Critics Flashcards
Mr Casey
A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man- James Joyce
‘No God for Ireland!…We have had too much God in Ireland. Away with God!’
Trevor L. Williams
‘there is not a single priest who is not somehow morally and intellectually compromised’
Trevor L. Williams
Joyce’s exile
‘Joyce’s self-imposed exile from Dublin was precisely a flight from the ‘net’ of church-state ideology’
Trevor L. Williams
essay intro/conclusion
‘Dubliners is a gallery of human wrecks’
Professor Walz
‘At the end [of The Dead], Joyce suggests, as he had done in all the stories of public life, that people who live meaningless lives of inactivity are the real dead’
Trevor L. Williams
‘Above all, there is paralysis: linguistic, sexual, alcoholic, marital, financial; even history itself seems to have stopped’
Lyons
‘The most prevalent disease in Dubliners is alcoholism’
Kane
Grace, Ivy Day, counterparts
Gratification from alcohol is ‘illusory, temporary and destructive’
David Lloyd
Links the alcoholic excess of Counterparts to the despair of a conquered land – ‘bitterly diagnostic of the paralysis of Irish men in colonial Ireland…which is counterpointed by drinking’
Richard Ellman
on epiphanies
‘Joyce’s discovery…was that the ordinary is the extraordinary’
Declan Kiberd
on Araby epiphany
“sight has been replaced by insight or inner vision”
- because the ‘light was out’ when the boy has his moment of realisation (inversion of traditional light symbolism)
Garry Leonard
Joyce ‘privileges the notion of an “epiphany” as the primary aesthetic building block of his stories’
Garry Leonard
‘The Joycean epiphany does not so much confirm a truth as disrupt what one had grown comfortable accepting as true’
M. Pilar Sanchez Calle
‘Although the portrayal of women is complex, a masculine point of view prevails throughout this work’
Suzette Henke
on Mrs Kearney’s victimisation
She is a ‘victim of her greed and frustration’ but also of a ‘male dominated power structure of bourgeoisie impresarios who control Dublin culture’
Erica Gregory
gender
‘Joyce strives to provide a female perspective of marriage that is often lacking in the male-dominated Ireland’
Trevor L. Williams
joyces delay of marriage
Marriage was a ‘legal apparatus embodying for him both state power and religious oppression’ - refused to marry Nora for 27 years
Shelia C. Conboy
‘Dubliners shows the female body objectified and mystified by the male gaze’
Sheila C. Conboy
The Dead
‘When Gabriel’s desire for his wife is interrupted by her memories of a dead lover, his objectification of her is shattered’
Trevor L. Williams
In Dubliners, marriage is seen as a ‘much more elevated state of ownership’
Jeri Johnson
on Eveline
‘a nuanced depiction of one steeped in competing codes of femininity…dutiful daughter, battered woman, (failed) romantic heroine’