Criminal Law > Elements of Crimes Flashcards
Elements of a CrimeA crime almost always requires proof of 3 elements. A crime may also require 2 additional elements. What are they?
Almost always proof of1. a physical act (actus reus)2. a mental state (mens rea), and3. concurrence of the act and mental stateSometimes proof of:4. proof of a result and5. causation (i.e. that the act caused the harmful result)
Elements of a Crime > Actus ReusActus Reus (the physical act of a crime) could come in 3 forms. What are they?
- Physical or external component of a crime2. Voluntary act; or3. Omission which violates a legal to duty to act or aid
Elements of a Crime > Actus ReusWhat are three examples of a physical or external component of a crime that could fulfill it’s Actus Reus requirement?
- prohibited conduct (e.g. speeding)2. prohibited result (e.g. killing); or3. attendant circumstances (e.g. age of victim)
Elements of a Crime > Actus ReusGenerally there is no legal duty to act or aid another. But when a crime’s Actus Reus comes from an omission which violates a legal duty to act or aid, what are the 5 potential sources of its duy?
- statute (e.g. paying taxes, reporting child abuse)2. contract (e.g. nurse, nanny)3. relationship (e.g. parent, spouse)4. assumption of care (e.g., Misery)5. creation of peril (e.g. hitting pedestrian)
Elements of a Crime > Mens ReaWhat is Mens Rea?
Mens Rea is the mental or internal component of a crime.
Elements of a Crime > Mens ReaThere are 4 types of common law crimes that require different degrees of Mens Rea. What are they and what is the Mens Rea requirement?
- Specific intent crimes: Purpose– acting with a conscious object to do something2. Malice crimes: Knowledge– Awareness that the conduct is of a particular nature or will cause a particular result3. General intent crimes: Awareness– Awareness of acting in a proscribed manner4. Strict liability crimes: No Mens Rea– Awareness of committing the act.
Elements of a Crime > Mens ReaName the 4 types of common law specific intent crimes.
- first-degree murder2. assault3. inchoate offenses (solicitation, attempt, conspiracy)4. property-related offenses (larceny, embezzlement, false pretenses, robbery, burglary, forgery)
Elements of a Crime > Mens ReaName the 3 common law malice crimes.
- murder2. arson3. malicious mischief
Elements of a Crime > Mens ReaName 4 types of common law general intent crimes.
- rape2. battery3. kidnapping4. ALL OTHER CRIMES that don’t require specific intent or malice (and are not subject to the exception of strict liability) - This is a catch-all
Elements of a Crime > Mens ReaName the 3 types of strict liability offenses that require no Mens Rea at all.
- statutory rape2. public health and safety regulations (e.g. traffic, health and sanitation codes, selling liquor to minors, etc.)3. bigamy (in some jurisdictions)
Inchoate OffensesWhat are these crimes? What category of mens rea?
Solicitation, Attempt and Conspiracy - specific intentThese are specific intent crimes with the goal of committing some target crime. They cannot be committed through negligence or recklessness.
Inchoate Offenses > SolicitationElements?
- Actus Reus: Asking or encouraging someone to commit a crime.2. Mens Rea: With the intent that they commit the crime.
Inchoate Offenses > Solicitation3 Liability Rules:
a. Solicitation is complete once words are spoken.b. Merger into completed target offense.c. Impossibility is no defense.
Inchoate Offenses > ConspiracyElements and majority rule/common law/MPC distinctions
- Actus Reus: An agreement to commit an unlawful act2. Mens Rea: Intent to achieve the object of the agreement3. An overt act in furtherance of conspiracy, however minor. - Majority of states - NOT required at Common Law4. Both parties to the agreement must have the intent to achieve the target objective. - Majority rule/common law “Bilateral Rule” - ONLY 1 PARTY under UPC
Inchoate Offenses > ConspiracyLiability Rules:
- Conspirators may be liable for 3 different crimes2. You cannot withdraw liability retroactively3. Impossibility is no defense
Inchoate Offenses > ConspiracyLiability Rule 1: Conspirators may be liable for 3 different crimes. Which 3?
a. conspiracy;b. completed target crime (there is NO merger); andc. all foreseeable crimes by co-conspirators in furtherance of the conspiracy.e.g., Elinor and Marianne agree to rob a bank with fake guns. E hides a real gun in her purse and shoots dead a guard during the robbery.- What crimes are M liable for?- ALL of them! 1) conspiracy, 2) armed robbery, AND 3) murder***It is foreseeable that Elinor would shoot and murder an armed guard to aid in the armed robbery because she hid a real gun in her purse for the robbery. Marianne is liable for that.