Development Flashcards
Defining Development:
What are some characteristics of development?
Something that is 'good' For the 'deserving' poor progression (more advanced) post - 1945 modernisation wester led?
Defining Development
What are the different types of development?
Assistance for International Development (AID)
- support from developed to developing countries. (not the same as disaster relief)
Development state
- project of national development e.g. Brazil, China, S.Korea
Defining Development
Who are the top two recipients of aid
Iraq - 9115 (USD millions
Afghanistan - 3195
Defining Development
Aid to least developed countries is falling
NA
Defining Development
What are the two types of poverty?
Absolute and Relative
Defining Development
What is Absolute poverty?
UN (1995): “condition characterised by severe deprivation of basic human needs, including food, safe drinking water, sanitation facilities, health shelter, education and information. It depends not only on income but also on access to services”
World Bank (2005 prices) international poverty line of $1.25 per day
Defining Development
What is Relative poverty?
socially defined standard which therefore differs between countries overtime.
Defining Development
What is the Human Rights Based Approach to development (UNHR)?
It contains many different rights including: - the right to education, the right to life, liberty and security, -freedom of expression, - protection of the law - freedom from slavery
Defining Development
What are some development failures?
there is nothing new about development so surely if it was always working we would have ended poverty by now?
Suggested it could be:
- neo-colonial?
- pro-capitalist?
- anti-market?
- too little?
- too much?
- poor projects
Maybe it’s working and it’s just a matter a time?
Measuring Development
discuss the widening gap
Has the gap between the rich and poor nations narrowed since 1945?
whats more important, inequality or progress?
Expectations of modernity
What institutions were created in 1944 at the Bretton Woods Institutions?
IMF
World Bank
also established primacy of US gold and dollar
Expectations of modernity
What is modernisation?
Social change can result from adopting characteristics of more advanced (westernised) societies, including a centralised powerful state.
Acceptance of scientifically rational norms and transformation of social relations.
Under developed is a consequence of conditions internal to less developed societies.
Expectations of modernity
What is Rostows theory of economic growth?
It is based on the experiences of Europe and North america and states that each country must pass through 5 stages in order to be developed.
- Traditional society, limited technology, static society
- Preconditions for take off, commercial exploitation of agriculture and extractive industry.
- take off, development of manufacturing sector
- drive to maturity, development of wider industrial and commercial base
- high mass consumption.
A linear narrative of modernisation as development.
Expectations of modernity
Some suggest that the affluence and development of countries in stage 5 is dependent of them exploiting other stages
NA
Expectations of modernity
Zambia
Copper mining, built towns looked like USA, had deteriorating terms of trade. development denied: falling copper prices and production, external debt burden, huger and malnutrition, AIDs epidemic. Rosters theory breaks down as Zambia went from stage 3 to 2. Is globalisation the explanation?
Development theories
Critiques of modernisation
ICT4D - Laptops for children - development as modernisation today.
‘Left’ - Failure, eurocentric, top down, reproduced capitalist society,
‘Right’ - Failure, CA, inefficient, Blocked free market
Development theories
Zambia - after modernisation (mid 70s onwards)
development policy in Zambia abandoned goal of industrialisation and free market was promoted as solution for development.
Development theories
Explain neoliberalism
theory underpinning structural adjustment, market is main actor in economy (Hayek) public sector reduced (Thatcher) trade barriers lowered (globalisation)
Development theories
explain the dependency theory
Relationships of exchange between rich and poor nations (Frank)
Wallerstein’s world systems theory
Development theories
Explain development state
strong state takes control of economy state drives industrialisation, normally capitalist but with protectionism, can involve modernisation.
Development theories
Explain what orientalist discover creates
constructs a binary opposition between ‘west’ and ‘east’ (Said 1978)
Development theories
Explain Bottom up development
In the 1980s and 1990s people began to embrace post-modernism. Participation, gender, environment, disability.
Alternative ideas became the mainstream in AID.
Development theories
Explain participatory approaches in development
they acknowledged non-western knowledge, giving voice to ‘others’ “putting the last first”
Problems with AID projects - biases: temporal, spatial and respondent.
Solution - new methods - Participatory approaches.
Resource Curse
What are the theories of the ‘resource curse’?
- Tax policy: decline in need for tax weakens the social contract between state and citizens. undermines democracy, competition for state power.
- Over reliance and vulnerability: commodity prices fall (except oil)
- Dutch disease: Netherlands discovered natural gas but the rest of their economy declined, became unbalanced, oil or gas requires little labour.
Resource Curse
What are the two options for managing a resource (oil)
- Conservative strategy: this recognises the danger of dutch disease, the potential for corruption and the volatility of global oil prices.
- Big push - revenues are used to support investment for growth
Resource Curse
What did the expansion of capitalism lead to?
Businesses spreading geographically and the race to the bottom (wages)
Resource Curse
Is there really free trade?
Rather than being truly liberal english led trade in the 18th and 19th century was heavily regulated: Protected markets, monopolies, price controls, tariffs, capital constraints.
Resource Curse
What happened during post war trade liberalisation?
Trade was liberalised between rich countries, especially through the General Agreement on Trade and Tariffs (GATT) and later the WTO.
Resource Curse
Africas relation to the world has persistently been determined by exports of agricultural products and mineral commodities
NA
Development of E.Asia and S.Korea
Do countries need to protect their economies to develop?
What are NICs?
Newly industrialised countries:
Developmental states, important role for national government, not unfettered by free market economies.
Development of E.Asia and S.Korea
compare Ghana and S.Korea historically
1961 S.Korea income was $82 per person, Ghana’s was $179. Nkrumah proclaimed Ghana to be “free forever” and USAID said Korea was a ‘bottomless pit’
Development of E.Asia and S.Korea
What happened to S.Korea following the Korean war?
1950 - 53 (Korean war) post war recovery: S.Korea had one of the world’s fastest growing economies in the second half of the 20th century.
Development of E.Asia and S.Korea
In contrast, what was N.Korea like?
They were trapped in persistent poverty, amongst poorest country in the world and widespread famine was commonplace.
Development of E.Asia and S.Korea
Why did some Asian nations develop?
S.Korea’s post war leader, General Park Chung-Hee, had goal of raising per capita income 1000 USD by 1981, had 5 year economic plans, per capita grew phenomenally and the country was obsessed with economic growth.