Employee Stock Options, Stock Plans and Nonqualified Deferred Compensation Flashcards
Basic provisions and differences from qualified plans
Nonqualified
- may discriminate
- exempt from ERISA
- no ER tax deduction until EE is taxed
- earnings may be taxable to ER
- distributions taxable ordinary (except ISO)
Qualified
- may not discriminate
- many ERISA requirements
- immediate ER tax deduction for contributions
- earnings grow tax deferred
- distributions taxable ordinary (except 10 yr av. and NUS under stock bonus or ESOP)
Choosing to offer nonqualified plans
- when ER wants to provide additional benefits to executive who is already receiving max benefits under ER qualified retirement plan
Salary reduction plans
aka. pure deferred compensation arrangements
- use some portion of EE current compensation to fund the ultimate compensation benefit
Salary continuation plans
- uses ER contributions to fund the ultimate compensation
Unfunded plans
requirements for unfunded deferred comp and nonqualified stock based comp
1. Must be unfunded
- naked promise: (promise to pay)
- informally funded: LI, annuity, MF, other investments (owned by company and subject to their creditors)
2. EE has no access to the comp that has been deferred
3. no ER tax deductions until EE is taxed
4. EE taxed when they have constructive receipt or economic benefit
Life insurance and section 162
- used an informal funding vehicle because CV is not taxed
- premiums for nonqualified deferred comp taxed as follows
- ER owns policy and will be beneficiary
- premiums not deductible
- DB paid to ER not taxable (bc premiums were not deductible)
- benefits paid to EE or surviving dependents is deductible to ER
- benefits paid to EE or surviving dependents is deferred comp and taxable
- PV included in EE gross estate
Rabbi trust
requirements
- assets must be available to all general creditors of ER
- participant cant have greater rights than other unsecured creditors
- have clear rules for when benefits will be paid
- company must notify trustee of any bankruptcy or hardship - trustee must suspend payment to trust beneficiary for creditors
When Rabbi trusts are used
- ownership/ management may change before deferred comp benefits are paid (takeover/acquisition)
- new management may be hostile to key employees in future and fail to honor agreement
- litigation to enforce payment in future would be too costly
Secular trusts
- addresses 2 problems with nonqualified deferred comp plans
1. lack of security in relying on informally funded plans
2. fear that tax savings will disappear if tax rates in retirement are higher - irrevocable trust for exclusive benefit of EE
- beyond reach of ER creditors
- taxed in year funds placed in trust and ER gets deduction that year (or when substantial risk of forfeiture no longer exists)
- funded nonqualified comp
Tax implications - informal funding
- ER taxation
1. funds set aside to fund plan taxed at corporate level
2. earnings on funds may create additional tax - if annuity is held by entity (not natural person) rules change and income is taxed ordinary in year
Constructive receipt
- income is taxable in year it is paid or made available to taxpayer
- not constructively received if taxpayers control is subject to substantial risk of forfeiture
Substantial risk of forfeiture
- when EE rights to enjoyment of property are conditioned upon performance of services for a period of time
- 2 tests
1. EE relationship to other stockholders and the degree of their potential control
2. EE relationship to corporate officers
Economic benefit doctrine
- if any economic benefit is conferred on an individual by ER as compensation in a taxable year then it is taxable to individual
Employee stock options - basic provisions
- employee stock options enable employees to buy shares of ER stock at a specified price
Funded vs informally funded (unfunded) plans
- if deferred comp plan is not a naked promise to pay for income tax purposes then its funded
- two determinants of taxation
1. free transferability of EE interest
2. presence of substantial risk of forfeiture at time of contribution made by ER
Company restrictions
- stock plans can be designed to benefit anyone
- usually not offered by small closely held corporations
- usually dont want to share ownership of the business
- often used where ownership of broad or company is publicly traded