Criminal Law workshop 1 Flashcards
What is a crime?
- behaviour which is recognised as deserving of punishment
- a public wrongdoing deserving of punishment
- something which is committed against society
What are the reasons for criminalising behaviour?
- incapacitation
- rehabilitation
- deterrence
- other punishment
- protection
What are the two approaches to criminalising behaviour?
- moralist approach
- utilitarian approach
What is the moralist approach to criminalising behaviour?
- seeks to criminalise behaviour which is regarded as immoral, EVEN IF no harm has been done
What is the utilitarian approach to criminalising behaviour?
- seeks to criminalise behaviour which is BOTH morally blameworthy and causes harm
What is the rule of law
- there can be no criminal liability unless the conduct is prescribed by the law (conduct is part of a criminal offence)
- there can be no criminal liability unless the offender is convicted following a proper trial
What is the classification for criminal offences?
- summary only offences
- either-way offences
- indictable only offences
- all offences start in the magistrates
Summary offence
- can only be tried in magistrates
- less serious crimes
- minor assault
Either -way offence
- can be tried by magistrates or crown
- middle range of offences
- theft, burglary, dangerous driving
Indictable only offence
- only tried in the crown
- most serious crimes
- murder, rape
Difference between crown and magistrates
- magistrates judge decides points of law and fact
- crown judge decides the point of law, jury decides the point of fact and decides if guilty or not guilty
How is it decided whether a case will be tried in the magistrates or crown?
- magistrates have to consider its sentencing powers
- if they think the conviction deserved is outside of their sentencing powers, they will refer the case to the crown
Who has the burden of proving a criminal offence
the PROSECUTION
- duty of the prosecution to prove the prisoner’s guilt
Is there a burden of proof on the defence?
- there are some situations where the defendant has to prove a defence
- called evidential burden
- includes self-defence and insanity
What is the standard of proof for the prosecution
beyond reasonable doubt
What is the standard of proof for the defence
on a balance of probabilities
Criminal Appeals - appeal against a conviction by the jury
if the court of appeal decides there was an error of law made by the judge, the conviction is quahsed