democracy Flashcards
how many approve of the fptp system in 2019
25%
brexit turnout
72% turnout
Referendums settle controversial issues
Good Friday (1998) 81%, 71% yes laid plans for a devolved ni assembly and brought peace among unionists and republicans
when did brexit protests happen
september 2023
scottish independence referendum turnout
84%
how many believed leaving the EU was wrong
57%
percentage of oxbridge mps 2024
20%
2014 scottish referendum turnout from 18-24 year olds
75%
how many 16-17 year olds say the vote given to them in 2014 made them more inclined to be politically engaged in the future
97%%
2024 apathy
59.8% turnout , historic highs not met of average 75% (1950s)
essay plan for direct vs representative
legitimacy vs stability
informed electorate vs governance by experts
power to people vs practicality
legitimacy in direct democracy
referendums give a strong mandate to decide on constitutional changes due to high turnout compared to general elections
how many people approved of system in 2019
25% according to hansard society
stability with repressive democracy examples
anti brexit protests (sept 2023) , e-petition with over 6 million, rise of snp
stability with representative democracy
long lasting divisions within direct - 57% thought it was wrong to leave eu due to close result and ambiguity
representative allows distance from politics (apathy)
Uproar when constitutional isssyes are decided without referendum
Lisbon Treaty
Referdums do not settle controversial issues
1997 wales and Scotland voted for a devolved gov but in 1979 rejected , neverendums- 2014 Scottish referendum was a narrow vote meaning snp are campaigning for another
Referdums provide a clear mandate
Turnout is much higher in 2016-72% but 2024 ge had 60% and effectively only 33% voted for labour
Referendums do not provide a clear mandate
50.1% welsh assembly turnout 1997 (tyranny of minority) and only 50.3% said yes , ambiguous message on what Brexit would look like hard or soft
Fairness established by electoral commission in referendums
2013 rejected salmonds preferred question for Scot independence as it encouraged a yes vote
Referendums aren’t fair as open to manipulation from elites
Nigel farage said he shouldn’t have promised 350 million for eu would be given to nhs every week as it promoted lack of understanding and misinformation
Parliament have power in referendums
Can avoid undesirable results by rejecting referendums (legislative Referdums)-Lisbon treaty,they determine threshold 1979 Scot needed 40% electorate only had 33%, decide wording such as Scot tax 1997
Example of government undermining e-petition
Cameron issue a three line whip on a vote for a referendum to leave eu (2011),bbc have to arrange the Debates
Prevent trump from making a state visit e petition
1.8 million signed , gov rejected