Criminal Law and Procedure Flashcards
What are the elements of a crime?
Elements:
- Physical act (actus reus);
- Mental State element (mens rea);
- Causation (actual and proximate cause); AND
- Concurrence (mental state and physical act occur at the same time).
Priority: HIGH
When is an Omission to act considered a crime?
- The defendant had a legal duty to act;
- The defendant had knowledge of facts concerning the duty to act; AND
- It was reasonably possible for the defendant to act.
Priority: Medium
What does Causation require?
It requires both:
- Actual causation (but for); AND
- Proximate cause (it was foreseeable that the injury would have occurred from the defendant’s physical act).
Priority: HIGH
What is a Superseding Intervening Cause?
It is a third-party’s act that breaks the chain of causation. This normally cuts off the defendant’s liability.
An act will ONLY break the chain if the force was:
- Independent of the defendant’s wrongful conduct; AND
- Not foreseeable.
Priority: HIGH
What is the Simultaneous Acts Rule?
A person’s acts will still be the proximate cause of a resulting injury if his wrongful conduct created a condition of peril.
A wrongful act that accelerates death is still the legal cause of death, even if the person was going to die eventually.
Priority: HIGH
Under the Common Law, what mental state categories were used?
Mental states under the Model Penal Code?
Common Law: Specific Intent, General Intent, Malice, & Strict liability.
MPC: Purposefully, Knowingly, Recklessly, & Criminal Negligence.
*Willful Blindness Standard: A person acts knowingly when they are aware that certain facts are highly probable OR are intentionally ignorant of them.
Priority: HIGH
Murder
When is a Malice Aforethought killing established?
Upon a showing of:
- An intent to kill;
- An intent to inflict great bodily injury;
- A reckless disregard of an extreme risk to human life; OR
- An intent to commit an inherently dangerous felony under the felony murder rule.
Priority: HIGH
Murder
Second Degree Murder
vs.
First Degree Murder
Second Degree Murder: The unlawful killing of a person with malice aforethought.
First Degree Murder: Occurs when the killing was willful, deliberate, AND premeditated.
Priority: HIGH
Murder
Murder under the Model Penal Code (MPC)
The killing of a person either:
- Committed purposely/knowingly; OR
- Recklessly under circumstances manifesting an extreme indifference to the value of human life.
*Recklessness and indifference are presumed if the killing occurred during the commission of or an attempt to commit a dangerous felony (Felony Murder Rule).
Priority: HIGH
Murder
Felony Murder Rule
A person is guilty of murder if a person is killed during their:
- Commission of (or attempt to commit) a dangerous felony; OR
- Felony escape.
*Dangerous felony = robbery, rape, arson, burglary, kidnapping
Priority: HIGH
What is Voluntary Manslaughter?
An intentional killing of a person without malice aforethought (adequate provocation).
Adequate provocation is established if:
- The defendant was provoked;
- A reasonable person would have been provoked;
- There was not enough time to cool off before the killing; AND
- The defendant DID NOT cool off before the killing.
Priority: HIGH
What is Involuntary Manslaughter?
An unintentional killing of a person committed:
- Recklessly;
- Under the Misdemeanor Murder Rule; OR
- During a non-dangerous felony.
Priority: HIGH
What is Manslaughter under the Model Penal Code (MPC)?
The killing of a person:
- Committed recklessly; OR
- Which would otherwise be murder, but is committed under the influence of extreme mental or emotional disturbance.
*The MPC doesn’t distinguish between voluntary/involuntary manslaughter.
Priority: HIGH
What are the elements of Larceny?
The:
- Trespassory taking,
- And carrying away,
- Of the personal property of another,
- With the intent to permanently deprive the owner of the property.
*Larceny by Trick = when one obtains possession of another’s property by trick or deception.
Priority: HIGH
What are the elements of False Pretenses?
It occurs when one:
- Obtains title,
- To personal property of another,
- Through a known false statement of material fact,
- With the intent to defraud.
*Opinion or commercial puffery is NOT false pretenses.
Priority: HIGH
What are the elements of Embezzlement?
- The fraudulent or wrongful,
- Conversion,
- Of personal property of another,
- By a person with lawful possession of the property.
Priority: HIGH
What are the elements for the crime of Receiving Stolen Property?
When a person:
- Receives possession of stolen property,
- Who knows the property is stolen at the time of receiving it, AND
- With the intent to permanently deprive the owner of the property.
Priority: HIGH
What are the elements of Robbery?
- The trespassory taking and carrying away,
- Of the personal property of another person,
- In their presence;
- By the use of force or threat of immediate physical harm,
- With the intent to permanently deprive the owner of the property.
*Armed robbery requires the elements above, PLUS the use of a dangerous weapon.
Priority: Medium
What are the elements of Burglary?
Burglary is:
- The breaking and entering,
- Of a dwelling,
- Of another,
- At night,
- For the purpose of committing a felony inside.
*Most jurisdictions have extended burglary to any structure at any time.
Priority: HIGH
Under the Common Law, what are the elements of Rape?
- The unlawful sexual intercourse,
- Of a woman by a man (not her husband),
- Without her consent.
*Under the common law, a husband could not be convicted of raping his wife. The modern definition now contains marital rape.
Priority: Medium
Rape
When is there a Lack of Effective Consent?
When:
- Actual force is used;
- Threats of immediate great bodily harm are used;
- The victim is incapable of consenting; OR
- The defendant fraudulently caused the victim to believe that the act is not intercourse.
Priority: Medium
Under the MPC, when is a man guilty of rape?
If:
- He compels her to submit by force or by threat of imminent death, serious bodily injury, extreme pain, or kidnapping;
- He has substantially impaired her power to consent by secretly drugging her;
- The female is unconscious; OR
- The female is under 10 years old.
*Deviate sexual intercourse is gender neutral and has the same elements as above.
Priority: Medium
What are the elements of Statutory Rape?
- The unlawful sexual intercourse,
- With a person,
- Under the age of consent, regardless of whether it’s against the person’s will.
*This is a Strict Liability crime.
Priority: Medium
Battery vs. Assault
Battery: Unlawful application of force, directly or indirectly upon another person (or their clothes/belongings) that results in an injury or offensive contact. (General Intent Crime).
Assault is either:
- An attempted battery; OR
- The intentional creation of a reasonable apprehension of imminent bodily harm to a person.
Priority: Medium