Delivery Of Services Flashcards
What are 2 important factors architect must consider before accepting a project?
- Is client’s budget sufficient to cover construction and professional fees?
- Reputation + reliability of client
If client is using a bidding method, what does this usually indicate?
That the client is very concerned with cost and it is likely the client could file a claim to save or recover $
Who decides on the project delivery method?
The owner
When should the project delivery method be confirmed?
Before the agreement between the architect and client is final
List 2 scenarios where a construction manager method may be preferred
- When the firm is small and doesn’t have the expertise to administer the project
- Cost is main priority
When may a design assist method be preferred?
When an inexperienced firm is working on a large and complex project they may need specialty consultants in the early phases of design and during CDs
List 4 reasons why a design build method may be preferred
- If a small firm is risk averse
- If a firm focuses on design more than documentation and CA
- If the architect wants to maintain control and is concerned with quality
- If schedule is a concern
List 2 reasons why the ipd method may be preferred
- Large scope projects
2. If quality is most important
When would a fast-track method be used?
When client has a tight schedule
Name 2 types of project delivery methods that do not require bidding
- Design build
2. Fast track
What are 2 types of project delivery methods that could be used if there are many unknowns on a project?
- Design-Bid-Build using a cost plus fee (with or without a GMP)
- Design-Build led by construction contractor (w/ guaranteed maximum price)
What is an advantage of using the IDP project delivery method?
Shorter construction time means lower cost and better design
What are the 7 components of selecting a project delivery method?
- Firm size and experience
- Project scope
- Schedule
- cost
- Building quality
- Risk
- Protecting intellectual property
List the 6 types of project delivery methods
- Design-Bid-Build
- Construction Manager as an advisor
- Construction Manager as a constructor
- Design-Build
- Design assist contracting
- Integrated project Delivery
What project delivery method traditionally yields the lowest cost but can be risky for the client?
Design-Bid-Build
In a design-bid-build project delivery method who does the owner have separate contracts with?
The architect and the contractor
What are the advantages to using a design-bid-build project delivery method?
1, all roles are well defined
2. Coordination problems are minimized
Describe The design-bid build project delivery method
Arch designs proj. and prepares specs. → contractor bidding/negotiation → award → contractor builds project
What is the disadvantage to using the design-bid-build project delivery method?
Design must be complete before construction can begin
In a construction manager as adviser position, who hires the cm?
The owner
Do the architect and cm have separate contracts in a CMa project delivery method?
Yes
What is the cm’s role in a CMA project delivery method?
I. Acts as agent for owner (like the architect)
2. Advises on constructibility, provides cost estimating, schedule, will sometimes provide GMP and substantial completion date
What are 3 methods the cm might use to establish construction costs?
- Fixed price (stipulated or lumpsum) method
- Cost + fee method W/ GMP
- Cost + fee method w/o GMP
Describe the fixed fee cost method in a CMA project delivery method
Owner knows cost before construction begins and is not responsible for any cost over-runs but does not receive any savings the contractor may find
Describe the cost + fee method for a CMA project delivery
Owner pays actual cost of construction plus a fee that is agreed upon before construction begins
It contractor includes a GMP and the project is completed for less, the owner receives the savings
When is fast-tracking used?
Most commonly when there is a cm on board, but it can be used with any project delivery method
Describe fast-tracking
Construction can begin before design is done - documents are issued in stages thru bid packages
What is the advantage to fast-tracking?
Reduces time and cost
What is the disadvantage to fast-tracking?
Requires many prime contracts and a lot of coordination
Describe the construction manager as constructor project delivery method
Contracting firm has single contract with owner to provide services covering cm and construction
Cm work is divided into 2 phases (preconstnction and construction) which can proceed concurrently to fast-track
How are projects prized in a CMC project delivery method?
Cost + fee W/ or w/o a GMP
Why is prizing W/ a GMP risky in a CMC project delivery method?
Because GMP is based on partially completed documents usually after dd phase
In a CMC project delivery method, when can the architect perform CA work?
Once one ot 3 things happen:
- Owner accepts CMC’s GMP
- Owner approves cmc’s control estimate
- Owner issues notice to proceed to cm
What is a control estimate in a CMC project delivery method?
Sum of cm’s cost of work plus the cm’s fee
-establishes substantial date of completion
In a design-build project delivery method, how does the contracting work?
Owner contracts W/ one entity to provide design and construction services. That entity then subcontracts services as needed.
What is the most common scenario for organization in the design build project delivery method?
Led by contractor + independent architect + consultants - In this scenario the architect and consultants have a contract with the contractor, not the owner
What is the owner’s role in the design-build project delivery method?
To provide a clear set of criteria for the project requirements so that the design-builder can develop the preliminary design and contract sum
Owner also assumes CA duties and must certify a substantial date of completion
What are 3 advantages of using the design -build project delivery method?
- Single source of responsibility W/ one contract
- Owner receives fixed price early in the project
- Cost + time usually less than other project delivery methods
What are 2 disadvantages to using the design-build project delivery method?
- Owner has less control over design
- Design-build entity has control over methods of Const. And quality of materials and can substitute for cheaper materials to stay W/ in budget
What AIA doc does the owner use to establish the substantial date of completion in the design build project delivers method?
AIA doc G744
What are 3 ways cost can be determined for the design-build project delivery method?
- Stipulated sum
- Cost + fee
- Cost + fee with GMP
What AIA doc outlines the architect’s responsibilities in the design-build project delivery method?
AIA doc B143
What is the benefit of bridging?
- Combines advantages of DBB and DB Methods
- Someone represents the owner throughout the entire process
- Competitive bidding and a fixed cost, single-source responsible for construction
Describe the bridging workflow process
- Owner hires an arch, or engineer (ae)
- AE helps owner develop project scope and preliminary drawings and specs
- Design-Build firms bid on project
- Design-Build firm takes over ae role
When would an architect use design-assist contracting?
If the project is large and /or has complex issues
What is integrated project delivery?
All participants collaborate from conception to move-in
Owner can have multiple agreements
List the 7 phases of IDP
- Conceptualization(Pre-Design)
- Criteria design (SD)
- Detail design (DD)
- Implementation docs (CD)
- Agency review (bidding from those not on integrated team)
- Construction (CA)
- Closeout
What is the advantage of the IDP project delivery method?
Lower project cost, quality construction
What are the 3 ways to establish contractual relationships in the IDP project delivery method?
- Transitional forms
- Multi-party agreement
- Single purpose entity (spe)
What is a multit-party agreement?
Single agreement executed by owner, architect, contractor, and other key participants
What AIA doc outlines the multi-party agreement for IDP?
AIA doc C191
What is a single-purpose entity
An LLC created for the sole purpose of planning, designing, and constructing a project
- complete sharing of risk and rewards (fully collaborative)
When would an SPE be used?
For large complex projects
What AIA doc outlines the requirements for an SPE?
AIA doc c195
What types of firms use departmental organization
Specialty firms and some design firms
What types of firms use studio organization?
Generalist firms
What is EBD?
Evidence based design- it establishes design decisions on credible research that links one or more environmental elements W/ desired outcome
Ex: daylighting improves student performance in schools
What is the most important role of the architect during pre-design?
Assembling and coordinating a team of professional consultants to work on the project
What are 2 ways consultants can be contracted on a project?
- Thru the owner - owner coordinates all arch. And consultant work
- Thru the architect - arch. is responsible for coordination and holds the primary contract with the owner. Architect receives payment and thin pays consultants. A clause may be added to “pay when paid” to anticipate delays in payment from owner.
List the AIA doc series
A- owner-contractor agreements B- owner-architect agreements C- other agreements D- misc. Docs E- Exhibits G- contract administration