English Legal System + Law Making Flashcards
What are the 3 sources of law?i
Statute, common and custom law
What is statute law and state an example
Statute law is law that is made by parliament. It helps enforce parliamentary sovereignty.
E.g. criminal attempts act 1981
What is common law and state an example?
Common law is law that is made by the courts (judges) when they decide cases
E.g. r v Cunningham
What is custom law?
Custom law is a body of unwritten law based on legal precedents established by the courts
- least common source of law
What is parliamentary sovereignty?
Parliamentary sovereignty makes parliament the supreme legal authority in the UK, which can create or end any law. It states that law made by parliament is the highest form of law.
What is the acronym for why we use statutory interpretation?
INTERPRET
What does the N in INTERPRET mean?
New unforeseen situations may arise
What does the T stand for in INTERPRET in statutory interpretation?
Technological advances may mean that old statutes do not cover modern day issues
What does P stand for in INTERPRET in statutory interpretation?
Passage of time means word changes in meaning.
What are the 3 rules in statutory interpretation?
- The literal rule
- The golden rule
- The mischief rule
What is the literal rule?
The literal rule is when words in statute are given their ordinary, literal, dictionary meaning, even if the result is absurd
What case is used in the literal rule?
Whitely V Chappell
What is an advantage of the literal rule?
It upholds parliamentary sovereignty as parliament’s words are followed exactly.
What is a disadvantage of the literal rule?
Words can have more than one meaning and the literal rule does not take this into account
What is the golden rule?
It is used when the literal rule produces an absurd result, the judge should alter the words to produce a satisfactory result.
What are the 2 approaches in the golden rule?
The narrow and wide view
What is the narrow view?
The narrow view is where the word has more than one possible meaning, then the court can chose the more suitable meaning to avoid absurdity.
What is the case that is used in the narrow view?
R v Allen
What is the wide view?
The wide view is where words that have only one clear meaning would make the outcome absurd, the court can modify (change) the meaning to avoid absurdity.
What is the case that is used in the wide view?
Re sigsworth
State an advantage of the golden rule
The golden rule provides an escape route from the absurd outcomes of the literal rule.
What is a disadvantage of the golden rule?
It is limited to being used only when the literal rule would lead to an absurd outcome.
What is the mischief rule?
The mischief rule is when the judges can ignore the wording of the statute to react to the desired outcome
What is the leading case for the mischief rule?
The leading case is r v heydon
- it provides 4 elements that the court would need to consider