Divorce Flashcards
Why were there few divorces prior to the Matrimonial Causes Act 1857?
Had to have a private act of Parliament.
Briefly describe the 1857 Matrimonial Causes Act.
It was fault based, husbands could divorce on wives adultery. The wife had to prove a lot more.
Briefly describe the Matrimonial Causes Act 1923.
Made adultery the same for husbands and wives. She could still petition for rape or unnatural offence.
Briefly describe the Matrimonial Causes Act 1937.
Extended the grounds so that both could petition on cruelty, desertion for 3 years and incurable insanity.
What is the current law on divorce?
Matrimonial Causes Act 1973
What are the two stages of divorce?
- Decree Nisi
2. Decree Absolute
What was stated in Kim v Morris [2012]?
If there is a long delay between decree nisi and decree absolute, the decree nisi can be rescinded.
What are the facts in the case of Kim v Morris?
The wife petitioned and obtained decree nisi in 2006. Couple reconciled and lived together for 4 years. They split up again and the wife applied for a decree absolute. Was not granted and decree nisi was rescinded.
Where are the grounds for divorce found?
s1(1) Matrimonial Causes Act 1973
What are the grounds for divorce?
Irretrievable Breakdown as evidenced by one of five facts:
- Adultery
- Behaviour
- Desertion
- 2 years separation with consent
- 5 years separation without consent
When can you not petition for divorce?
During the first year of marriage
If there is no fact but there is irretrievable breakdown, can the couple still petition for divorce?
No, there has to be both elements in order to petition for divorce
What happened in the case of Stringfellow v Stringfellow [1976]?
Husband left his wife and family. Three months later the wife petitioned for divorce but she could not show fact so she had to wait until it had been two years with consent
What happened in the case of Biggs v Biggs?
Wife granted decree nisi based on husband’s adultery. H was in prison when decree granted and when he came out they lived together. This showed that there was no irretrievable breakdown so she was refused her decree absolute.
What fact is contained within s1(2)(a) of MCA?
Adultery
What are the requirements for the fact of adultery?
Cannot petition your own adultery.
Petitioner must find it intolerable to live with the respondent however the intolerability does not have to be linked to the adultery.
What is the case of Cleary v Cleary [1974]?
Wife had an affair but was reconciled with husband. She then started to see another man and he found this intolerable. It was not linked to the adultery however was enough.
What was established in Goodrich v Goodrich [1971]?
Intolerability is subjective
What counts as adultery?
Penetrative sex, anal and non-penetrative sex does not count.
What happened in the case of Maclennan v Maclennan [1958]?
Couple separated, he went to live in the US. She had a baby girl and her husband tried to divorce her on basis of adultery. She said it had been through IVF. There was no evidence of IVF so he was granted a divorce.
What was established in Clarkson v Clarkson?
The sex must be voluntary and not rape.
What happened in the case of Clarkson v Clarkson?
Husband worked at sea and came home to find his wife pregnant. She alleged she had been raped, there was evidence. He petitioned on basis of adultery and it was refused as it was not voluntary.
Who holds the burden of proof in adultery cases?
Respondent must prove that the sex was voluntary
What happened in the case of Redpath v Redpath [1950]?
Wife alleged rape. Man tied but not found guilty. Husband petitioned for divorce. At first instance refused however on appeal it was granted. It was up to the wife to prove it was not voluntary, not husband.
When will adultery be available to same sex couples?
When a person has slept with someone of the opposite sex