Critics Flashcards
Arnold Stein on the war in heaven
‘more than a simple, finished event’
Blair Worden on Satan’s rhetoric
‘Satan’s rhetoric of republicanism signals Milton’s profound disillusion with his own party’
Lydia Schulman on Moloch and his position regarding war
‘Moloch most resembles a stoical military leader of classical times…open war, therefore, is in his self-interest’
Neil Forsyth on the eternal nature of the war
Highlights that an eternal war is one that excludes the possibility of victory
David Quint on Satan’s army
‘the greatest army ever summoned up by epic poetry’
James A. Freeman on Milton’s feelings on war
‘anti-war to the point of pacifism’
Anna Beer on the purpose of the evenly matched nature of the war
‘an example of just how close the battle between good and evil can be’
A. J. Waldock on Milton’s narrator undercutting Satan
‘There is hardly a great speech of Satan’s that Milton is not at pains to correct’
Arnold Stein on Satan’s magnificence
‘Satan is far less magnificent away from his followers’
Christopher Hill on Satan’s motivations and rebel nature
‘Satan has always been a rebel for the wrong reasons – self-interest, jealousy, ambition’
C.S. Lewis on Satan’s motivations
‘Satan wants to go on being Satan. That is the real meaning of his choice’ - it is a war of the right to free will and freedom
Julia Staykova on Milton’s epic similes
‘the Miltonic simile undermines the construction of a visually and temporally solid experience’
Steven Blakemore on evil
‘evil can only imitate and parody goodness’
Neil Forsyth on the way Satan’s sees things
‘Satan sees everything in physical terms’
John Rumrich on Sin the character (2)
‘readers may pity her as a passive victim, more sinned against than sinning’
‘passive voice of duty divinely imposed on her’
Johnson on Milton’s use of allegory
‘undoubtedly faulty’
‘such abstractions should not take part in epic poetry’
Allegorical figures do not occur in classical epics
Stanley Fish
Surprised by Sin - argues that Milton makes the evil of Paradise Lost alluring so that the reading of Paradise Lost mirrors its doctrinal message i.e. the reader falls and is then forced to contemplate why
Malcom M. Ross on the narrator’s attempts to direct the reader
Argues that the narrator’s interjections fail to prevent the reader from falling
David Loewenstein on rhetoric
‘he also sensed how the arts of persuasion may be dangerously exploited’
Daniel Shore on rhetoric
‘the point of rhetoric is not to describe the world but to change it’
N. K. Sugimura on Milton’s use of the fallen angels
‘Milton used his angels to think through the fraught metaphysical relationship between sameness and difference – uniformity and individuality’
C.S. Lewis on Moloch
‘the simple-mindedness of a true general’