Criminal Law Flashcards
Essential Elements of a Crime - General
- Act (or Omission)
2. Mental State
Movement that does not qualify as an ACT
- Conduct which is not the product of your own volition
- Reflex or convulsion
- act performed while asleep or unconscious
Omission
when legal duty arises
- By Statute
- By Contract
- Relationship between the parties (parent/child)
- voluntary assumption of a duty or care and failure to perform
- Where your conduct created the peril
4 Common Law Mental States of a Crime
- Specific Intent
- Malice Crimes
- General Intent Crimes
- Strict Liability Crimes
Specific Intent Crimes (11)
Solicitation Conspiracy Attempt First Degree Murder Assault Larceny Embezzlement False pretenses Robbery Burglary Forgery
Malice Crimes (2)
Murder
Arson
General Intent
All crimes that are not specific intent, malice crimes, or strict liability
Doctrine of Transferred Intent
-
Strict Liability
No Intent Crimes
- If the crime is in the administrative, regulatory, or morality arena and you do not see any adverbs such as Knowingly, willfully, or intentionally, then the statute is meant to be a no intent crime of strict liability
Model Penal Code Mental States
- Purposely
- Knowingly
- Recklessly
- Negligently
Purposely
One acts purposely when it is his conscious objective to engage in certain conduct or case a certain result
Knowingly
One acts knowingly when he is aware that his conduct will very likely cause the result
Recklessly
One acts recklessly when he consciously disregards a substantial and unjustifiable risk
Negligently
One acts negligently when he fails to be aware of a substantial and unjustifiable risk
Accomplice
One who Aids, Advises, or Encourages the principle in the commission of the crime charged
Accomplice Intent
Must intend that the crime be committed
Accomplice’s Liability
Accomplices are liable for the crime itself and all other foreseeable crimes
Accomplice Withdrawal
- If encouraged the crime, must repudiate the encouragement
- if aided by providing assistance to the principal, must do everything possible to neutralize the assistance
- Alternative to withdrawing - Contact police
Incohate Offenses
Incohate = Incomplete
- Solicitation
- Conspiracy
- Attempt
Solicitation
Define
Solicitation is asking someone to commit a crime. The crime of solicitation ends when you ask them.
Note: if the person you ask to commit the crime agrees to do it, it becomes a conspiracy and the solicitation merges and the only crime left when the other person agrees to do it is conspiracy.
Note: Factual Impossibility - No Defense
Conspiracy
Define
An agreement, with an intent to agree, and an intent to pursue and unlawful objective.
Note: Agreement can be express or inferred by conduct
Note: majority requires an overt act, minority looks to whether an agreement is present
Note: Factual Impossibility is NOT a defense
Conspiracy and Merger
Conspiracy does NOT merge with substantive offense. You can be convicted of conspiring to do something and doing it.
Liability for Co-Conspirator Crimes
Each conspirator is liable for ALL the crimes of co-conspirators if those crimes were committed in furtherance of the conspiracy and were foreseeable
Bi-Lateral Approach
Common Law
- Requires 2 guilty parties
- If one person is merely feigning agreement, the other person can’t be convicted of conspiracy
- Acquittal of one = acquittal of all
Unilateral Approach
Modern and MPC Approach
Requires that only 1 person have a genuine criminal intent
Withdrawal from Conspiracy
Withdrawal can never relieve defendant from liability from the conspiracy itself. May withdraw from the liability for the other conspirator’s subsequent crimes.
Attempt
define
Requires:
- Specific intent; and
- An overt act in furtherance of the crime
Note: Act must be a substantial step in furtherance of the commission of the crime. Mere preparation is not enough.
Defense of Abandonment
Majority Rule: Once Defendant has taken a substantial step toward committing the crime abandonment is NEVER a defense
Minority/MPC Rule: Allows for defense only if it fully voluntary and a complete renunciation of criminal purpose
Impossibility and Attempt
Legal Impossibility - Defense to attempt
Factual Impossibility - Not a defense to attempt
Defenses Based on Criminal Capacity
Insanity
Intoxication
Infancy