Criminal V2 Flashcards
1st Degree Murder (Elements) - Common Law
- Killing a human
- With “malice aforethought”
- By:
- Particular means specified by statute
- During another crime specified by statute
- With premedittation and deliberation
2nd Degree Murder (Elements) - Common Law
- Killing a human being
- With “malice aforethought”
- And is not first degree
Voluntary Manslaughter (Elements) - Common Law
- Killing a human being
- While in a “heat of passion”
- The heat of passion was reasonable
- No time to cool off (by reasonable person standard)
Involuntary Manslaughter (Elements) - Common Law
- Killing a human being
- While being criminally negligent
“Malice Aforethought” Defined
- Express Malice - intent to kill
- Implied Malice - (Generally 2nd Degree)
- Intent to commit serious bodily injury
- Depraved Heart
- Felony Murder
Felony Murder Rule
A killing, even an accidental one, wil be murder if it was caused with the intent to commit a felony.
Merger Doctrine
If a defendant commits a single act that simultaneously fulfills the definition of two seperate offesnes, the two charges merge together. (lesser offense drops out)
Felony murder rule does not apply to assaultive felonies
Agency Rule
If a third party was proximate cause of death, no felony murder
Murder (Elements) - MPC
- Causing the death of another human being
- With
- Purpose or knowledge
- Extreme indifference to the value of human life
- While committing a listed crime
- Robbery, Rape, Arson, Burglary, Kidnapping, or felonious escape.
Manslaughter (Elements) - MPC
- Murder (see elements for Murder)
- While under “extreme mental or emotional disturbance for which there is a reasonable excuse” from the view of the defendant
Involuntary Homicide (Elements) - MPC
- Causing the death of another human being
- While reckless or negligent
Forcible Rape (Elements)
- Intercourse of any kind
- With lack of consent
- Due to:
- Force
- Threat of Force
- Unconciousness
- Incapacity to Consent (Legal)
- Due to:
Mistake of Consent Defense
Defense is available if mistake is “reasonable and honest”
Statutory Rape (Elements)
- Intercourse (Strict Liability)
- With a minor
Larceny (Elements) - Common Law
- Unlawful taking
- Carrying away (no matter how slight)
- From the possession of another
- With the intent to permanently deprive the owner
Burglary (Elements) - Common Law
- Breaking and entering
- A dwelling
- At night
- With the intent to commit a felony
Robbery (Elements) - Common Law
- Larceny
- From the victims person or immediate presence
- Using force or threat of force
Burglary (Elements) - MPC
- Entering
- A building or occupied structure
- With purpose to commit a crime
Robbery (Elements) - MPC
- Theft (basically larceny at common law)
- While threatening or inflicting serious bodily injury (or while committing a 1st or 2nd degree felony)
Attempt (Elements) - Common Law
- Requires an “overt act”
- That is more than mere preparation
- Unequivocally Test: do the acts unequivocally manifest criminal intent
- Dangerous Proximity Test: acts were dangerously proximity to success.
- With the intent to commit the target offense; and
- With the intent to take the overt act
Renunciation Doctrine
- Voluntarily abandoned the attempt (not from fear of being caught or difficulty); and
- Renunciation is complete (not postponed)
Attempt (Elements) - MPC
- Defendant does or omits to do anything
- That is a substantial step in the commission of the crime
- Examples: lying in wait, following or searching for the victim, enticing the victim, reconnoitering, unlawful entry, possession of materials to be used in crime
- With the required mens rea of the underlying crime
- Defendant purposely took the substantial step
- Defendant planned to commit the crime
Accomplice Liability (Elements)
- Assisting the principal by: encouragement, physical assistance, or omission
- With the intent to assist the principal; and
- Intent that the principal commit the crime
Conspiracy (Elements) - Common Law
- A bilateral agreement to commit a crime
- An overt act by one of the co-conspirators
- With the intent to enter into an agreement; and
- With the intent to commit, or aid in committing the targetted crime
Conspiracy (Elements) - MPC
- A unilateral agreement to commit a crime
- With the purpose to enter into an agreement; and
- Purpose to commit or aid in committing the targetted crime
- An overt act for felonies 3rd degree or below (otherwise not required)
Voluntary Intoxication Defense - Common Law
Intoxication prevents the defendant from forming the criminal intent necessary to commit the crime
- Available for Specific Intent Crimes
- Crimes that require intent to do some further harmful act (X with the intent to X, or X for the purpose of X)
- Unavailable for General Intent Crimes
- All other crimes
Voluntary Intoxication Defense - MPC
- Defendant is voluntarily intoxicated
- Negates an element of the offense
- Not available to disprove recklessness or above
Involuntary Intoxication Defense - Common Law
- Defendant was involuntarily intoxicated
- Intoxication made the defendant temporarily insane
- Four Circumstances:
1. Fault of another (force, fraud, duress)
2. Innocent Mistake (didn’t know it was an intoxicant)
3. Unknowingly have a condition that makes them abnormally susceptible to intoxicants
4. Unexpected Intoxication from medically prescribed drugs
- Four Circumstances:
Involuntary Intoxication Defense - MPC
- Defendant was involuntarily intoxicated
- Defendant was unable to appreciate the criminality of his conduct or to conform his conduct to the requirements.
Mistake of Law Defense
- Not an excuse; unless
- Crime requires knowledge of the law as an element
- Tax evasion, insider trading, etc.
Mistake of Fact Defense - Common Law
- Must negate the mens rea of the crime
- Specific Intent Crime: mistake can be unreasonable
- General Intent Crime: Mistake must be reasonable
Legal Wrong Test: no defense if defendant’s view of facts, he was still committing a crime (punished for how facts actually were)
Mistake of Fact Defense - MPC
- Must negate the mens rea of the crime
- Mistake does not need to be reasonable
- Mistake can sometimes result in lower level crime being charged/convicted
Legal Wrong Test: No defense if facts as defendant believed them, defendant was still committing a crime (punished for crime based on facts as defendant believed them)