Documentary Evidence and Witnesses Flashcards
Authentication
All evidence, other than testimony, must be authenticated. Authentication is proof the item is what the proponent claims it is.
How can a handwriting be authenticated?
- Handwriting expert
- Layperson already familiar with the persons handwriting
- Handwriting exemplars shown to jury
How can a handwriting be authenticated?
- Handwriting expert
- Layperson already familiar with the persons handwriting
- Handwriting exemplars shown to jury
How can real evidence/Physical Evidence (gun, drug etc) be authenticated?
- Distinctive characteristics
- Chain of custody OR
- Personal knowledge
- Comparison (By expert or trier of fact)
How can real evidence (gun, drug etc) be authenticated?
- Distinctive characteristics
- Chain of custody OR
- Personal knowledge
What are exceptions to the BER?
The BER will not bar admission of evidence if
1. Its a duplicate
2. Proof of unavailability: If original unavailable, then oral testimony or other evidence admissible to prove the contents of the writing
3. Testimonial evidence (Witness has first hand knowledge. Eg shipping address)
4. Collateral matter
5. Summary of voluminous record
6. Public Record
Rule of completeness
When a party introduces part of a writing or recorded statement, the other party may require the introduction of any other part to establish the full context
Absence of Entry (BER)
Records can be admitted to show the absence of an entry to prove the nonoccurrence of the event.
When is the ONLY time BER applies?
When a party is trying to prove the CONTENTS of a writing
Can a presiding judge testify?
Under FRE NO!
When is a juror allowed to testify under the FRE?
Jurors can testify for the limited person of identifying whether
1. Improper outside influence was bought in
2. Improper extraneous prejudicial information, or
3. Error on the verdict form
Present Recollection Refreshed
Technique that allows any item (photo, report, notes) to be used to refresh a witness’s memory. W can only testify from their refreshed memory.
Remember that it is NOT evidence unless adversary brings it in
Present recollection refreshed: Adversary’s right to inspect and admit
-Item used to refresh W WHILE testifying: Adversary can inspect item, cross examine, and admit pertinent portions into evidence
-Item used BEFORE testifying: Right is at courts discretion.
PROPONENT CANNOT ADMIT ITEM INTO EVIDENCE UNLESS ITS OTHERWISE ADMISSIBLE.
Expert Opinion
Expert Opinion is testimony by a person qualified as an expert in their field. Expert testimony admissible if:
1. Helpful to jury
2. Expert is qualified
3. Reasonable certain opinion
4. Opinion supported by a proper factual basis
5. Reliable principles and methods
Marital Privileges: What are the two types?
Spousal immunity and Marital confidential communications
What are the different ways to offer character evidence?
Opinion, reputation, specific instances of conduct