Definitions Flashcards
Conflict (Wallensteen)
a social situation in which a minimum of two actors strive to aquire at the same moment in time with an available set of scarce resources
Armed conflict (COW)
sustained combat, involving organized armed forces, resulting in a minimum of 1000 battle-related deaths
Armed conflict (UCDP)
a state-based armed conflcit is a contested incompatibility that concerns government and/or territory were the use of armed force between two parties, of which at least one is the government of a state, results in at least 25 battle-related deaths in one calendar year.
Social conflict (Kriesberg and Dayton)
Social conflicts occur when two or more persons or groups manifest that they have incompatible objectives
Minor armed conflict
More than 25 less then 1000 b.r.d i.o.c.y
War
More than 1000 b.r.d i.o.c.y
Incompatibility (Wallensteen)
a state based armed conflict is a contested incompatibility that concerns government and/or territory …
Incompatibility over government (who controls the state and how?)
Overthrowing government, changing the type or composition of a government
Incompatibility over territory (who controls the territory and how?)
Seizing certain territory, gain independance or political autonomy
Wallensteen trichotomy of a conflict, give empirical examples and solution: Interstate - territory
Russia - Ukraine
ex. Shifting priorities/horse trading - Russia leaves Ukraine –> Ukraine doesn’t join NATO
Wallensteen trichotomy of a conflict, give empirical examples and solution: Intra-state over territory
Turkey - PKK
Wants their own Kurdish state that the government does not accept
ex. Share control - Coalition government
Shift priorities - PKK accept autonomy instead of sovereignty
Wallensteen trichotomy of a conflict, give empirical examples and solution: Intra-state over government
Nepal government - Maoist rebel group
ex. Conflict resolution mechanisms - ordering arbitration or referendums on who should lead the state and how
Wallensteen trichotomy of a conflict, give empirical examples and solution: Intra-state over government B
Syria: Government of Hafez vs. Muslim brotherhood
Muslimbrotherhood was crushed through a bloody assault when being in the occupied Hama. Hama was leveled to the ground and they were defeated.
Incompatibility was the autocratic government, a solution could’ve been share control - coalition government.
7 conflict resolution mechanisms
- Shifting priorities - from overthrowing government to wanting influence over it or accepting autonomy instead of sovereignty
- Dividing resources - splitting and in half or natural resources
- Horse-trading - You support me on A, I support you on policy B or prisoner trading over countries
- Share control - coalition government
- Leave control to other - both agree not to rule on a resource themselves
- Conflict resolution mechanisms - arbitration, referendum, elections
- Leave for later or oblivion - losing symbolic value, not solving all problems at once. Not good for rebel group because of arming up, but could be good if trust is built during that time.
Stages of negotiation
- Pre-negotiation
- Planning
- Intital meeting and analysis
- Inventing options and constructing formulas
- Drafting an agreement
- Signing and ratifying
- Implementing
Negative peace
Absence of direct violence; absence of armed conflict and physical force between individuals or groups.
Is not very likely to be long-lasting sine the grounds for conflict still exist ex. ceasefire.
Absence of positive peace leads to conflcit and then negative peace
Positive peace
Absence of indirect violence; absence of any social injustice (poverty, discrimination, unequal opportunities etc).
Positive peace is more difficult to achieve but longer lasting if successful. Linkages to quality peace.
What levels of analysis are there?
Individual, Nation-sate/society, international/systemic
What belongs to the individual level of analysis
- Human emotions and nature (anger, greed, fear, empathy)
- belief system, cognitive bias (political socialization, education, former experiences).
- Personalities (loving, aggressive, rational)
- Misperceptions/asymmetries (military strength, resources, wiliness to continue, cost willing to bear for the sake of winning)
What belongs to nation-state/societal level of analysis?
Governmental factors:
- Structure of political system
- bureaucracies
Societal factos:
- Class structure
- Politial, economic, political inequalities
- Ethnic fragmentation, nationalism
What belongs to international/systemic level of analysis?
- Anarchic structure of the international system
- Number of major powers
- Distribution of military and economic power between the international system
What is causal theory and what does it answer?
Logical arguments about how different phenomena in the world are related. It answers HOW and WHY a cause has a certain effect.
Definition of social conflict (Pruitt and Kim)
A perceived divergence of interest
Three components of a conflict?
- Actors
- Incompatible issues
- Actions (making claims overt)
Why do conflicts occur according to Kriesberg and Dayton?
- Internal factors - human nature, social psychological responses, group processes
- Relational factors (intergroup) - inequalities (relative depravation), differences in values and beliefs
- Systemic factors - resource scarcities - rational choice approach
- Social identity theory - Group identities based on diverse factors
(ethnicity, religion, politics) etc. - Realistic conflict theory - Competition over scarce resources,
Strategic choice - what are the four strategies
- Contending
- Accommodating
- Problem-solving
- Avoiding
What are the main components of conflcit according to Wallensteen?
Actors, incompatibility, action
What are the three types of violence according to the UCDP?
- State-based armed conflicts
- Non-state armed conflicts
- One-sided violence
What are the differences between inter-state and intrastate conflict (over government and territory)?
Inter-state conflict: Conflict between two parties
Intra-state conflict: Conflict between a non-state actor (rebel group, militia etc) and the government of country.
What dimensions can escalation take place along?
- The level of coercion (severity of acts)
- The scope of it (number of participants mobilized
- The number issues that the conflict is fought over.
What are the three waves identified in the literature on peacekeeping? (match the descriptions to the waves)
First: This wave focuses mainly on peacekeeping in wars between states
Second: This wave is driven by the boom in peacekeeping and reflects critically on failed and dysfunctional peacekeeping missions
Third:
Under what conditions is a party to the conflict most likely to change their tactics toward tactics that lead to de-escalation?
- The contentious tactics used are not perceived to be successful.
- The necessary resources are exhausted.
- The costs of continuing with contentious strategies outweigh the benefits
- There is a loss of support for the cause.
- The economic situation changes for the worse.
What are the purposes of (traditional) peacekeeping?
- Guarantee protection during demobilisation.
- Verify compliance with the terms of the demobilisation process.
- Organise demobilisation.
How can we define nonviolent resistance?
Nonviolent resistance can be defined “as the application of unarmed civilian power using nonviolent methods such as protests, strikes, boycotts, demonstrations without using or threatening physical harm against the opponent
What types of non-state violence exist?
- Ethnic riots
- Communal conflict
- Intergang violence
- Herder-farmer conflicts
Why are groups that forcibly recruit more likely to perpetrate gang rape according to Cohen?
They perpetrate performative violence to make up for low cohesion.