Evaluating An Argument Quiz Flashcards
Which option presents a complete and effective evaluation of Dan DeLuca’s argument in his article “Dylan’s Nobel Prize Settles Debate: Rock Lyrics Are Poetry”?
DeLuca believes that rock lyrics must be recognized as poetry because legendary singer-songwriter Bob Dylan has been awarded the Nobel Prize for Literature. In doing so, the Nobel committee has recognized the value of Dylan’s words, which have spoken for and inspired generations since the 1960s. DeLuca uses credible facts and research to support his claim
Read the excerpt from Parvati’s argument in favor of using cell phones in class.
Today’s cell phones are not just phones; they are little computers. That means they are effective research tools. Students can use them to access dictionaries, encyclopedias, and other reference materials. They can search for articles, videos, and images. In my civics class, our teacher even held mock elections, and we voted using our cell phones.
What is the best evaluation of Parvati’s evidence?
It is relevant and sufficient, because she gives convincing examples of how phones support classwork
Read Gunther’s evaluation of an argument.
In his editorial “Better Safe Than Sorry?: Revisiting the Debate over Capital Punishment,” Nemo Jones effectively lays out his argument that the death penalty should be abolished. In his thorough examination of the evidence, he presents authoritative case studies of people whose innocence was proven too late and of criminals who were undeterred by thoughts of capital punishment. He examines comprehensive statistics regarding these groups and summarizes years of interviews with officials in government, law enforcement, and the penal system. His final paragraphs contain the most emotionally persuasive evidence, as he relates the lasting effects on the children of those who have been put to death.
Which element is missing from this evaluation?
A concluding statement
What is the function of a claim in an argument?
To state the writer’s opinion
Which sentences would be effective thesis statements for a paragraph evaluating an argument? Select two options.
C and D
Read the introduction to Samantha’s argument.
My friends like going to fast food restaurants. It’s not that I mind, but I’m a vegan, and these restaurants offer few things that I can eat. Even salads contain ingredients like cheese, eggs, and ham. What’s more, there may be cream or gelatin in the dressing. Sometimes all I can do is order something to drink, while my friends enjoy their meals. By not offering vegan meals, fast food restaurants are missing out on additional sales.
Which statement summarizes Samantha’s claim?
Fast food restaurants would profit from offering vegan meals
Read Colin’s argument.
Nowadays, one often hears complaints that drones can invade people’s privacy. But this is not true. Flying drones is actually a sport. It requires coordination and technical skills like other sports. In fact, there should be professional drone-flying leagues. If people recognized this sport, they would no longer complain about where and when drone owners flew their drones.
Is Colin’s evidence relevant to his claim?
No, because it is about flying drones being a sport, not about privacy issues
Read Lola’s argument that post-secondary degrees are beneficial.
It seems like every high school student is expected to further their education after high school. Some teenagers resent the pressure this expectation puts on them. But we teens have to be realistic. A college degree or skilled trade certificate is necessary in today’s world.
75% of new jobs today require job applicants to have a college degree. Many jobs require specific skills acquired through courses geared to that profession. Of course, not every job requires the exact subject matter you learned at college. But employers are looking for people with perseverance, analytical skills, and the ability to communicate. Those are the things you will learn during your years at college or in an apprenticeship.
What is the best evaluation of the evidence Lola provides?
The evidence is relevant and sufficient because the main reason people continue their education is to gain skills to find a job and support themselves
In “Water Flowing from Toilet to Tap May Be Hard to Swallow,” what reasons does Schwartz give to support his claim? Select two options.
B and E
Which claims are supported by relevant evidence? Select two options.
A and D
