Ethics Flashcards
What would you do when faced with an ethical dilemma?
Refer to the RICS ethics decision tree
*Decision tree = framework of questions to consider legality of my actions / consistency with RICS Rules of Conduct
*Decision Tree Steps - HINT= Fish Love Red Coral Reefs, PDAs are Rude
> Facts? - Separate facts from mine or other’s emotional responses
Legal? - If unsure seek further advice
Rules?
Consult - with appropriate people - consider all risks / options
Reasoned/Informed decision?
Press?
Decide
Act
Reflect + Record
*Could also use RICS Regulation Confidential Hotline
What is the purpose of the RICS regulating its members and firms?
- To protect the public
- To uphold professional standards and public confidence in the profession
What may trigger or give rise to a disciplinary procedure?
- Complaint to the RICS
- Information received or established by RICS
- Allegation by a client or third party
Not all shortcomings by firms/members will result in disciplinary proceedings but firms/members will be asked to justify their actions -recording part of ethics decisions tree/all decision making is super important
HINT - CIA
What are the different levels of disciplinary action?
- Action by Head of Regulation - Initial investigation
- Regulatory Tribunal (lay members)
- Appeal Panel (lay members)
- reviews old/new evidence & can allow appeal and vary penalty imposed
HINT - ARA
What actions can be imposed if disciplinary action is required following an initial investigation by the Head of Regulation?
> Fixed Penalty Notice
RCO
Refer to single member or Regulatory Tribunal
Refer to directly to Regulatory Tribunal Disciplinary Panel
HINT - FRRR
What are fixed penalties and when are they applicable?
> Breaches to Rules relating only to the supply of information to the RICS by firms/members
> May consist of a fine and / or caution
What is a Regulatory Compliance Order and when is it applicable?
> Low-level breaches of any Rule
> Written document stating corrective actions firms must take or restrain them from taking certain actions for a specified time
> May include agreement to pay fine
What is the Regulatory Tribunal Disciplinary Panel and when is it applicable?
> Serious breaches to Rules of Conduct
> Panel includes lay members
> 5 penalties it can impose
1. Regulatory Compliance Order (RCO)
2. Fine per breach (unlimited but proportionate to offence)
3. Condition of continued membership or registration
4. Expulsion of member/firm
5. Publication of hearing results in RICS Modus/website/local paper
Give at least 2 examples of a breach of the Rules of Conduct where expulsion would be a suitable penalty imposed by the Regulatory Tribunal Disciplinary Panel?
Gross, persistent or willful failure to comply with an RICS rule of conduct
e.g. fraud, dishonesty, conviction of a serious criminal offence, gross incompetence, deliberate discrimination, misappropriation of a client’s money
When would the RICS likely investigate concerns about social media posts?
> RICS Regulation paper on the Use of Social Media: Guidance for RICS Members (Version 1)
> RICS may investigate a social media post that adversely impacts upon public confidence or trust in the profession such as posts that are:
- Discriminatory (which would also breach the Equality Act 2010),
- Dishonest
- Abusive or threatening
- Bullying, harassing or victimizing another person or people
> RICS unlikely to investigate posts that are:
- critical of an organization’s policies or performance rather than individuals
- use professional/respectful language
- removed if requested to do so
> RICS can take disciplinary action to protect public or profession reputation
> Personal posts by members may also be investigate if they are highly offensive and may cause reputational damage to profession
Give an example of social media activity that could cause reputational damage to the profession.
> Personal racist post
Posts that are bias against ethic minorities
When was the RICS founded?
1868
When did the RICS receive its Royal Charter and what is a Royal Charter?
1881
> Royal document
Gives organization right to govern own affairs - don’t have to answer to the Privy Council
Defines organizations objectives & constitution
What are the different levels of RICS membership?
- FRIC
- MRICS
- AssocRICS
- Trainee/Student
How do you become a fellow of the RICS?
> Must demonstrate 4/5 Fellow characteristics
- at least 5 years of being a MRICS
2/3. professional/technical/academic achievement - leadership role
- raise profile of RICS
> Must provide supporting portfolio of professional achievement including CPD record
Talk to me about the governance structure of the RICS
> Governed by various boards, associations and councils as per terms of Royal Charter
> UK Structure - x4 National Boards, 10 Regional Boards, Local associations
> Boards/Committees report to Governing Council e.g. Management Board/Regulatory Board
> Governing Council chaired by RICS president Ann Gray
> RICS CEO = Richard Collins
> Governing Council has 21 members
> 17 professional groups covering property, land & construction - responsible for setting professional standards and best practice
Talk to me about Levitt’s Review 2021
> exposed lack of Clarity, Governance and Strategy of RICS
> called for review of PSG - Purpose, Governance & Strategy of RICS - Bichard review 2022
What are the major challenges currently facing the RICS & recent initiatives?
> Levitt Review exposed lack of Purpose, Governance and Structure
> RICS commissioned Lord Michael Bichard (2022) to
- clarify purpose of RICS
- provide recommendations on governing structure to achieve purpose
- make proposals for future culture and strategy
What is the role of the RICS?
M-P-B
> Maintain highest standards of education and training
Protect consumers through strict regulation of professional standards
Be the leading source of information and independent advice on land, property, construction and associated envrinmental issues
What were the key recommendations from the Bichard Review?
1/2. Public Interest - more focus on Public Interest - Royal Charter amended to create Public Interest panel to advise Governing Council + independent review of if RICS is acting for public advantage
- Maintain self-regulation - more independence of Regulatory functions
- More focus on D+I
- Empowering members - greater support for regional boards/ increased member engagement with focus on younger members
- Simpler, Clearer & Accountable governance structure
- Greater leadership on issues such as sustainability/climate change
P-I-M-D/E-S-G
> Please Investment More Dough in ESG
What are the benefits of becoming an RICS member?
Ruth Knows My New Secret = R-K-M-N-S
- Recognition
- Knowledge
- Market advantage
- Network (+137,500 members)
- Status
What are the benefits of RICS regulation for firms?
Polly Can’t Shoot = P-C-S
- Confidence for clients - ‘gold standard’ from regulation
- Professionalism from firms who have to provide clear/impartial expert advice
- Security for firms from recognized complaints procedure, access to PII cover
What are the firm requirements for RICS regulation?
> RICS members - if 50% of Principals are members then must be regulated, if 25% can apply to be
> Annual return confirming compliance with RICS obligations incl. info on:
1. Type of business/staffing details
2. Statutory regulated activities
3. Nature of clients
4. Complaints handling procedure details & records
5. PII details
6. Whether firm holds clients money
HINT - Tell Siana No Coke Pills Weed - T-S-N-C-P-W
> Regulated firms must have a Responsible Principle to ensure compliance with regulations & report to RICS (Savills RP = Nicola McGinnis - ‘Nick drinking Guinness’)
What is the RICS approach to regulating firms?
To protect consumers and maintain trust in the profession through ensuring members and firms comply strictly to standards
When were the Rules of Conduct published & why were they updated?
> October 2021
> replaced Rules of Conduct for Members and Firms + 5 Global Professional and ethical Standards
> Updated to provide simpler/clearer structure (example behaviors for each rule) + focus on D&I/Technology/Global challenges
What are the RICS Rules of Conduct?
B-M-P-T-A - Be Mindful Prior To Acting
Members and firms must…
- Be honest, act with integrity and comply with RICS obligations
- Maintain professional competence and ensure services are provided by competent individuals who have the necessary expertise
- provide a good-quality and diligent service
- Treat others with respect and encourage D&I
- Act in the public interest, take responsibility for their actions, act tp prevent harm and maintain public confidence in the profession
What is Rule 1 of the RICS Rules of Conduct and what are some example associated behaviors?
Members and firms must be honest, act with integrity and comply with their professional and RICS obligations
Members and firms…
> do not mislead others by their actions or omissions or being complicit in those of others
> do not allow themselves to be influences improperly by others or by their own self interest
> are open and transparent with clients about their fees
What is Rule 2 of the RICS Rules of Conduct and what are some example associated behaviors?
Members and firms must maintain professional competence & ensure that services are provided by competent individuals with the necessary expertise.
Members and firms…
> ensure they have the necessary knowledge, skills and resources required to carry out work - check that employees/subcontractors carrying out work for them also do
> CPD - maintain and develop knowledge and skills throughout their career
> reflect on the work they have undertaken and what they can learn from it and apply it to future work
What is Rule 3 of the RICS Rules of Conduct and what are some example associated behaviors?
Members and firms must provide a good-quality and diligent service.
Members and firms…
> understand their client’s needs and objectives before undertaking any work for them
> agree the scope, limitations and timescales of work to be provided with the client
> communicate in a clear and timely manner with clients in all circumstances, particularly if there is a change in the TOE or estimated costs/fees
> have effective quality control processes for work
> check that all data used is accurate and up to date, kept securely and they have the proper legal right to use it
What is Rule 4 of the RICS Rules of Conduct and what are some example associated behaviors?
Members and firms must treat others with respect and encourage D&I.
Members and firms…
> respect the rights of others and treat others with courtesy
> treat everyone fairly and do not discriminate against anyone on any improper grounds such as age/disability/gender reassignment/pregnancy/race/religion/sexual orientation
> do not bully/victimize/harass anyone
> work cooperatively with others
What is Rule 5 of the RICS Rules of Conduct and what are some example associated behaviors?
Members and firms must act in the public interest, take responsibility for their actions and act to prevent and maintain public confidence in the profession.
Members and firms…
> must question practices and decisions they suspect are not right and raise concerns with appropriate persons such as colleagues/senior staff/clients/RICS - firms should provide processes for staff to raise concerns to senior management
> support those that have raised concerns
> ensure public statements made do not undermine public confidence in the profession
> take appropriate action if they think rules of conduct have been breached and report any significant breaches to the RICS
> cooperate with investigations and provide any necessary info
What does Appendix A of the RICS Rules of Conduct 2021 provide?
Core obligations for members and firms - additional professional obligations are found in the mandatory requirements of RICS professional statements relevant to specific practices.
What are the core professional obligations for members? (Appendix A - Rules of Conduct 2021)
Members must…
- Comply with RICS CPD requirements
- Cooperate with RICS
- Promptly provide all information reasonably requested by the Standards and Regulation Board
What are the core professional obligations for firms? (Appendix A - Rules of Conduct 2021)
RICS-regulated firms must…
- Cooperate with RICS (same as members obligations)
- Provide all info promptly to Standards and Regulation Board (same as members obligations)
- Publish a complaints handling procedure INCLUDING RICS approved ADR provider + maintain complaints log
- Ensure all past and present work is covered by adequate/appropriate PII approved by RICS
- Arrange alternatives if there is just one sole principal so that professional work can continue in the event of incapacity/death/absence
- Display on business literature that they are regulated by RICS (in accordance with RICS policy)
- Report to RICS on any matter required under Rules for the Registration of Firms
Talk to me about fee negotiations
Fee negotiations
> firms must avoid price fixing/aggressive fee cutting/collusion with competitors
- x4 Somerset estate agents were prosecuted and fined by CMA for colluding in 2017
> can negotiate fee with clients but must do so in professional manner
> granting/accepting referral fees should be clearly stated in TOE and considered with regard to Bribery Act 2010 and RICS Rules of Conduct 2021
What steps should you follow when looking to take on a new instruction?
C-I-T
- check professionally competent
- establish no conflicts of interest or personal interests
- Confirm TOE in writing & get signed by client BEFORE starting work
What must be stated in all TOE?
> proposed fee basis
> payments of expenses (and how calculated)
> that copy of firms complaints handing procedure is available upon request
How does the Consumer Rights Act 2015 affect TOE?
Allows 14 day cooling off period from date of agreement