in a proceeding
- Giving evidence may be given in what ways?
Key Words
OW-OCPJJPCP
AW-CUSD/P OC VRBH
AOW-PBEA06 o ORE
O W - eO iaC itPoa J,J,PttP, C aMotP abtJ.
A W - itC bUtS tDoOP. OtC obVR mBtH.
A O W - Pf btEA 2006 oaORE.
Key Words:
Ordinary Way - Orally Courtroom Presence Judge Jury Parties Counsel Public
Alternative Way - Courtroom Unable See Defendant/Persons Outside Courtroom Video Recording Before Hearing
Any Other Way - Provided By Evidence Act06 or Other Relevant Enactment
- ordinary way – either orally in a courtroom in the presence of a judge, jury, parties to the proceedings, counsel and members of the public allowed by the judge
- alternative way – in the courtroom but unable to see the defendant or other persons. Outside the courtroom or by video recording made before the hearing.
- any other way – provided for by the evidence Act 2006 or any other relevant enactment.
- Definition of Hearsay statement, (p 9)
Key Words
MPOWOEPPTC
Stwm baP ottW aio iE itP tPtT oiC
in Exam 1 & 2
Hearsay statement
Key Words:
Made Person Otherthan Witness Offered Evidence Proceedings Prove Truth Contents
Statement that was made by a person other than the witness and is offered in evidence in the proceedings to prove the truth of its contents
- Definition of veracity (p9)
Key Words
DRLG/P
DoaP tRfL WG oiaP
Veracity
Key Words:
Disposition Refrain Lying Generally/Proceeding
disposition of a person to refrain from lying whether generally or in a proceeding
- Definition of Propensity (p9)
Key Words
ACW PSM IE ACEO PAI
EaaPP tAiaCW ohaP SOM aIEo
ACEoO
wwaP iA thbi
Propensity evidence
Key Words:
Act Certain Way-Particular State Mind-Including Evidence-Acts Circumstances Events Omissions
Person Alleged Involved
Evidence about a person’s propensity to act in a certain way or have a particular state of mind and includes evidence of:
Acts, Circumstances ,Events or Omissions,
with which a person is alleged to have been involved.
- Definition of Direct Evidence (p9)
Key Words
GbW Fii-SHOE
aE gbaW ataFii thos hSHoOE
Direct evidence
Key Words:
Given by Witness-Fact in Issue-Seen Heard Otherwise Experienced
Any evidence given by a witness as to a Fact in Issue that he or she has Seen Heard or Otherwise Experienced.
- Definition of Circumstantial Evidence (p9)
Key Words
CDDPAFiiAiEFD
EoC tdn DPaFii bwaia tE otF tbD
Circumstantial Evidence
Key Words
Circumstances-Don’t Directly Prove-Any Fact in issue-allows Inference-Existence Facts Drawn
Evidence of circumstances that do not directly prove any fact in issue but which allows inference about the existence of those facts to be drawn.
- Definition of Corroboration (p9)
Key Word
IECSF-OEG-IDCC
IE tTt CoSsF owoE ig aitD itCC
Corroboration
Key Words
Independent Evidence Confirm/Support Fact-Other Evidence Given-Implicates Defendant Crime Charged
Independent evidence that tends to confirm or support some fact of which other evidence is given and implicates the defendant in the crime charged
- What is the Woolmington Principle – The Presumption of Innocence (p10)
Key Words
FPCLPI
ESSSEBOPLCPREO
tFP ICL it PoI.
TPE tStSSE tBoP Lcwt PiR taot EotO
key Words:
Fundamental Principle Criminal Law Presumption Innocents.
Establishes Subject Specific Statutory Exceptions Burden of Proof Lies Clearly Prosecution Relation Elements Offence
The fundamental principle in criminal law is the presumption of innocents.
This principle establishes that subject to specific statuary exceptions the burden of proof lies clearly with the prosecution in relation to all of the elements of the offence.
- What was held in Woolmington v DPP
Key Words
PDPPGSGISE
BoPLPPEO
Pha DtPtPG SttD oIoaSE.
tBoP LCitH oPtPt EotO
In exam 1 & 2
Key Words:
Prosecution Duty Prove Prisoners Guilt Subject Defense Insanity/Statutory Exception.
Burden Proof Lies Prosecution Prove Elements Offence
prosecution has a duty to prove the prisoner’s guilt subject to the defense of Insanity OR any statutory exception. The burden of proof lies clearly in the hands of prosecution to prove the elements of the offence.
- Exceptions to the Principle that the burden of proof is on prosecution (p12)
Key Words
BoPRFoD
ALDI - SSEE - UASC
BoP RaF otDw:
- tAWt LaDoi
- SSEe
- UASC
Key Words: Burden of Proof Reverses Falls On Defendant Accused Lays Defense Insanity Specific Statutory Exception Exit Under Age Sex Cases
Burden of proof reverses and falls on the defendant when:
• The accused wishes to lay a defence of Insanity 23(1) CA61
• Specific statutory exceptions exist (202A weapons)
• Under age sex cases – under 16 s134 CA61
- MILLER v Minster of Pensions – Balance of Probabilities (p14)
Key Words
DRPPE BoP SS MPTN
wtDi RtP aPE sai oot BoP,
im SS tiim Ptn.
In Exam 1
key Words
Defense Required Prove Particular Element-Balance of Probabilities-Simply Show-More Probable than not
Where the defense is required to prove a particular element such as insanity or on the balance of probabilities it must simply show that it is more probable than not.
- What is the purpose of the Evidence Act?
Key Words
AHSJDP
iAt HStJ DoP
Key Words:
Aims Help Secure Just-Determination Proceedings
It aims to help secure the just determination of proceedings.
- 6 Purposes of the Evidence Act (p 17)
A. P FEAL R B. P RERiRA NZBoR A1990 a C . PFPW a D. PRCOPi a E. AUED a F. EALoE
In Exam 1
A) Providing for facts to be established by the application of logical rules and
B) By providing rules of evidence that recognise the importance of the rights affirmed by the NZ Bill of Rights Act 1990 and
C) Promoting fairness to parties and witness and
D) Protecting rights of confidentiality and other important public interests and
E) Avoiding unjustifiable expense and delay and
F) Enhancing access to the law of evidence
- Explain - Judicial Notice (p19)
Key Words
CJNFDFE o DJETENEFE
waCt JN oaF,
iD tiw ftFE,
ow DtJtDs eTEhnb EttFE.
Key Words:
Court Judical Notice Fact Delares Fact Exists
Directs Jury-Even Though Evidence-Not Established Fact Exists
When a court takes judicial notice of a fact, it declares that it will find that fact exists, or will direct the jury to do so even though evidence has not been established that the fact exists
What are the 4 principles Court refers to when deciding whether the evidence is admissible? (p26)
Key Words
RRUPI
In Exam 1 & 2
- Relevance
- Reliability
- Unfairness
- Public interest
- What is the test for Relevance?
Key Words
M-EOMFIICDP
P-ELTPDMPO
M aWtE itC iOoa Moa Fiio CttDo tP S7(3)
P aWtE haL TTPoD tMP o WiiO S7(3)
MC Exam 2
Key Words:
Materiality Evidence Offered Matter Fact In Issue Consequence Determination Proceedings
Probativeness Evidence Logical Tendency Prove/Disprove Material Propostion Offered
Materiality asks whether the evidence in the case is offered on a matter or a fact in issue of consequence to the determination of the proceedings s7 (3)
Probativeness asks whether the evidence has a logical tendency to prove or disprove the material proposition on which it is offered s 7 (3)
- Evidence can be relevant and yet inadmissible because it is unfair. In what two ways does it arise? (P22) – (fairness and general exclusion under s8)
Key Words
UPP
OCAAAU
ii whs UP it P
wih bOi Ct wm iAa tAU
In Exam 1
Key Words:
Unfair Prejudice in the Proceedings
Obtained Circumstances Admission against Accused Unfair
- If it would have some unfair prejudice in the proceedings
- Where It has been obtained in circumstances that would make its admission against the accused unfair.
- What is a Voir Dire? (p24)
Key Words:
S15 GEW PFN DEAP
S15 EA 2006 GEg baW tPtF NfD Wso Esb AiaP.
In Exam 1
Key Words:
S15 Governs Evidence Witness Prove Facts Necessary Deciding Evidence Admitted Proceeding
Section 15 evidence act 2006 governs evidence given by a witness to prove the facts necessary for deciding whether some other evidence should be admitted in a proceeding.
- Most of the laws of evidence concern the things that cannot be given in evidence. By and large they are based on common sense. What are the exclusive rules of evidence?
HOPVI IOE
In Exam 1
HOPVII
- Hearsay
- Opinion
- Propensity
- Veracity
- Identification
- Improperly obtained evidence
- What are the matters that the judge must consider when the veracity of a witness is questioned - section 37 (p30)
A. LoV otP otP wua LO tttt. B. taP hbC o1o MOt iaP fDo LoV. C. aPIS mbtP. D. Bop otP. E. Mop otP tBU.
Exam 2?
a) lack of veracity on the part of the person when under a legal obligation to tell the truth.
b) That a person has been convicted of 1 or more offences that indicate a propensity for dishonesty or lack of veracity
c) Any previous inconsistent statements made by the person
d) Bias on part of the person
e) Motive on part of the person to be untruthful
- In deciding whether to give permission for the prosecution to question / offer evidence, to the defendant about his or her veracity the judge may take into account Sec 38(3) - (p32)
A. tEtw tDV otVo aPW hbP iii tDE.
B. tTt hES aCa WtP StgE.
C. WaE gbtD aV wEbP.
a) The extent to which the defendant’s veracity or the veracity of a prosecution witness has been put in issue in the defendants evidence
b) The time that has elapsed since any conviction about which the prosecution seeks to give evidence
c) Whether any evidence given by the defendant about veracity was elected by prosecution
- What are the rules for Propensity (p33)
b) dniE oaA oOti -
ootE otO fwt Pib Tfo
tCoA it PiQ.
In this section and sections 41 to 43 the rules of propensity:
b) Does not include evidence of an act or omission that is –
• one of the elements of the offence for which the person is being tried for or
• The cause of action in the proceedings in question
- In relation to a statement by a person who is not a witness the Evidence Act defines circumstances as? - Section 16(1) (p42)
Key words: N C M V AO
A. t Not Sa B. t Cot Sa C. t CtR tt Mot Sa D. a CtR tt Vot Pa E. a CtR tt Aot OotP.
a) The nature of the statement and
b) The content of the statement and
c) The circumstances that relate to the making of the statement and
d) Any circumstances that relate to the veracity of the person and
e) Any circumstances that relate to the accuracy of the observation of the person.
- When is a witness deemed Unavailable? section 16 (2) (p41)
A. iD
B. iO NZ aiin RPf HoH tbaW o
C. iUt BaW BoA oP oMC o
D. in CtgE.
In Exam 1 & MC Exam 2
a) Is dead
b) Is outside NZ and it is not reasonably practicable for him or her to be a witness or
c) Is unfit to be a witness because of age or physical or mental condition or
d) Is not compellable to give evidence