Democracy in UK Flashcards
When was the Scottish Parliament established?
1999
What are the Scottish Parliament responsible for controlling?
The devolved powers in Scotland
Name a devolved power
- Education
- Tourism
- Police and fire services
- Sport
- The Arts
Name a reserved power
- Immigration
- Broadcasting
- Defence and national security
- Constitutional matters
- Forgien policy
What is the annual budget for the Scottish Parliament and what is used to calculate this?
£37 billion from Westminster called the ‘Block Grant’ calculated by a ‘per head of population’ calculation called the Barnett Formula
What is changing about Scotland’s budget?
The Scotland Act 2016 gives tax raising powers to Scotland which means that the ‘Block Grant’ will only account for half of the Scottish budget
Powers included in the Scotland Act 2012
Airguns - owners must have a licence
Drink driving - stricter limits introduced
Why was there an independence referendum?
The SNP manifesto contained a commitment to holding a referendum on independence. In May 2011 they won an outright majority in The Scottish Parliament (69/129). The date for the referendum was set with almost two years notice.
Why was the Scotland Act 2016 introduced?
Just three days before the referendum leaders of the pro-union parties made a vow that if Scotland remain in the union significantly more powers would be devolved. this came in the form of The Scotland Act 2016
Powers included in The Scotland Act 2016
Tax raising powers
Policing of railways
Abortion
The Independence referendum - date and result?
18 September 2014
55% NO
45% YES
What is the West Lothian Question?
A question posed by an MP from West Lothian - Tom Dalyell. Questions the fact that an MP from Scotland has the right to vote on matters affecting education in England but an English MP has no say of Education in Scotland.
What is EVEL?
English Votes for English Laws
Introduced by David Cameron to reduce powers for MPs from Scotland at Westminster.
What did people make of the Scotland Act 2016?
Good:
- It gave the Scottish Parliament the ability to legislate in a number of important areas.
- Gave Scotland tax raising powers
Bad:
- The vow has not been delivered - huge number of powers reserved by Westminster
- SNP not impressed does not go as far as they wish
What 4 levels are we represented by in Scotland?
- Local Councillors - 1227
- Members of The Scottish Parliament (MSPs) - 129
- Members of the UK Parliment (MPs) - 650 (59 Scotland)
- Members of the European Parliment (MEPs) - 73 (6 Scotland)
EU Referendum (Brexit) Result
72% Turnout
- 9% Yes
- 1% No
What are some pressures on political representatives?
- The whips
- Pressure groups
- Constituents
- The media
- Their own conscience
- Their party
What are the whips?
People in each party responsible for for keeping each MP voting in line with party (many will be tempted to vote against party in the interest of their constituents)
What is the whip system?
The whip sys†em is used in a weekly document sent to MPs. Each item is underlined to show its importance - 3 underlines means your attendance is necessary regardless of the circumstances.
Why is the ‘archaic’ whip system in need of reformation?
Many believe that proxy voting needs to be introduced in certain circumstances.
Labour MP Naz Shah had to be wheeled through HoC in her pyjamas after a car accident - an experience she described as humiliating.
Jo Swinson, fellow MP, was also required to be present despite being 9 months pregnant and living in Glasgow.
What is Federalism as an alternative to the governance of Scotland
- Federalism involves a written constitution which separates powers between a central federal government and state governments.
- Disputes are settled by a constitutional court.
- The UK states would be Scotland, England, Wales and Ireland.
PROS of Federalism
- The USA, Germany, Canada and Australia already have federal systems of government.
- It would make the UK have a single codified constitution the UK would benefit from this modernisation
- It would be devo-max plus for Scotland, devolved power but not independence
CONS of Federalism
- There is a huge disparity in the size and needs of each ‘state’
- 85% of the UK population lives in England
- The state could also be outvoted by the three smaller states
- The house of lords would need abolishing (even trying to reform it has proved difficult)
PROS of Independence
- Independence is a natural form of government for any country
- Scotland is a country not a region and therefore should have full economic and political powers of any country
- Scotland has the population, skills and resources needed to be successful (oil)
- Scotland would be welcomed into the EU
CONS of Independence
- Scotland don’t know what currency they would use
- UK economy is better than Scotland being isolated (Scotland on it’s own would not have recovered from the 2008 banking crisis)
- Scotland’s oil will run out
- Wealth and opportunities are centred around London
What is full fiscal autonomy or devo-max?
All government spending would funded by taxes raised in Scotland. It would mean all financial ties with Westminster would be cut.
Explain the passage of a bill through parliament
-House of commons:
Readings and votes
Room for scrutiny
-House of Lords:
Readings and amendments made (can be sent back to HoC)
Room for scrutiny
-Royal Assent:
The Queen always signs the bills
What are adjournment debates?
30 minute dates at the end of each day where MPs can raise an issue of concern to constituents and require government to give a response
What are the limitations of adjournment debates?
There is very poor attendance at this time of day and barely any media coverage.
A very limited number of MPs are chosen to air their concerns.
What is a recent example of an adjournment debate?
Debate of regulations in the hairdressing industry which did receive some media coverage
What is PM’s Question time?
One a week on a Wednesday for 30 minutes opposition and backbencher can question the prime minister about government actions. First 6 Questions go to the leader of the opposition.
What are the limitations of PMQ’s?
There are no follow up questions so the level of scrutiny is superficial
Staged questions are often asked by members of PM’s party
Recent example of PMQs?
Corbyn repeatedly asks Theresa May questions on her plans for Brexit deals
What are select committees?
Select Committees are groups of MP specialists of their field who investigate the work of government and hold it to account. They examine issues in detail and produce reports with recommendations.
What are the limitations of select committees?
They reflect the balance of power in Commons so government majority makes it hard to challenge ministers.
Recent example of select committees?
Work and pensions inquiry into the ‘gig’ economy
What are opposition days?
20 MPs each year are are chosen by ballot to put forward a new law of their choice
What are the limitations of opposition days?
Only 20 are chosen and few are successful are successful because lack of time and support from other other MPs.
Recent example of an opposition day?
SNP gained 3 opposition days in which they used 2 to discuss trident and the last to discuss refugees in Britain
How many peers are there in the House of Lords?
840
What was the daily attendance in the House of Lords in 2014/15
483 peers
How much can peers in the House of Lords claim in expenses each day?
£300
What are the functions of the House of Lords?
- To make laws
- To hold the government to account
- To provide independent expertise
What are the limitations on the House of Lords?
- They do not discuss money bills (tax and public spending)
- They can delay the passage of bills for only a year and if the government reintroduce it next year it can be passed without there approval
- They cannot vote against the second or third reading of a bill if it has been in the governments election manifesto (Salisbury Convention)
PROS of The House of Lords
- Important to revise and amend bad legislation before it becomes a law
- Lord’s feels less obliges to ‘toe the party line’ as commons MPs
- No overall majority in the House of Lords
- Can be important in delaying hurried commons legislation
- More willing to debate controversial topics
CONS of The House of Lords
- It is undemocratic to have unelected people making decisions for our country
- The House of Lords costs £94 million each year to run
- The 26 Bishops don’t reflects out multicultural society, religion has no place in politics
- The Prime Minister can just appoint whoever they want -‘Tony’s Cronies’. (David Cameron appointed 45 people including 26 former Tory ministers before resigning in 2015)
What does ‘Primus inter pares’ mean and who does it refer to?
It means ‘first amount equals’ an is used to describe the position of the prime minister
What are the powers of the Prime Minister?
- Head of The Executive, in charge of the civil service
- Oversees government policies
- Leader of their party
- Speaks on behalf of the government
- Representative of the UK to forgiven countries
- Power to appoint, sack and reshuffle the cabinet
Limitations on the power of the PM?
- Media attention can undermine their powerful image
- Need to retain the support of the cabinet (Theresa May’s vote of no confidence shows real weakness in her)
- Needs to compromise regularly to show party unity (This didn’t happen in Labour leadership - causing people to either be Brownites or Blairites.)
What is collective responsibility?
A way of operating in British politics that states that when a decision is made in parliament all cabinet members must follow the party line and not publicly speak out against it.
What is a minister who will not publicly support agreed cabinet decisions expected to do and is this democratic?
Resign and No it does not allow ministers to speak for their own beliefs.
Why and when did Boris Johnson resign?
July 2018 because he openly criticised the plans to Britain to leave the EU - an example of not following collective responsibility.
What are the main roles of civil servants? (Non political part of the executive - Defence, education etc)
- To give impartial advice to ministers
- To manage their department
- To implement decisions of the government
What is the role of local councillors?
- Meet and assist locals people in any issue they may have
- Attend local council meetings and make important decisions
- Attend local functions