Ethnic Conflict Flashcards
Stefan Wolff
there are no automatics that lead from the existence of different ethnic groups to violent conflicts between them
definition of ethnicity
specific to time, place, and culture in which it is constructed, and to the individuals shaping its meaning
1938 Munich Agreement
- four signatory states agreed to abandon minority protection provided for by Paris Peace Treaties in favour of rearranging borders of Europe along ethnic lines
- one-sided expulsions under German occupation and chain of ethnic cleansing linking several countries in Nazi-ruled Europe were unprecedented
1942: British revocation of Munich Agreement
- symbolised turn away from appeasement and promised to restore integrity of Czechoslovakia
- also agreed “transfer” of large part of German minority in Czechoslovakia
post-WW2 Allies determined to create homogenous nation-states in entire larger region of East Central Europe
12m Germans, millions of Poles, and many Ukrainians, Byelorussians, and Hungarians shifted around Europe
1945: Soviet Union allowed return of most Hungarian refugees to Transylvania
- Stalin as ruthless tactician
- matter of power politics: harder to stabilise regimes and establish Communist state when millions of uprooted people in streets
Treaty of Neuilly
- set precedent in both international law regulations and practice execution of “population exchange”
- provided for minority populations on either side of Greek-Bulgarian border to change places
- ethnic homogenisation by means of forced emigration was coupled with demographics transformation by means of purposeful settlement
Treaty of Lausanne
- marked turning point by lifting constraints on geographic range of ethnic cleansing
- provided for ethnic cleansing of two entire nation-states
- formalised the policy of population exchange as a legitimate diplomatic solution to domestic issues
- made permanent the exodus of Christians from Turkey (1.5m), and initiated the new exodus of Muslims from Greece (350,000)
ethnic nationalism
- describes the ways in which the “nation” is defined in terms of ethnicity: by a shared heritage, common language, common faith, and common ethnic ancestry
- new postwar governments sought to rationalise and control societies by making them ethnically homogenous and fully responsive to the needs and goals of the dominant nationality
Yugoslavia
- 1980: death of Josip Broz Tito created vacuum, constituent republics became important power centres
- mid-1980s: Milosevic began to reassert Serb power in Kosovo and Vojvodina, exploited opportunity
- rise of Serbian nationalism motivated by fear of marginalisation and discrimination
- Milosevic as central catalyst: political entrepreneur willing to manipulate ethnic identity and social divines to create a powerful tool to mobilise people for personal political gain
- use of mass expulsion, ensured permanent ethnic domination; goal of Serb policy in Bosnia after 1992
nationality problem
different ethnic identities can exist within the same state, but different nationalisms cannot
How many Germans resettled 1939-442?
500,000
How many expelled or deported from territories annexed by Nazi Germany 1940-41?
1.3m
Phillip Ther
- fashionable in last decade to focus research on destructive impact of individuals or groups and their misdeeds rather than state institutions
- however case studies show it was largely in the hands of the great powers