EC104 Flashcards
Malthusian Model Key Features
- Land is in fixed supply
- Diminishing returns to labour
- Theory failed due to assumption that increases in income always lead to increasing number of children
- Assumed shocks to income are intermittent
Assumed that shocks to income are eaten by population growth- failure to see gains in labour productivity and specialisation
Smithian Model Key Features
- Specialisation is central to growth
- Gains from trade linked to specialisation
- Division of labour
- Good institutions linked to specialisation
- Tech change linked to specialisation
Lewis Model Key Features
- Splits economy into traditional sector and modern sector
- Traditional sector is agriculture and modern sector is manufacturing
- Labour can move freely from traditional to modern at a low cost
- Cheap labour from traditional sector means high profits due to reduced labour costs in the modern sector
- Modern sector profits reinvested
Solow-Swan Model Key Feautres
- Tech change exogenous to model
- Temporary rapid growth from capital accumulation
- Eventually economies reach a steady state rate of growth
Becker’s Q-Q Model for Children
- Explains the market for children
- As income increases, quantity demand for children falls (negative income elasticity for demand for quantity of children)
- As income increases, quality demand for children increases (positive income elasticity demand for the quality of children)
- Explains why population growth does not eat up income growth
Unified Growth Theory
- Tech change is a function of population and education
- Level of tech change determines returns to education
- Malthusian state characterised by slow tech growth, benefits of tech change offset by pop growth
- Higher levels of education generate higher tech change and this feeds back through to education
New Institutional Economics (NIE)
- English Language
- Religion
- Property rights
- Legal System
- Social Capital
New Economic Geography (NEG)
- Market potential
- Transport costs
- Distance to equator
- Miles of coastline
- Resource curse
Tropics Theory
Hall and Jones, 1999
- Distance to equator plays a role
- Tropics determined settlement patterns in Europe
- Wester European institutions came with migrants
Germs Theory (AJR)
- Good institutions in areas with low settler mortality (less germs and diseases)
- Bad institutions in areas with high settler mortality (more germs and diseases)
Crops Theory
Engerman and Sokoloff
- ‘Ba d’ institutions were set up in areas of high pop density- Asia
- ‘Good’ institutions were set up in areas of low pop density
Criticism of institutional view
Sachs 2003
- Better to focus on reducing disease, increasing transport links and prevent depletion of soil nutrients than to improve institutions
- Subtler differences may not be explained by institutions
Geography view 2003
Sachs 2003 lack of coal deposits lack of dry season high transport costs disease conditions
Geography View 2004
Sachs et al., 2004 distance to coast dependence on neighbours infrastructure cross boarder relations access to markets
Geography Trade 1990
Schedvin 1990
countries with ideal conditions for wheat did better
wheat prices drove boom in late 19C
Revisionist View of Great Divergence
- product of 19C IR
- due to coal, colonial policy and historical shocks
- reject reliability of income dat, use national accounting instead
Traditionalist View of Great Divergence
- NW Europe ahead at an early stage due to its institutions
- commercial expansion
- urbanisation
- agricultural productivity
- high wages
- cheap energy
- argue that wage comparison doesn’t make sense because developed countries’ food prices are higher- would have to adjust prices into a basket of comparable goods
Traditional School suggestions for Europe diverging from Asia
- China less urbanised
- China expensive energy
- China poor institutions, cultural and government
- China less innovative
- China different demographic patterns
- China had higher births and deaths
- China had lower real wages due to institutions governing marriage
- Europe had higher FAFM
- Europe had higher celibacy
Hajnal Study
- study on fertility
- Western Europe had lower marriage rate and higher FAFM
- NW Europe limited fertility within marriage
- confirmed that western Europe relied on preventative checks
Theory of Bandits Olson 1993
- no incentive to produce beyond subsistence
- society will seek security but free-rider problem will prevent cooperation e.g. China and USA expected to contribute more towards global warming prevention and other countries free ride the benefits
Glorious Revolution
- Europe fast in transitioning towards democracy (English Glorious Revolution of 1688)- Olsen’s Government Theory
- balance of power between parliament and co-monarchy of William and Mary made government more credible
- issues dividing the King and parliament before
- government ability to borrow increased
- capacity of government to provide services
- government employment increased
- investment in infrastructure increased
- role in legislation increased
European Miracle
- view that Europe overtook Asia vs Asia falling behind
- state involvement
- private order institutions
- independent legal and religious systems
- increased trade and finance
- structural change
two phases
1- Mediterranean responds to Black death, Italy captures opportunity to trade overland and via Mediterranean with Asia, Iberia captures opportunity to break Mediterranean trade via Atlantic
2- Dutch and English responds to Great Discoveries- Holland captures opportunity to break Portuguese monopoly and English capture opportunity to break Dutch monopoly
3-MEG- British capture opportunity for sustained economic development
Conclusions:
- Europe had good institutions for LR growth
- Europe capitalised on opportunities for trade and commerce
- Pre modern European success based on Smithian growth
- Britain first economy to transition this to MEG
Italian Success
- urbanised
- trade related industries emerged such as ship building
- import substitution
- banking
- food productivity high
- good policy and state involvement
- good institutions, political, legal and agriculture
Portugal
- overtook Italy in shipbuilding
- established trading ports from Mozambique to Indonesia
- established major slave and sugar colonies
- replaced Venice as main producer of sugar
- good state involvement
- good geography, location and luck
- broke Venetian trade monopoly
- not based on good institutions
Dutch Golden Age
- replaced portugal as dominant European traders
- productive agriculture
- industry generally less productive than agriculture
- developed bills of exchange
- established Amsterdam exchange
Dutch and English Success
- good state involvement
- good institutions, free flow of knowledge and low tariffs
- founded universities
- peasants freer than rest of europe
- good geography
British Exceptionalism
- acquired massive trade empire from rivals
- empire allowed manufactured goods to the periphery
- agricultural revolution, enclosure, crop rotation, selective breeding and root crops
- structural change- agriculture to proto-industry to industry
- good institutions- property rights
- good human capital, applied tech and scientific knowledge
- good credit markets- BoE
Role of Atlantic Trade
- only really SR success
- created opportunities for Smithian growth
- allowed Europe to increase urbanisation and its population
- provided SR growth without good institutions
MEG Kuznets 6 characteristics
- sustained rates of growth of population and GDP per capita
- significant evidence of structural change
- urbanisation and secularisation
- rapid transport and communications
- wide gaps between rich and poor countries
- high sustained growth of efficiency (TFP growth)
Britain first example of MEG during IR
Reasons why Britain first to undergo IR
- High agricultural productivity
- Proto-industrialisation (early start)
- Strong fertility patterns
- Strong applied tech knowledge of labour and high wages
- Good policy, banking, finance, taxes
- Good resources and geographic isolation
- Speculative- luck in war, empire and religion
- Good institutions, legal and informal
Italy, Netherlands and France not first because:
- new inventions made cost effective in Britain (Allen, 2009a)
- Crafts (1997) said emphasis on luck and macro invention
- Mokyr said emphasis on institutions
Definition of IR
A fundamental redeployment of resources away from agriculture- Mathias, 1969