Criminal Courts Flashcards
What are the 2 first instance criminal courts?
- Magistrates
- Crown
What are the 3 classifications of offence?
Summary - Heard in the magistrates (e.g. assault)
Triable Either Way - Heard in mags or crown (e.g. ABH)
Indictable - Heard in crown (e.g. Serious GBH)
What is a summary offence?
The least serious type of offence. They are always heard in the mags where the magistrate will decide the verdict and sentence D.
What is a triable either way offence?
Mid-serious offences. They can be heard in either the mags or crown court, with the magistrate deciding the verdict and sentencing D in the mags and the jury deciding the verdict and the judge sentencing D in the crown.
What is an indictable offence?
The most serious type of offence. They are always heard in the crown court, where the jury will decide the verdict and the judge will sentence D.
What is the procedure for a summary offence?
- D receives a summons and is charged.
- D appears in the mags for a preliminary hearing.
- D enters their plea.
Guilty Plea: - Mags will sentence D (max 6 months)
- Mags can refer the case to the crown if they think their sentencing powers are not enough.
Not Guilty Plea: - Mags will set a date for trial
- Mags will set bail
- Trial
- Verdict and sentencing.
What is the procedure for triable either way offences?
- D is charged
- Plea before venue hearing (D enters plea)
Guilty Plea: - Mags will sentence D
- Mags can refer the case to the crown if they think their sentencing powers are not enough.
Not Guilty Plea: - Mode of Trial Hearing - mags decide whether or not they are able to hear the case, if not the case will go to the crown court, but if they can, the D will be given the choice which court to go to.
Mags: - Hear evidence and reach a verdict.
- Mags can refer the case to the crown if they think their sentencing powers are not enough.
Crown: - Case Management Hearing - date of trial is set and bail is set
- Jury decide verdict
- Judge sentences D
What are the factors taken into account by the mags in the mode of trial hearing?
Level of seriousness of offence Complex facts Complex issues of law Vulnerability of D or V Abuse of trust
What are the advantages for the D choosing the Magistrates over the Crown?
Cheaper
Quicker
Limits on sentencing
Local knowledge
What are the advantages for the D choosing the Crown over the Magistrates?
More likely to be acquitted
More likely to be granted legal aid
More likely to be represented by an experienced lawyer
If D is on remand and likely to receive a custodial sentence, their sentence will be reduced for their time spent on remand.
What is the procedure for indictable offences?
- D is charged
- D enters Plea - in mags
- Case Management Hearing - date of trial is set
- Trial
- Jury decide verdict
- Judge sentences D
What are the two grounds on which the D can appeal?
Conviction
Sentence
What is an appeal against conviction from the Mags?
A judge and 2 mags will hear the appeal in the crown court. They can uphold the decision (no change), quash it (D shouldn’t be guilty) or vary it (change the charge).
What is an appeal against sentence from the Mags?
A judge and 2 mags will hear the appeal in the crown court. They can uphold, decrease or increase D’s sentence. They can only increase it up to the maximum sentencing powers of the mags (6 months).
What must D apply for for an appeal from the crown court?
D must be granted leave (permission from the CoA to appeal)