Criminal Law Flashcards
R v Woolmington
D showed gun to wife, it went off and killed her - proof beyond reasonable doubt
Hill v Baxter
Act must be voluntary action - D ignored stop sign and crashed but claimed he was in automation
State of affairs
Offences where D is found in this particular circumstances, irrelevant of how they got there.
State of affairs case
Winzar v CC Kent
Police put drunk man out of hospital into their vehicle and arrested him one on the road for being drunk on the highway
Exceptions of Positive Action Principle
Omissions
Omission by Contractual Duty
R v Adomako
Anaesthetist failed to notice or check faulty breathing tube
Omission by virtue of relationship
R v Gibbins and Proctor
Parents failed to feed child who died of starvation
Omission by Voluntarily taking care of another
R v Evans
Teen heroin addict overdosed on heroin provided by half-sister and died after mum and sister failed to get help
Omission by duty from holding a public office
R v Dytham
D was policeman and failed to intervene in violent attack
Omission by duty from Ds conduct
R v Miller
D (squatter) started fire from cigarette in empty home and didn’t attempt to help
‘But for’ test
R v Pagett
D used girlfriend as human shield against policeman. She was shot and died.
Novus Actus Interveniens -
Third party intervention
R v Smith
Soldier stabbed another in lung, who was given incorrect treatment and died. Stab was overwhelming cause of death so original stabbed was guilty.
Novia Actus Interveniens -
Act of Victim
R v Roberts
Girl jumped from car to escape sexual advances and was injured from jump.
Novus Actus Interveniens -
Natural but predictable act
R v Blaue
Woman stabbed and declined blood transfusion for religious reasons (thin skull rule)
Direct intent
Obvious purpose
R v Mohan
D drives at policeman intending to scare/ injure him
Oblique/ indirect intent
Virtual certainty
R v Woolin
D throws baby against wall who dies - the death was a virtual certainty of his actions
Recklessness
R v Cunningham
D takes gas meter off wall to steal money inside. Gas leak injures neighbours.
Oblique/ indirect intent test
- Was the outcome a virtual certainty of Ds actions?
- Did D realise this?
Subjective recklessness test
- Was D aware of the risk?
- Did D take the risk anyway?