Defenses 1 Flashcards
Modern Accomplice Liability
Defendant is Principal their conduct is:
Person who commits the illegal act or who causes an innocent agent to do so.
Modern Accomplice Liability
Defendant Principal Liability:
Liable for principal crime
Modern Accomplice Liability
Accomplice (includes common law principal in the second degree and accessory before the fact)
Conduct:
Person who aids or encourages principal to commit the illegal conduct
Modern Accompliace Liability
Accomplice (includes common law principal and in the second degree and accessory before the fact.
Liability:
Liable for the principal crime if accomplice intended to aid or encourage crime
Modern Accompliace Liability
Accessory After the Fact
Conduct:
Person who aids another to escape knowing that they have committed a felony
Modern Accomplice Liability
Accessory After Fact
Liability:
Liable for separate, less serious crime of being an accessory after the fact.
Types of Defenses
Credibility of Evidence
Explanation:
Fact-based defense focused on calling into question the credibility of the prosecution’s evidence
Types of Defenses
Credibility of Evidence
Examples:
Misidentification
Witness lying/ bias
Types of Defenses
Government Misconduct
Explanation:
Can be question of law or fact-based argument for jury focused on the legality or thoroughness of the investigation.
Types of Defenses
Government Misconduct
Examples:
Entrapment
Prosecutorial Misconduct
Illegal search or seizure
Forensic errors
Types of Conduct
Sufficiency of the Evidence
Explanation:
Question of law challenging that the government has not presented evidence to prove each element of the offense beyond a reasonable doubt.
Types of Defenses
Sufficiency of the Evidence
Examples:
No proof of requisite mental state
(Mistake of fact/law)
No proof of completed act
Types of Defenses
Affirmative Defenses (Justification and Excuse)
Explanation:
Question of law not challenging that the elements of the offense have been met, but rather that a legal justification or excuse exists.
Types of Defenses
Affirmative Defenses (Justification and Excuse)
Examples:
Self-defense
Duress/ Necessity
Insanity
Intoxication
- The right to counsel (as well as the right to funding for experts)
- The right to confront witnesses against them; and
- The right to present a defense (including the right to present witness on their behalf.)
Constitutional rights of a criminal defendant