education theory Flashcards
consensus and marxist perspective
Consensus- creates useful citizens. meritocratic. individual strengths are nurtures and maximised.
X legitimates hegemonic british culture
X system modelled on white christian student
X myth of meritocracy
Marxist - part of super structure, produces docile workers
X creates a population unaware of discrimination
X prepares a section of workforce for failure
the system in addressing ethnic inequalities
promotes a positive multicultural society
teaches to accomodate ethnic differences
key context to challenge discrimination
facilitates social mobility
- need a critical perspective for this to happen,
self help approaches
- used to bridge the gap
- Rollock et al 2014, BME parents show high levels of educational support
- BME tradition of supplementary saturday schooling
problems of the underachiever argument
reproduces stereotypes
self fulfilling prophecy and reinforces low expectations
suggests some groups are less able
assumes there is a level playing field
traditional focus with social class
preoccupied with social class in explaining educational inequality
less straight forward
e/g bangladeshi students have high amount on FSM but also have high achievement.
Bourdieu’s concepts
Habitus- our socialisation process and inbuilt radar on how to respond to and act within situations
Cultural capital- skill and knowledge to give advantage
social policy
1981 Rampton report - recognised racism in schools
1985 Swann Report - recommended multiculturalism
1988 Education Reform act - national curriculum and promotion of british values
1999 Macpherson report- schools required to report racist incidents to the local education authority
1950-1960s
assimilation
monoculturalism
dispersal
1970-1980s
multiculturalism VS antiracism approaches
policy war
reinforced racialised otherness
Educational subnormality
consequence of assimilation
problem of afrocaribbean pupils:
-racialised interpretation of behaviour
-3x more likely to have behavioural problems
Social and political construction of the dysfunction of black families
2000s
race and racism marginalised as a special concern
racism not routinely investigated by OFSTED
fundmental british values policy 2014:
-rule of law
-individual liberty
-mutual respect
-tolerance of others
migration related factors
may have to go away and miss school for family
length of settlement and schooling
X no established link
X blames children
X detracts from structural reasons for underachievement
cultural and religious factors
constrains on the inclusion and participation of girls
absences due to religious celebration
values and aspirations of school arent same as religions
X no established link
X blames children and families and forces them to change
X neglects the value migrants place on education
X 32% faith schools got outstanding for community relations. Only 16% for non faith (OFSTED)
Ability (IQ)
Hernstein and Murray
Control thesis of a cognitive elite developing in the US
Intelligence = genes + environment
X IQ tests are ethnocentric
X racialised categories are social constructions
X socioeconomic background has clearer effect on IQ.
Cultural deficit theory
deficient/ dysfunctional cultures
too much family (southasian) too little family (afrocaribbean)
racialisation of african caribbean as anti education
X essentialises culture
X reinforces stereotypes and low expectations
X blames children and Families
X detracts from structural reasons.