Evidence Flashcards
Admissible
allowed to be presented at trial
Evidence is relevant if (2)
- it has any tendency to make a fact more or less probable than it would be without it AND 2. the fact is of consequence in determining the action
The court may exclude relevant evidence if its
probative value is substantially outweighed by a danger of unfair prejudice, misleading the jury, confusing the issues, undue delay, wasting time
Evidence of subsequent remedial measures is not admissible to prove (4)
- negligence
b) culpable conduct
c) a defect n a product or design
d) a need for a warning or instruction
Evidence of subsequent remedial measures is admissible to prove (4)
- impeachment
- control
- ownership4.
- feasibility
Statements and offers made during settlement negotiations are NOT admissible to (2)
- prove or disprove the validity or amount of a disputed claim OR
- impeach by a prior inconsistent statement or contradiction
Statements and offers made during settlement negotiations are admissible to prove (3)
- witness bias/prejudice
- negating a contention of undue delay
- proving obstruction of justice
Plea Negotiations: The following are NOT admissible against a D in a subsequent civil or criminal case (4)
- statements made during plea discussions
- a nolo contendere plea (D doesn’t admit to a dispute or charge)
- later withdrawn guilty plea
- statements made during an above 2 or 3 proceeding
Paying/offering to pay medical expenses are not admissible to prove liability for injury, but…..are admissible
related statements or factual admissions
Evidence of insurance or lack thereof is not admissible to prove culpability but it is admissible for other purposes (5)
witness bias/prejudice, agency, ownership, control, motive
How may physical evidence be authenticated (2)
through witness testimony or by evidenced that shows it has been held in a substantially unbroken chain of custody
Voice recordings may be authenticated by (2)
anyone who has heard the person speak and identified the recorded person as the speaker
Exceptions to the best evidence rule: the original writing, recording, or photograph is required to prove its content UNLESS (5)
- its a reliable duplicate (a photocopy)
- all the originals are lost or destroyed and not by the offering party acting in bad faith
- an original cannot be obtained by judicial process
- it was not produced after proper notice was given to the party in control and against whom it would be offered against, OR
- it’s not closely related to a controlling issue
Character evidence is generally not admissible to prove
propensity (that a person acted in conformity with a character trait on a particular occasion)
BUT, character evidence is generally allowed for (2)
- non-propensity purposes or when character is in issue— it’s an essential element or ultimate issue of a charge, claim, or defense (e.g. defamation, negligent entrustment)
In criminal cases, if a D’s character may offer evidence of their own character trait, the prosecution cannot offer character evidence of D unless D
first offers admissible evidence for that character trait (D “opens the door”)
Prosecution may introduce D’s prior acts of _______ or ______ when D is accused of such conduct
sexual assault/child molestation
In a non sex-offense case, a D may offer evidence of victim’s character (to establish a defense or show D’s innocence). If D presents such evidence, prosecution may offer evidence of (2)
victim’s good character (for the same trait) or D’s bad character (for the same trait)
In a homicide case, the prosecution may offer evidence of victim’s peacefulness only if
D claims victim was the first aggressor (self-defense)
Evidence is not admissible to prove a victim’s sexual behavior or predisposition except when (3)
- evidence of victim’s sexual behavior if offered to prove D was not involved in the sex crime (not the source of semen)
- evidence of sexual relations between D and victim either to prove consent (if offered by D) or for any reason (if offered by prosecution) OR
- if its exclusion violates D’s constitutional rights
In civil cases, character evidence to prove propensity is not/admissible
not admissible
In civil sex-offense cases, evidence of a victim’s sexual behavior or predisposition is admissible only if its probative value substantially outweighs the danger of (2)
harm to any victim AND unfair prejudice to any party
Specific acts or instances are only allowed (2)
- on cross of a character witness 2. if character in issue
Prior bad acts are admissible for non-propensity purposes (7)
motive, identity, absence of mistake/accident, intent, common plan or scheme, opportunity, or preparation
To offer such evidence of prior bad acts, the proponent must show that (3)
- the prior act was committed (by preponderance of evidence)
- the probative value substantially outweighs the danger of unfair prejudice AND
- proper notice in criminal cases (at least 15 days notice unless good cause shown)
Habit/routine practice
behavior that’s specific, repeated, and reflexive, that is admissible to show that a person (or organization) acted in accordance with their habit or routine practice
Impeachment
attack witness’s credibility at trial
Prior inconsistent statements are admissible to impeach a witness. Need not ____ contacts of the statement to witness during examination, but must _____ to adverse party’s attorney upon request
show
Extrinsic evidence is admissible only if 2
relevant to material issue at trial (one other than witness’s credibility) AND proper foundation is shown (witness is first given an opportunity to explain or deny the statement and an adverse party is given an opportunity to examine a witness about it )
*****Does not apply when extrinsic evidence offered against party opponent
Evidence of a prior felony or misdemeanor involving dishonest are always admissible to
impeach
Other misdemeanors are not/admissible to impeach
not admissible
In civil and criminal cases, felonies that do not involve dishonesty are admissible if
witness is not a criminal defendant
In criminal cases, felonies that do not involve dishonesty are admissible if D is the witness but only if
probative value outweighs any prejudicial effect
10 year exception
If ten years have passed (from conviction or release from jail, whichever is later), the conviction is not admissible unless its probative value outweighs its prejudicial effect and the proponent provides reasonable written notice to the adverse party
A felony is a crime punishable by (2)
death or imprisonment over a year
A witness’s credibility may be attacked on cross with specific instances of conduct (Prior bad acts) ONLY IF the
conduct is probative of the witness’s character for truthfulness or untruthfulness
_____ evidence is never admissible to attack or support the instances of a witness’s credibility
extrinsic