CRIM LAW Flashcards
CRIM LAW CHECKLIST 5
1) 4 essential elements of a crime
2) Homicide
3) OTHER CRIMES
4) DEFENSES
5) IMMUNITY
CRIME 4BRD
Prosecution must prove each element beyond reasonable doubt: 1) actus reus, 2) mens rea, 3) concurrence, 4) causation
ACTUS REUS 2
- Physical voluntary (mtn ctrl) act, incl verbal but not involuntary
- Omission / failure to act when a duty exists
- statutorily
- contractual
- special relationship
- detrimental undertaking
- causation (causing the danger)
Vicarious liability when committed by TP
- generally limited to regulatory crimes, punishable by fines
- Corps may be liable when act is performed by a high-ranking agent (representing the Corp)
MENS REA 5
a guilty mind / legally proscribed mental state
1. SI FIAT CL
2. Gen Intent BRKF Transferred
3. Malice AM
4. MPC
5. Strict liability 2
MOF may negate crim intent if
- rnxble and unrxnble mistakes in SI crimes
- only rxnble mistakes in Gen Intent and Malice crimes
MOL only valid if D relied on Ct decision/administrative order or official interpreation of law
SPECIFIC INTENT CRIMES FIAT CL
THEFTS ROB BURG 1M INCH ASS
D has the subjective desire, specific objective, or knowledge to accomplish prohibited result FIAT
1. 1M
2. Inchoate
3. Assault w intent to commit Battery
4. Theft
Mistake of Fact MOF is a defense in both rxnble and unrxnsnable mistakes
MALICE CRIMES AM(CL)
Reckless disregard of a high risk of harm
Requires only the act w/o excuse, justification, or mitigation
Intent can be inferred from the completed act
1. Arson
2. CL Murder
Rxnble MOF may negate crim intent
GENERAL INTENT CRIMES BRKFI
intent to perform unlawful act
1. Battery
2. Rape
3. Kidnapping
4. False imprisonment
MPC Intent PKRN
Rxnble MOF may negate crim intent
Transferred intent 1 - bad aim victim only, not mistaken ID
usually confined to Homicide, Battery GI, and Arson (Malice)
Not for attempted crimes
MPC INTENT PKRN
- Purposely - concious objection to engage in conduct or to cause a certain result
- Knowingly/willfully - aware or know that the result is practially certain to occur from conduct
- Recklessly - concious disregard of a substantial and unjustifiable risk
- Negligently - should be aware of substantial and unjustifiable risk that a material element of a crime exists or will result from conduct, ie. gross deviation from standard of care (voluntary intox/DUI)
does not specifically recognized transferred intent
STRICT LIABILITY CRIMES SR BI REG
no mens rea
1. Statutory Rape
2. Bigamy
3. Regulatory offenses
generally disfavored (must have clear legislative intent to dispense men
CONCURRENCE A&M BRD
the mens rea must simultaneously be present at the comission of the actus rea
Beyond a Rxnble Doubt standard applies for convictions
CAUSATION AP/S
the mens rea (if required) must cause the actus reus, and the act must cause the particular result made unlawful
1. Actual - but for
2. Proximate - legal
- Superseding
ACTUAL CAUSE
V would not have died but for D’s conduct
PROXIMATE CAUSE
D is responsible for all results that occur as a natural and probable consequence of his conduct (teacher’s suicide is not PC of teen lying about fondling/clerk’s heart condition dn break causation), unless there was a superseding force
SUPERSEDING EVENT 3
break the chain of legal causation
1. acts of nature
2. coincidence
3. NOT neg med care
HOMICIDE 4
the killing of another human being
1. CL - unlawful killing of another with malice aforethought 4
2. Statutory MM
3. Felony Murder BARRK
4. Manslaughter VI
Homicide of police 2
i. D must know V is police, and
ii. Police must be acting in the line of duty
CL Murder Malice 4
- intent to kill
- intent to do serious bodily inj (unintentional killing)
- depraved heart - reckless indifference to an unjustifiably high risk to human life (unintentional killing)
- intent to commit an inherently dangerous felony
FMR occur during or attempted commission & ends @ temp safety
STATUTORY MUDER 2M
- First degree Murder
- deliberate and premediated murder, or
- after froming the intent to kill, time for reflection
- FMR
- SI defenses - Second degree Murder
- malicious intent to kill = CL Murder
- default if not 1M
MANSLAUGHTER VI
- Voluntary Manslaughter - homicide with malice aforethought but w mitigating circumstances 2
- Involuntary Manslaughter - unintentional homicide committed w Criminal Negligence or during an unlawful act 2)
VOLUNTARY MANSLAUGHTER 2
- Heat of Passion
- in response to inlammatory situation, not mere words
- not a defense, but reduce/mitigate murder down
- exclude murder where there is sufficient time bw the provocation and the killing (cool down period)
- tranferred provocation applies - Imperfect defense if
- D started the altercation, or
- unrxnbly believed in the necessity of using deadly force
no mens rea
INVOLUNTARY MANSLAUGHTER 2
- Criminal Negligence - grossly negligent action (or inaction when there is a duty to act) that puts another person at a significant risk of serious inj or death (ex. untreated sick child)
- Unlawful act - a killing committed during the commission of (no mens rea)
- a misdemeanor (ex. traffic deaths)
- a felony that is not 1M or 2M
FELONY MURDER BARRK
- unintended and foreseeable killing
- proximately caused by and during
- the commission or attempted commission
- of an inherently dangerous felony BARRK
Point of safety ends FMR killing
defense to underlying felony is defense to FMR
REDLINE DOCTRINE FMR
D is not guilty of death of a co-felon by a V or police under FMR
FMR LIABILITY A/PC
- Agency theory (majority) - D is not liable for bystander’s death caused by V or police
- Proximate Cause theory (minority - a bystander’s death falls underFMR bc the death is a direct consequence of the felony
PARTIES TO CRIME PAA
- Principal - actus reus, must be actually or constructively present at the scene
- Accomplice 3
- Accomplice - aid/abet/faciliate a Prin prior to or during
- Principal in the Second Degree - physically / constructivelly present during the commission
- Accessory before the fact - neither physically or constructively present during - Accessory After the Fact
- avoid apprehension or conviction after commission
- must know that felony was committed
- only liable for separate crime (ex. obstruction of justice / harboring a fugitive)
INSANITY TESTS 4
- M’Naghten (right from wrong) - did not know eitherr (1) the nature and quality of the act, or (2) the wrongfulness of the act bc of a defect of reason due to menatl disease
- Irresistible Impulse (inability to conform conduct to law) - lack capacity for self-control and free choice due to mental disease or defect
- Durham (but for)- the unlawful act was the product of mental disease or defect
- MPC (M’Naghten + II) - at the time of the conduct, lack substantial capacity to appreciate the wrongfulness of the act or to conform conduct to law as a result of mental disease or defect
INTOXICATION VI
- Voluntary - intentional taking of intoxicating subtance, but need not intend actual intoxication
- defense to SI crimes
- defense to MPC purposely / knowingly - Involuntary - taken w/o knowledge or under duress
- may negate strict liability
- defense to all crimes