Evaluate The Veiw That The Hol Is Undemocratic And Undermines Uk Politics Flashcards
For: undemocratic because unelected
Appointed by gov on merit and can inherit positions
As of 2021 92 hereditary peers remain in hol making descisions on our behalf even though we didn’t choose this
Therefore lack direct accountability to ppl
Against: democratic even though unelected
The fact that they are appointed by merit ensures a range of diverse backgrounds and experiences seen in hol
As of 2024 700 life peers remain showing 700 diff perspectives
For: limited representation
Members are drawn from elitist groups like former judges or business leaders which are likely to be men
Lords gender balance report stated that as of 2023 70% of hol members are men
Against: limited representation doesn’t undermine democracy
This is bcs the hol was designed to be a place for expertise debate on complex issues which require specialist knowledge therefore should be populated by ppl w valuable insights
Prior to 2021 40% of hol is made up of former judges, solicitors which highlights the legal knowledge
For: undemocratic because limited accountability
Members of hol are not subjected to regular elections or direct public scrutiny compared to hoc
Undermines democratic principles because those in power should be held accountable
2020 yougov poll 68% of the public supported the idea of introducing elected representatives
Against: are not scrutinised but scrutinise gov
Although they are not subject to scrutiny by public, the importance lies within their role of scrutinising the gov ensuring that legislation proposed is the best for the public
2017-18 gov introduced the eu withdrawal bill where the hol suggested 300 amendments
