Criminal Procedure Flashcards
Welfare and Institution Code 707
Do what is in the best interest of the juvenile including sending them to prison
Prop. 21
DA has discretion on whether to try the juvenile as an adult or a juvenile
Intervene (cop)
Have to reasonably believe that the person is a felon to use deadly force
Juvenile Process (indigent parents)
Have the right to appointed counsel
Insanity
NGI defense = Not Guilty; Insane
Plea = not guilty or not guilty for reason of insanity
Considered to be winning the case if granted
Person will be locked up in an insane asylum to go through treatment and be released upon being cured
Defense of Others
Using enough force as is necessary to defend another person
Burden on the defendant
Defense of Habitation
The closer an offender gets to a house, the more the rules change
If they are in the house, they are trespassing
CA: If the victim intrudes on a home and the occupant reasonably believes that the person will commit a crime other than an entry and they MIGHT use physical force to commit that crime, deadly force used against them is permitted.
Rule has been extended to apply to someone who is trying to physically harm (substantial damage) the house (arson cases from the outside).
Force cannot be excessive
Sentencing takes place…
in superior court. Each county has a superior court
Necessity
Crime was necessary
Ex: speeding to get someone to the hospital
Burden on the defendant
Imperfect Self-Defense
The defendant was wrong
Defendant thought they should act when they really shouldn’t have
Burden on the defendant
3 Strikes CA
All 3 offenses have to be serious or violent and all have to be strikes =25 to life
Intervene (non-cop)
Using force that is deadly requires a reasonable belief that the crime will result in death or GBI before the non-cop can use deadly force
Have to KNOW that the person is a felon before they use deadly force
Gebtz (he shoots some guys on a subway who were demanding $5 from him, they threatened him with screwdrivers)
D has burden of proof
Exception: “I had no choice”
Middle Term
Judge is ordered to give this term in felony cases
3yrs
Self-Defense
Using enough force that is necessary to protect yourself but no more
No duty to retreat law in CA
Burden on the defendant
Juvenile Process (petition)
Complaint
Juvenile Process (disposition)
Conviction
Juvenile Process (3rd Step)
Status Conference
Same as pretrial conference for adults
Judge wants to know if the case has settled
Happens 3-4 weeks after detention hearing
There could be multiple status conferences
3 reasons Dr. Bronson gives in favor of the death penalty
Does it deter?
Is it cheeper to execute the inmate?
Retribution or revenge?
Upper Term
5yrs
Juvenile Process (5th Step)
Jurisdictional Hearing
Same as an adult trial
State becomes the parent
Issue is: does the court have jurisdiction over this minor? Does the court have jurisdiction to dispose of the juvenile? Judge will decide these things.
If yes –> the court will act as the juvenile’s parent
Juvenile Process (5)
- Petition filed
- Detention Hearing
- Status Conference
- Dispositional Bargaining
- Jurisdictional Hearing
- Dispositional Hearing
Juvenile Process (6th Step)
Disposition Hearing
Same as a sentencing hearing in adult court
Judge can give lower, upper, or middle term
Judge can dispose the juvenile or find jurisdiction over them
Aggravating and mitigating circumstances
Juvenile Process (2nd Step)
Detention Hearing
Same as “arraignment” for adults
Charges
Max punishment
Custodial status
Appointment of attorney
DA will argue: do we detain the juvenile in Juvi until the hearing?
Probation department is involved but considers Juvi instead of jail (no such thing as bail in juvenile cases)
Can be released with juvenile and adult terms and conditions (ex: curfew)
Alex Cape-Jones
The best boyfriend ever!
Loves you very much!
Is willing to do anything for you.
Is here to help you out during finals.
Juvenile Justice System’s goal
To do what is the best interest of the juvenile. To establish jurisdiction over the juvenile.
Juvenile Process (if not sent to Juvi, then…)
Foster care
Grandparent’s house
Home with terms and conditions
Long Term Sentencing (juveniles)
CA Youth Authority (CYA)
Boot camp
Juvenile Hall
Lower (mitigated) Term
Mitigating circumstances outweigh aggravating circumstances
1 yr
Juvenile Process (4th Step)
Disposition Bargaining Same as plea bargaining Can continue the matter: 1. Juvenile attends counseling 2. Juvenile getting better -->Status Conference (3rd Step) in 4 months (there could be multiple status conferences) Two ways the case can go: 1. Disposition Hearing (repeat 6th step) OR 2. Jurisdictional Hearing (5th step)
Is it cheeper to execute an inmate? (Bronson)
No; it’s more expensive than incarceration
Added costs include:
Pretrial and trial costs for death penalty
Automatic appeal
State & federal habeus corpus
Incarceration for life
Juvenile Process (prosecutor’s strategy)
Juveniles do not have the right to a jury trial
Sometimes prosecutor will want the juvenile to be charged as an adult to get a jury trial (Prop. 21 or 707 motion) if is in the bet interest of the juvenile
Juvenile Process (attorneys…)
Attorneys are supposed to do what is in the best interest of the juvenile
Prosecutor is not supposed to prosecute too hard.
Defense is not supposed to try too hard to get the juvenile off.
Alibi
Defense proves that the defendant was at a different place at the time the crime was committed
Whatever places the defendant in the circumstance where it couldn’t have been them that committed the crime
Juvenile Process (burden of proof)
Burden of proof is still beyond a reasonable doubt
Highest standard
Affirmative Defenses
Self-Defense Imperfect Self-Defense Defense of Others Defense of Habitation Defense of Property Public Authority Domestic Authority Insanity Temporary Insanity Prevention of Crime (Intervene) Entrapment Alibi Necessity
Enhancements
Additional aggravating circumstances that can tack on additional years
Juvenile Process (1st Step)
Petition (complaint) is filed
Juvenile Process (judges…)
Make the ruling on where the juvenile will go
4019 Credits
Take time off the top of time already served (ex: 3yrs - 6months already served).
Prevention of Crime (intervene)
To defend persons or property
Force cannot be excessive
Can intervene on felony but not misdemeanors unless they involve a breach of peace (violence)
Any amount of non-violent force is permitted as long as it is reasonably necessary to prevent the crime from happening
Commonwealth v. Emmonds
Public Authority
Perception of a cop’s overreaction (use of excessive force)
Allow a person to do something that they would otherwise not be able to do if it wasn’t for their authoritative position
Told to commit a crime by a public authority
Under color of law or under cover of authority
As long as they do not exceed the authority they are given (excessive force)
Cannot depart from authority given
State v. Manteli
Juvenile Process (prosecutor gets to…)
Decide whether the juvenile is charged as a juvenile or as an adult.
Prop. 21
Three Strikes
All three counts have to be serious or violent offenses
If the third offense is a regular felony, then the sentence is just doubled
If the defendant practices their right to refuse probation or if the judge refuses to grant probation…
Will be sentenced with the max penalty which is 365 days in CA
6th Amendment
Right to speedy, public, jury trial. Right to counsel and witnesses
Domestic Authority
Punishment must be: 1. Reasonably necessary to protect the welfare of the child 2. Reasonably related to the conduct 3. Proportional to the conduct Ex: Parents spanking their children
Does the death penalty deter? (Bronson)
Compliance with the law increases as the penalty increases
Juveniles cannot get…
LWOP or death
Entrapment
Police officers convinced someone to do something that they were not otherwise predisposed to do
Brought up by way of motion; not in front of a jury
Juveniles can go to state prison when…
They turn 18