Criminal law Flashcards
What is the criminal law? The distinction between criminal and civil law?
Criminal law is a specific branch of law. It is a system of legal rules that express community standards, determines whether they have been violated (that is crime) and allocates punishment (that are consequences of crime).
The distinction between criminal and civil
Civil law - the relationship between individuals (making agreements). Protect - not suffer from damage. The main consequence is monetary compensation (Plaintiff- Private party, Defendant - private party).
Criminal law - the relationship between individuals and community. A consequence of the action is not only monetary compensation but also social compensation (imprisonment). (Plaintiff - Government, Defendant - private party).
List of the constitutional principles which concern criminal law
1) Principle of legality (nullum crimen nulla poena sine lege: no crime, no punishment without law)
2) Principle of materiality (nullum crimen nulla poena sine actione: no crime, no punishment without a material act)
3) Harm principle (nullum crimen nulla poena sine iniuria: no crime, no punishment without a real offense)
4) Principle of culpability (nullum crimen nulla poena sine culpa, no punishment without a real culpability)
List and define the elements of the crime of Unauthorized access to an IT or a telematic system
Sec. 615-ter Italian Criminal Code
Whoever
1) illegally (i.e. without defence);
2) logs himself into (or enters) a computer or a telematic system;
3) which is protected by security measures (i.e. not open access or free access);
4) or stays inside the system against the will of those who have the right to exclude it,
5) is punished with imprisonment up to three years.
1) Illegally:forexample,
- in a first time the perpetrator was authorized to access the system, then the authorization was revoked;
- a public officer, who works at the Criminal Court, can enter the telematic system of the Court within the scope of his duties; but if he – staying at home, outside working hours – enters the system to verify if his neighbor has been convicted, the access becomes illegal.
How can cybercrime be defined? what are 2 basic forms of cybercrime
criminal acts committed using electronic communications networks and information systems or against such networks and systems.
We can make a distinction between two basic forms of criminal offences:
- Offenses where digital technology is the tool or the instrument of the crime;
- Offenses where digital technology is the target of criminal activity.
Cyber crime in a narrow sense (computer crime):
any illegal behaviour directed by means of electronic operations that targets the security of computer systems and the data processed by them;
and
• Cyber crime in a broader sense (computer-related crime):
any illegal behavior committed by means of, or in relation to, a computer system or network, including such crimes as illegal possession and offering or disturbing information by means of a computer system or network.
List the main types of cyber criminals and explain the importance of cyber criminology
Cyber criminality -People who intentionally abuse and misuse ICT cover a spectrum of criminals.
TYPES OF CYBER CRIMINALS:
- Children and adolescents;
- Organised hackers;
- Professional hackers/crackers – White-collar criminals: their criminal activity is motivated by financial gain.
But also:
- Criminals with a specific personal motivation;
- Accidental cyber criminals;
- Low profile cyber criminals.
Common traits of cyber criminals:
• Technical knowledge;
• Generally non-violent individuals;
•Tendency to not perceive himself/herself as a criminal (e.g.: rationalizations about why particular laws are invalid or should not apply to them);
• Lack of perception of the damages caused to the victim.
•Cyber criminology is a valuable tool that can give investigations many clues about the person who commits a specific crime or series of crimes.
Criminal profiling - science of developing a description of a criminal’s characteristics (physical, intellectual, and emotional) based on information collected at the crime scene, in order to determine the identity of the person that committed a specific crime.
Digital profiling -A new tool to digital investigation, that analyses the digital memory through specific technical and intelligence profiling (through mining, comparison and recognition of digital profiles of a user digital device), in order to obtain information useful to reconstruct the user fingerprint and the description of the modus operandi, and to identify the perpetrator of a crime
what are the risk factors and the main characteristics of cybercrime
Use of ICT (Information and Communications Technology) to commit crimes:
• has a global reach;
• leads to deterritorialisation, which implies that cybercrime is almost by
definition transnational;
• allows for decentralized, flexible networks in which perpetrators can organize themselves to divide labour or to share skills, knowledge, and tools;
• facilitates anonymity,
• enables distant interaction with victims, removing potential social
barriers that perpetrators face in physical, person-to-person interaction;
• reduces the costs of crime, allowing for automation of criminal processes
has structural limitations to capable guardianship that can serve as a social or technical obstacle to commit crime;
• has rapid innovation cycles.
* it is the combination of such factors that makes cybercrime a special challenge for the legislators.
Characteristics of cyber crimes:
Two of the main characteristics that confer to cybercrime its specificity come from the perceived anonymity and the transnational character.
Transnational character can be met also in the case of the classical forms of crime, but not to the same degree. Time, distance, and national borders are much less important than in traditional crime.
These traits make difficult identifying the offender or the place where he/she operates and much more difficult to prosecute him/her and consequently to apply a sentence.
What are substantive law and its difference from criminal procedural law?
Substantive Criminal Law involves:
• the general principles that apply to all crimes (so called “general part” of Criminal Law), and
• the definition of specific crimes and their punishment (“special part” of Criminal Law)
It is distinguished from Criminal
Procedure Law, which involves the study of all the rules and standards governing the detection, investigation, evidence and prosecution of a crime: in short, how the Law is enforced by the judge.
Substantive Criminal Law
What is crime? Concepts, Categories, Notions about Criminal Law.
For example: intention, negligence, defence… Definitions of single crimes: theft, bribery, murder, sexual offences.
Criminal Procedure Law
How to do a trial: Investigations, arrest and charge, first court appearance, evidences.
Trial; verdict and sentencing; imprisonment/Fine
Social functions of criminal law
Retribution: punishment is meted out to the offender because this is what he deserves in response to his infraction of the Criminal Law (you have killed somebody>you deserve prison)
• General deterrence: dissuading other possible offenders from offending by the example made of each particular offender (punishing murder, the State prevents murders in general);
• Special deterrence: dissuading the individual criminal from re- offending in the future (punishing a specific murder, the State prevents other murders by the same killer);
• Rehabilitation: the purpose of the training and treatment of convicted prisoners shall be to encourage and assist them to lead a good and useful life (punishing a specific murder, the State gives a moral example, re-educates the guilty person).
Describe the principle of legality
Article 25 of the Constitution:
No one can be punished if not in compliance with a law that was in force before the act was committed.
No crime without law
No punishment without law
Corollaries:
1) the prohibition to interpret criminal law by analogy, punishing actions that the Law does not expressly describe as “crime” (if a behavior is not expressly punished, it is not a crime).
For example: a “file” is not a material thing for the Criminal Law: “no
theft of files”
For punishing whoever “steals files”, you must introduce a new Law that expressly punishes this kind of theft.
Whithout this new law, you cannot punish the “theft of files”, because you cannot extend the area of the legal concept of “theft”.
2) the express determination of the offences (whereby it is the rule itself which should exactly and precisely distinguish an unlawful act from an action that is irrelevant from a criminal point of view: avoiding ambiguous formulations in the Criminal Law)
3) the prohibition against the retrospective application of a criminal law
having NEGATIVE consequences for the offender. For example:
If “A” commits an action that, at this time, is not a crime (there is not a positive Law that expressly punishes this action).
After one month, the Parliament introduces a new Law, that punishes with imprisonment this kind of behavior for the first time.
Principle o materilaty
A person cannot be convicted if he or she did not perform a materially observable act (in Italian: «fatto»).
• No liability for «evil thoughts» alone
General rule: all the people can express his own opinions without any punishment
Exception: also opinions and speech can be punished when they are intolerable or bring a danger
Sec. 604 bis, Italian Criminal Code:
The punishment of imprisonment between two and six years
is applied if the propaganda or incitement, committed in a way that results in a concrete danger of diffusion, are based in whole or in part on denial or serious minimization for the Shoah or crimes of genocide, crimes against humanity and war crimes, as defined by articles 6, 7 and 8 of the statute of the International Criminal Court.
Harm principle
It is only permissible to punish a behavior if it causes harm to a ‘‘legal good‘ (bene giuridico), that is to say to an interest that has to be protected by Criminal Law.
• Criminal law allocates punishment for those conducts which harm or endanger some legal interests which are considered worth to be protected (life, property, honour, etc.)
for example:
Printing money in «black and white», because everybody can realise that is fake money, not real money;
Principle o culpability
one person could not be held responsible for the act of another
•principle upon which the individual must be considered blameworthy for the offence committed in order to be punishable.
In Italy, crimes can be punished only
1) For “intention”: for example, killing someone desiring and wanting death as a consequence of his action
2) For “negligence”: for example, killing someone by mistake, that is by violation of legal rules of diligence and caution (for example, violating the Road Traffic Act – Codice della Strada).
If somebody kills somebody without intention and without negligence, cannot be punished.
Criminal violations: felonies and misdemeanours
Two main categories:
1) Felonies («delitti») – more serious
2) Misdemeanours («contravvenzioni») – less serious criminal violations
Felonies («delitti») are criminal violations that are punished with three kinds of penalties:
a) life imprisonment («ergastolo») b) imprisonment («reclusione») c) a special fine called «multa»
Misdemeanours («contravvenzioni») are criminal violations that are punished with:
a) special imprisonment called «arrest» («arresto») b) special fine called «ammenda».
Example:
Sec. 640 ter c.p. (Cyber Fraud): (a serious crime)
Whoever, altering the functioning of a telematic system or intervening in any way (without right) on data, information or programs contained in a computer or a telematic system, causes for himself or others an illegal profit with others damage, is punished with imprisonment (“reclusione”) from six months to three years and with a fine (“multa”) from Euro 51 to Euro 1.032
he distinction between FELONY and MISDEMEANOURS carries out many legal consequences.
For example:
- crimes are punished only by way of intention
- misdemeanours by way of intention or negligence (both), even if the punishment by way of negligence is not expressly
established by the law
Elements of crime
There are 3 elements of crime:
- Actus reus
- Mens rea
- Not existence of defences (negative element)
- ACTUS REUS
• Criminal act (material conduct or behaviour): a crime involves an act or a failure to act (omission): criminal act called actus reus (objective element)
•Action/Omission + Event: the physical consequence (result or effect) of the offender’s conduct
The connection between Action and Event is called: CAUSATION (if I shoot somebody > I kill or hurt him or her)… causing death.
There is a «natural or physical law» that says: if you shoot somebody > you kill or hurt him or her
Haker attack -> … damages to a server or a computer
- MENS REA
• Criminal intent or inner (psychological) attitude: Criminal punishment is usually directed at individuals who intentionally or negligently (for recklessness) harm other individuals or properties, or other legal goods which deserve penal protection (subjective element)
INTENTION:
the will of the action and of the event
I want to kill somebody
I shoot somebody FOR KILLING him
RECKLESSNESS - NEGLIGENCE:
I do not want to kill anybody
But I cause somebody’s death, violating legal rules of diligence and caution (for example Road Traffic Act)
Example:
Sec. 575 c.p. (Murder)
Whoever causes intentionally the death of a man is punished with imprisonment for a term no less than twenty-one years
Actus reus:
Mens rea (Criminal intent or inner attitude): “intentionally…” (desiring and wanting to kill somebody)
Actus reus without men’s rea -> No crime
Example: A surgeon operates the patient in a technically perfect way
(without negligence); nevertheless, the patient dies.
A men’s rea without actus reus -> No crime
Example: A surgeon operates the patient’s actus intention to with the intention to steal them with negligence, not respecting the rules of medicine alive.
- Not existence of defences (negative element):
•Criminal liability is not imposed on an individual if it is demonstrated that his/her criminal act is justified (necessity, self-defence, superior order) or excused (i.e. duress, mistake of law or mistake of fact)
illegal interference in private life through video or a sound recording tools
Art. 615-bis: illegal interference in private life
Whoever,
1) through a video or a sound recording tools,
2) procures unduly informations or images relating to the private life taking place at home or in private residence,
3) is punished with imprisonment from six months to four years