Criminal Law/Procedure Flashcards
Merger of Crimes
ONLY for solicitation and attempt merge into substantive offense.
There is NO merger for conspiracy – separate crime.
Essential elements of a crime
1) Physical acts (acts reus): own volition, but not reflective, convulsive or unconscious; and
2) Mental state (mens rea)
What are the Specific Intent Crimes?
BAM ACTS: Burglary, Assault, Murder (1st degree), Attempt, Conspiracy, Theft, Solicitation
Malice Crimes
Reckless disregard of obviously high risk of harm
What are two different Malice crimes?
Second-degree murder and Arson
General Intent Crimes
Awareness of all factors constituting crime (e.g., awareness of act or high likelihood it will occur)
Strict Liability Crimes
No required awareness
Transferred Intent
Two charges - attempt and offense
Accomplice Liablity
Liable for crime itself and all foreseeable crimes
Requires active involvement (e.g., aid, counsel or encourage, with INTENT TO AID)
Solicitation
Asking someone to commit a crime.
Requires intent for person to commit the crime
the crimes is completed at the asking – if the other person accepts, it merges into conspiracy.
Conspiracy
(1) an agreeement; (2) intent to agree; (3) unlawful obj.
MAJ J.: Requires an overt act.
Liability: all foreseeable crimes committed to further conspiracy
Withdrawal: requires (1) affirmative act notifying all members of withdrawal and (2) assistance in neutralizing.
If withdrawal is successful: cuts off liability for subsequent crimes of co-conspirators, not conspiracy itself
Attempt
specific intent to commit the actual offense + substantial step beyond mere preparation
Defense 1: Insanity
Defense to ALL, including strict liability
D has the burden of production
Defense 2: Intoxication
Voluntary –> only a defense to Specific Intent Crimes
Involuntary –> like insanity. It is a defense to ALL, including SL.
1) taking drugs/alcohol
2) w/o knowledge, under duress, or pursuant to med advice without awareness of intoxicating effect
Defense 3: Infancy
If below 7 then NO liability
If above 14 then rebuttable presumption of no liability.
M’Naghten Test
First Insanity test
At time of conduct, D lacked ability to know wrongfulness of actions or nature/quality of actions
Irresistible Impulse Test
Second Insanity test
D lacks the capacity for self-control & free choice , or unable to conform conduct to the law.
MPC Test
Third Insanity test
D lacked the capacity to (i) appreciate criminality of conduct OR (ii) conform conduct to req’s of law.
Durham rule
Fourth Insanity test
D’s conduct was product fo mental illness
Self-Defense
An excuse/justification for a crime
Non-deadly: if reasonably necessary
Deadly: (i) D without fault; (ii) confronted w/ unlawful force; (iii) reasonably believe to be threatened w/ imminent death/great bodily harm
MIN. J.: retreat unless in person’s home; making lawful arrest; or victim of rape/robbery. But original aggressor must withdraw and communicate withdrawal
Defense of Others
An excuse/justification
Person assisted reasonably appeared to have legal right to use force in his own defense
Defense of property
an excuse/justification
Non-deadly force OK. No force allowed to regain possession unless in hot pursuit
Crime Prevention
Non deadly force to prevent felony or breach of peace
Deadly force only to prevent a dangerous felony (BARRK)
Effectuate Arrest
Private Person: Deadly force only IF person harmed was guilty of offense
Officer: Deadly force to apprehend fleeing felon who threatens death/serious bodily harm and necessary to prevent escape
Duress
excuse/justification
threats of imminent infliction of death/great bodily harm to person or third party (member of immediate family)
Does not excuse or justify homicide
Necessity
reasonably necessary to avoid imminent and greater injury to society
Private necessity = liable for property damage to other
no excuse for homicide
Impossibility
other defense
Factual impossibility = no defense
Legal impossibility = not illegal to do what D intended to do
Mistake of fact
other defense
Specific Intent Crimes = any mistake is defense
Malice/Gen. intent crimes = reasonable mistake only
Strict liability crimes = never
Consent
other defense
Only if crime requires lack of consent (e.g., rape)
requirements:
1) consent voluntarily/freely given
2) legally capable; and
3) no fraud
Entrapments
other defense
Only IF police originated criminal design and D was not predisposed to commit act