Criminal Law Flashcards
Fairness
processes and procedures that are in place to ensure that all are treated with impartiality, without fear or favour
Equality
the ability for all to be treated with the same status, rights and opportunities regardless of individual differences
Access
the ability for all to approach and use the criminal justice system and pursue their case in court
Summary offences
less serious, minor criminal offences, heard in the Magistrates’ Court in front of a single magistrate
-minor assault/traffic offences
Victorian Summary Offences Act 1966
Indictable offences
the most serious criminal offences, heard in the County Court or the Supreme Court
-manslaughter/murder/rape
Victorian Crimes Act 1958
Indictable offences heard summarily
when indictable offences are ‘less’ serious, they can be heard in the Magistrates’ court if the accused and prosecution agree to do so. This saves time and money
Burden of proof
the party with the onus or responsibility of proving the case in court/the guilt of the accused. In criminal trials, this rests with the prosecution
Standard of proof
the level to which the party with the burden of proof must prove the guilt of the accused. In criminal cases, the prosecution must prove the case beyond reasonable doubt
Presumption of innocence
the notion that the accused is presumed to be innocent before the eyes of the court until proven guilty or they plead guilty
Sources of rights of the accused
International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights 1966
Charter of Rights and Responsibilities Act 2006 (Vic)
Rights of the accused
- The right to a fair hearing
- The right to a trial by jury
- The right to be tried without unreasonable delay
Sources of the rights of the victims
Victims Charter Act 2006 (Vic)
Rights of the victims
- The right to be informed about proceedings
- The right to give evidence as a vulnerable witness
- The right to be informed of the likely release date of the accused
Who is a vulnerable witness?
(In Criminal Procedural Act) An individual considered to be at risk:
- child
- person with a cognitive impairment
- alleged victim of family violence or sexual assault
Victorian Legal Aid (VLA)
a government agency that provides free legal advice to the community and low/no cost legal representation to the most vulnerable members of society.
Purpose of VLA
- improve access to legal system by providing legal advice and affordable legal representation
- educate the community about their rights in regards to the legal system, their powers, privileges and duties under the law
Services VLA offers
- Duty lawyers (if meet the income test)
- free legal advice and information
- grants of legal assistance (to help pay for a lawyer)
Community Legal Centres (CLC’s)
operate alongside VLA- they are independent organisations that provide free advice, information and representation to those who cannot access other services. Another avenue for legal assistance
Role of CLC’s
Provide:
- information, legal advice and minor assistance
- duty lawyer assistance
- legal casework
Generalist CLC’s
provide broad legal services to people in a particular geographic area
-Barwon Community Legal Service
Specialist CLC’s
focus on particular groups of people or on a specific area of law
-Youthlaw= free legal services to those under 25
Committal Proceedings
part of the pre-trial procedures that take place in the Magistrates’ Court when:
- an accused pleads not guilty
- an individual has been charged with one or more indictable offences
Purposes of Committals
- Determine if a prima facie case exists (the strength of the prosecutions case and if it will gain a conviction at trial)
- Determine how the accused will plead
- Ensuring a fair trial
- Determining the direction of the case
Plea Negotiations
discussions between the prosector and the accused about the charges against the accused, particularly what the accused will plead guilty to
Outcomes of plea negotiations
- accused will plead to fewer charges
- accused will plead guilty to lesser charges
Purpose of plea negotiations
- gain a guilty plea (early plea and one that reflects the crime)
- prompt resolution without the need for a full trial
Appropriateness of plea negotiations
- willingness of the accused to cooperate and plead
- strength of the prosecution’s case and likelihood of success
- witnesses willingness to give evidence
- time and expense of proceeding to trial
Strengths of plea negotiations
- save time, money and resources
- prompt determination
- save trauma of a trial for victims
- accused may receive a reduced sentence
- certainty of an outcome
Weaknesses of plea negotiations
- view that the offender is being ‘let off’
- self represented accused may be pressured into accepting offer
- prosecution avoiding need to prove standard of proof
- held privately, lack of transparency in the legal system
Sentence Indications
given by a court to the accused to let them know what sanction is likely to be imposed on them at a particular point in time
Criminal Procedure Act