Disposition without Trial Flashcards
What are the four methods of disposition without trial? With their rule?
- Default judgment (Rule 55)
- Dismissal (voluntary or involuntary) (Rule 41)
- Settlement
- Summary judgment (Rule 56)
What rule governs entering a default?
Rule 55(a)
What rule governs entering a default judgment?
Rule 55(b)
When must a default judgment be entered by a clerk?
(1) PL’s claim is for a sum certain or can be computated
(2) with an affidavit proving the amount
(3) DF has been defaulted for not appearing
When must a default judgment be entered by the court?
In all other cases
When may a court conduct hearings or make referrals in entering a default judgment?
When it needs to (1) conduct an accounting, (2) determine the amount of damages, (3) establish the truth of any allegation by evidence, or (4) investigate any other matter.
Who must a party seek to enter a default?
the clerk
Who can default be entered against?
a party against whom a judgment for affirmative relief is sought that does not plead or otherwise defend
What are the two steps for obtaining default judgment?
- Seek clerk’s entry of default
- Seek default judgment from the court OR seek default judgment from clerk if sum certain (and DF is not minor or incompetent)
What are the rules regarding default judgment against minors and incompetent persons? Rules?
No default judgment may be entered by the clerk against a minor or incompetent person. Rule 55(b)(1). Default judgment entered by the court against a minor or incompetent person only if they are represented by a general guardian, conservator, or other like fiduciary duty who has appeared. Rule 55(b)(2).
What notice requirements are there for default judgment? Rule?
If a party has appeared personally or through a representative, the party must be served with written notice of the application to the court at least 7 days before the hearing. Rule 55(b)(2).
What are two protections afforded for default judgment? Rule/Statute?
For the United States (absent proof) (Rule 55(d)) and members of the military if service prevents an appearance (50 USC 3931)
How else may limits be imposed on default judgments?
Other statutes may impose limits on default judgments.
what kind of acts are required to prevent a default judgment?
Acts that show an intent to defend have frequently prevented a default judgment even though not connected to any particular rule.
What rule governs setting aside a default or default judgment?
Rule 55(c)
What are the 6 “good cause shown” factors in deciding whether to set aside an entry of default?
- Whether the moving party has a meritorious defense
- Whether the moving party has acted with reasonable promptness
- The personal responsibility of the moving party
- The prejudice to the non-moving party
- Whether there is a history of dilatory action
- The availability of sanctions less drastic
What rules allow a final default judgment to be set aside?
Rule 55(c) and 60(b)
What are the 6 (with subparts) potential steps in default/default judgment?
- Defendant does not answer (or appear in court after answer)
- Plaintiff obtains default (clerk or court - as applicable)
- Defendant moves to set aside entry of default: (A) if successful - case proceeds (B) if unsuccessful - move to next step
- Plaintiff obtains default judgment
- Defendant moves to set aside default judgment: (A) if successful - case proceeds (B) if unsuccessful - move to next step
- Plaintiff executes on their judgment
What rule governs damages for default judgments?
Rule 54(c)
What rules governs volunary dismissal by the plaintiff?
Rule 41(a)(1)
What rule governs voluntary dismissal by court order?
Rule 41(a)(2)
What is the two dismissal rule?
If the plaintiff or court voluntarily dismisses without prejudice for a second time, it operates as an adjudication on the merits (with prejudice)
When can a plaintiff volintarily dismiss an action?
Before any party has filed an answer or a motion for summary judgment or at any time if stipulated to by all the parties.
When may a plaintiff voluntarily dismiss an action by court order?
On terms that the court considers proper
What rule governs involuntary dismissal?
Rule 41(b)
How are counterclaims/crossclaims/third-party claims handled in regard to voluntary or involuntary dismissals?
Governed by Rule 41(c), the rest of the voluntary/involuntary dismissal rules apply as they would to other claims
What rule governs costs of a previously dismissed action?
Rule 41(d)
What rule governs pretrial conferences, scheduling, and case management?
Rule 16
Generally, what does Rule 16 allow?
Rule 16 gives the district court discretion to assist the parties and eliminate frivolous claims. Courts can do anything to streamline, control, or manage cases.
What is the difference between Rules 16(c)(2)(A) and 16(c)(2)(E)?
At any pretrial conference, the court may consider and take appropriate action on the following matters: formulating and simplifying the issues, and eliminating frivolous claims or defenses (16(c)(2)(A)) and determining the appropriateness and timing of summary judgment adjudication under Rule 56 (16(c)(2)(E)).
Regarding settlement, what can/can’t courts compel?
Courts may compel parties to attend a settlement conference. Courts may not compel parties to settle a dispute.
When is a party required/not required to attend a settlement conference?
If the conference is court ordered, a party is required to go. If it is not, they are not.