Crim Law 1 Flashcards
Impossible Crime and Penalty
- Act performed would be crime against PERSONS or PROPERTY
- Done with evil intent
- Accomplishment is
a. Inherently Impossible
b. Means employed were ineffective or inadequate - Would not constitute any other violation in the RPC
Penalty - Arresto Mayor and P200-P500
Doctrine of Pro Reo
Every doubt is rendered in favor of the accused. Courts must consider circumstances in his favor.
Rule of Lenity
When there is Ambiguity, resolve ambiguity in favor of the accused
Where is the power to define and punish crimes derived from?
Art II Sec 5. Maintenance of peace and order, protection of Life, liberty and property and promotion of general welfare are essential for enjoyment of democracy
General Intent vs Specific Intent
General - Intent to cause damage to another
Specific - Must be specific to the crime (Intent to gain, intent to kill)
4 Theories in Criminal Law
Classical - Basis of crim liablity is free will and punishment is for retribution
Positivist - Man is subdued by strange and morbid phenomenon that compels him to do crime
Mixed - Mix of the first where crimes have a social and economic element should be dealt with a modicum of compassion
Utilitarian (Protective) Primary purpose of Crim law is to protect society from actual/potential wrongdoers
Constitutional Limits to enact penal laws (8)
Equal Protection
Due Process
Freedom of Expression
Freedom of speech
No plain, oppressive, cruel or inhumane punishment
Criminal Due Process
Bill of Attainder
Ex post Facto
Attempted Felony
- Commences commission of felony directly by overt act
- Acts performed would constitute a felony
- Acts not stopped by own spontaneous desistance
- non-performance of act was independent of cause/accident
3 Characteristics of Crim Law
Generality - Applies to all those who live or sojourn in the PH
XP: Other Chiefs of state
Ambassadors
Minister Plenipotentiary and residents
Charges’ de affiars
Territoriality - Applies to entire territory of PH (See Art 1 1987 Consti)
XP: Ph ship/airship
forges/counterfeits ph currency or obligations (includes lotto tickets)
brings the same to PH
Public officers in discharge of their official tasks
Violation of laws of public security or national order
Prospective- Forward Application
XP: Unless specifically made retroactive
Art 22 RPC - Retroactive if favorable to the accused
EXP: Unless habitual delinquent
Felony - Art 4
Any act/ommission in violation of the RPC
may be done by dolo/culpa
Dolo vs Culpa
Dolo - With malice and intent to cause injury to another
Culpa - No malice and punished to a lesser degree
Habitual Delinquent
Within a period of 10 YEARS
committed 3 crimes or more
Crimes are FRETSeL
Falsification
Robbery
Estafa
Theft
Serious Phys Injuries
Less serious ph injuries
French vs English Rule
French: Flag country has jurisdiction
XP: Crimes on board are not triable unless it affects peace and order of host country
English: Territory has jurisdicition
XP: Crime merely affects internal management of the ship
Differentiate Oanis vs Ah Chong (When is there mistake of fact)
Ah Chong:
1. There is mistake of fact
2. No fault on accused
3. pressed by circumstances to act immediately
Oanis
1. No mistake of facts
2. Fault on the part of the accuse
3. Not pressed by any circumstance to act immediately
People v Santiago
The State has the power to define and punish crimes and lay down the rules for crim procedure