Democracy and Participation Flashcards
What does Democracy mean?
Political power resides with the people who live in an area (derived from the Greek demos - the people and kratos - rule)
What does Sovereign mean?
Possessing absolute and unlimited power wether it is legal authority or political power
What is direct democracy?
The people make fundamental decisions for themselves
What are the key features of direct democracy?
- The public make the political decisions for themselves
- Decisions made on a majoritarian basis
- Continuous public participation
What are two examples of a society with direct democracy?
- Ancient Athenian Democracy in 508 BC
- Swiss cantons (regions) once a year meet to debate and vote on major local issues of the day
What are the advantages and disadvantages of a direct democracy?
Advantage - Not one person making decisions, most will be satisfied, decision makers come from different backgrounds
Disadvantage - Not everyone is able to make an educated decision, time consuming
What is representative democracy?
A small group of people take political decisions on behalf of all the citizens in a country
What are key features of a representative democracy?
Citizen elect representatives to take decisions on their behalf, all adults have the right to vote, citizens delegate their authority to representatives, elections are free and fair
Advantages and disadvantages of a representative democracy?
Advantages - educated group of politicians make decisions, control of major decisions, less time consuming
Disadvantages- views of people may be overlooked, politicians have a narrower view of the world, power can corrupt politicians
Does the UK fit the criteria for a representative democracy?
- There is a general election every 5 years to elect a party and other local election for local representatives ✅
- Prisoners cannot vote ❌
- UK citizens allow the elected candidate to make political decisions ✅
- In theory elections are free and fair but there are often practical barriers
Arguments for a direct democracy in the UK
- The voice of the people is heard in it’s pure form e.g 2016 EU referendum
- More regular and meaningful opportunities to take part in the political system
- Citizens can pick and choose the individual policies they like instead one parties complete policies
- Public are more motivated to learn about the political process
Arguments for a representative democracy in the UK
- There is no venue big enough to have a single meeting of all UK citizens
- Turnout is already low in the Uk and there is no evidence they would participate more in voting
- Government put a coherent set of policies which the public might not do
- Governed by full time professionals, the public is simply to busy
What is a referendum?
The electorate vote on a specific question(s) - incorporates a direct democracy in a representative democracy
What is the 2015 Recall of MPs Act?
If an MP is sentenced to imprisonment or suspended from the House of Commons for more than 14 days a petition for a by-election can be triggered. If 10% sign a by-election is called
When has the recall petition mechanism been used?
2018, North Antrim - Ian Paisley with 9.4% so not removed
2019, Peterborough - Fiona Onasanya with 27.4% so removed and replaced by Lisa Forbes
2019, Brecon - Christopher Davis with 18.9% so removed and replaced by Jane Dodds (Lib Dem)
2019-present, Rutheglen - Margaret Ferries with 14.7% so will be replaced soon
What does legitimacy mean?
The right and acceptance of an authority
Where does legitimacy come from in the UK?
The consent of the people via elections, consent via referendums, the rules of constitution like ‘being able to command the confidence’, by law allowing power
Evidence for a free and fair elections
For - every eligible adult (except prisoners) can vote, very little evidence of identity fraud in voting
Against - 2015 UKIP had 4 million votes with turned into 1 seat (0.2%) in Commons
Evidence for popular participation in the UK
For - joining and funding political parties and pressure groups (no age limit)
Against - people don’t really bother to joking groups and some require you to pay, some people don’t vote as they don’t like voting system
Evidence for devolved governments in the UK
For - Scotland, Wales and London all have their own parliament
Against - England does not have its own parliaments unlike the other countries of the UK, NI assembly suspended
Evidence for free media in the UK
For - newspapers often have a bias so can challenge their oppositions publicly, social media can legally voice different views
Against - a lot of media is owned by a small group of rich businessmen
Evidence for independent judiciary
For - 2017 Theresa May lost a case to trigger the start of Brexit, 2019 Boris Johnson suspended parliament illegally which was taken to court
Against - government plays a small role in picking and approving judges
What does democratic deficit mean?
A situation in which political structures or decision making processes are perceived to lack legitimacy
What are so undemocratic elements in the UK?
Poor representation of voters due to voting system - FPTP and UKIP 2015, Labour 2005 got 35% of votes but 55.2% of seats
House of Lords lack democratic legitimacy- 100% not elected, life peers chosen by PMs, hereditary peers passed on by family and lord’s spiritual (CofE)
Lack of citizens right protection - Humans right act gives some basic protection but parliament are sovereign so can pass any act they want
Control of media by wealthy interests - 3 companies, News Uk, Daily Mail Group and Reach own big parts of UK media and we do not elect these people
What is a participation crisis?
A large proportion of the population do not engage with the political process
What ways can people participate in politics?
Contact a local MP or media, take part in a campaign, create or sign a paper or e- petition, attends political meeting or take part in a protest, vote in an election and donate money to a political party
Evidence of participation in a general elections
For - 2001 59.4% participated and in 2019 67% participated meaning and increase
Against - There’s been little increase and numbers have not been this low since the early 1900s
Evidence of participation in second order elections
For - 2021 Scottish Parliament had 64% turnout as well as the 2022 NI assembly election having the same
Against - 2022 Senedd election has a turnout of 47% and local elections tend to be in the low 30%
Evidence of participation in referendums
For - 1998 Good Friday referendum in NI had a 81% turnout, 2014 Scottish independence referendum had 85% of voters, 2016 Brexit referendum 72% voted in it
Against - 2011 alternative vote referendum had 42% turnout
Evidence of participation in political parties
For - SNP has 2.5% of Scotland as members, in 1950s the conservatives had 3 mil and Labour had 1 mil
Against - 432,000 members are in Labour and 172,000 people are in conservatives which is a significant decrease to what it was in the 1950s
What’s the difference between first order elections and second order elections?
First order determines the government and executive power and the second order elections are often smaller and do not determine the above.
What is political apathy and how is it linked to the participation crisis?
Some people don’t care about voting or some really do but are out of by the voting system. The credit referendum had a good tuner out but the people who didn’t vote in probably one of the biggest referendums in the UK will probably never vote as they don’t care
What factors might explain why participation levels fluctuate?
Competition being close means turnout will be higher while if there is a landslide turnout goes down, world issues also spikes turnout also the severity of vote
Evidence of participation in pressure groups
For - RSPB has over 1 mil members, trade unions have 7 million members in total
Against - 1979 there were 12 million people in trade unions so membership has declined
Evidence of participation in protests
For - 2003 the biggest UK protest was to stop the Iraq war with 1 million participants, the 2nd biggest was to stop Brexit in 2018 with just under a million
Against - massive protests are fairly rare in the UK
Evidence of participation of signing a petition
For - the most popular was to revoke article 50 in the EU with 6 million signers while the 2nd was another EU vote with just under a million marchers
Against - this isn’t proper activism it is more clicktivism
What are the four ways of voting in the UK at the moment?
- In person voting
- Postal vote
- By proxy (friend)
- By proxy by post
What was the UK turnout for the European Parliament elections in 1999?
24% - lowest in Europe
How did Labour try and combat low voting participation?
In 2004 they introduced all-postal ballots in four of Britains 12 European constituencies- turnout doubled in the regions and nearly 3 mil more people voted than in 1999