Diminished Responsibilty Flashcards
Act
52 Coroners and justice act 2009
4 elements
Abnormality of mental functioning
Recognised medical condition
Substainal impairment
Explain act or omission in killing
52.1
Abnormality of mental functioning
52.11A
Recognised medical condition
52.11b
Substantial impairment
52.1B
Explain act or omission
What makes a substantial impairment
Understand nature of his own conduct
Form rational judgment
Exercise self control
Case for substantial impairment
R V golds
Case for explain emission in killing
R V brown
Case for abnormality of mental functioning
R V Byrne - reasonable man test used - jury objective - state of mind so different form ordinary human that a reasonable man would find it abnormal
Recognised medical condition
R V Hobson - WHO
R V Steward - Alcoholic