Elections Flashcards
What are the three functions of elections?
To form government, ensure representation and uphold legitimacy
How may elections not be successful in forming governments?
Often, through use of proportional representation (or even very rarely under FPTP) a single ‘winning’ party is not found, and so deals must be made to form a coalition between two or more parties.
How do elections ensure representation?
They create a strong link between constituents and representatives, and also a strong link between the government and public opinion. This is ensured by making politicians removable and accountable to the public.
Why might elections not ensure representation?
- There are conflicting theories of what it means for politicians to represent the electorate
- 5 year terms weaken the constituents and representatives, because they are too long.
How do elections ensure legitimacy?
Elections uphold legitimacy by providing a ritualised means through which citizens consent to being governed, by voting.
How do elections NOT uphold legitimacy?
- Low turnout levels imply lack of consent, so no legitimacy
Define an election and explain what makes it different to a referendum
Elections are intended to form a government whereas referendums make singular policy decisions. When you vote in an election you vote for a party that has views on many policies, whereas a referendum you vote on one single issue. Referendums are direct, Elections are representative democracy.
Define Representation
Representation is a relationship through which an individual or a group acts on behalf of a larger body of people.
What are the three main theories of electoral representation?
‘Doctrine of the Mandate’, Burkean Trusteeship and Descriptive.
How does Burkean representation/Trusteeship work as a theory of representation?
Representatives should use their own better judgement and expertise to make decisions that are best for their constituents, rather than listening to their constituents’ potentially ill-advised opinions.
How has Burkean/Trusteeship Representation been criticised?
- MPs may act out of self interest, which is not at all representative
- Due to the whip system, trusteeship is now no longer applicable in any scenario except backbench revolts.
How does Doctrine of the Mandate work as a theory of representation?
It says that an elected government is given the authority and legitimacy to represent the public because it gained a ‘popular’ mandate. Thus, the entire party, not individual candidates, represent the public.
What are the criticisms of Doctrine of the Mandate?
- It assumes votes rationally, basing their decisions only on policy
- A vote for a party does not necessitate support for the entire manifesto
- There is no way of forcing governments to carry out manifestos once elected
- Does not work in Coalitions (e.g. Lib Dems with Tuition Fees)
How does the ‘descriptive/microcosm’ theory work as a theory of representation?
The composition of parliament/the government should be a microcosm of society to ensure needs are proportionately met; containing all races, social classes, genders, etc. in the same proportion as in society.
What are the criticisms of Descriptive/Microcosm Representation?
- a microcosm represents the weaknesses of a society as well as the strengths.
- it cannot really happen without limiting electoral choice, which weakens the integrity of democracy.
What are the main feature of FPTP, or any simple plurality system?
FPTP is a majoritarian system that works with a simple plurality on a constituency level, where a candidate only needs one more vote than any other party to win. The party with a majority of seats overall ‘wins’ and forms a government.
Where is FPTP used?
The General Election?
Where is AMS used?
The Scottish Parliament, Welsh Assembly and Greater London Assembly
Where is STV used?
Northern Ireland Assembly
Where is Regional List used?
EU Parliament Elections
Where is SV/AV used?
London Mayor (SV) and Scottish by-elections (AV)
How does AMS work?
Mix of Regional List and FPTP. Hybrid system. Voters get a Constituency vote and regional vote. Regional vote is calculated with the D’Hont method.