Court Phase 3: Expert Testimony Flashcards
Actus Reus
A wrongful deed
Unfit to stand trial
Refers to an inability to conduct a defence at any stage of the proceedings on account of a person’s mental disorder
Classical Penal System (Rehabilitation)
- Focused on the dignity and worth of the individual
According to the classical model:
• Free will enables human beings to purposely and deliberately choose to
follow a calculated course of action
• Crime is attractive and is controlled through the fear of punishment
• Punishment is to be applied equally to all offenders
• Punishment works best when perceived to be: Severe, Certain, Swift
• The model was utilitarian (“the greatest happiness for the greatest number”)
• Criminals are essentially the same as non-criminals. They commit crimes
after calculating costs and benefits
Rehabilitation
- Model that emphasises the provision of treatment programs designed to reform the offender
- Belongs to the modern penal system C19th
Rehabilitation and the modern penal system
• emerged with the growth of new scientific disciplines like psychiatry,
psychology and psychotherapy
• Positivist
• Human behaviour is determined and not a matter of free will
• Criminals are fundamentally different from non-criminals
• Crime is frequently caused by multiple factors
(psychological, biological, or social) that constrain our rationality
• Focused on offenders rather than systems
• Punishment to be applied differently to different offenders (‘what
works for whom, where and when?’)
• Programs designed to address criminal propensities
Contemporary Rehabilitation
Emphasises personal responsibility for offending
and rehabilitation
• Often involves: restorative justice, therapeutic jurisprudence, specialist
courts
Restorative Justice
– “a process whereby all the parties with a stake in a
particular offence come together to resolve collectively how to deal with the
aftermath of the offence and its implications for the future”
Rehabilitation (Focuses on the needs of victims of crime)
• holds offenders accountable and responsible for the harm
they have caused
• Offenders have to acknowledge their wrongdoing and
repair harm to victim
Conferencing Models
victim/offender mediation
(relatives and authorities are also involved); circle sentencing;
family group conferencing; community reparation boards (See
https://www.ncjrs.gov/pdffiles1/ojjdp/184738.pdf for more info on
each)
Therapeutic Jurisprudence (TJ)
legal term that describes criminal justice and court
initiatives that focus on therapeutic interventions to start
to rehabilitate an offender during the court process
• therapeutic jurisprudence can sometimes be referred to
as collaborative justice
• recognises that the law and legal process can have
positive or negative effects on participants, including
offenders
• TJ may look at how the court works, sentencing process,
sentences, speciality courts, etc
Speciality or problem solving courts
Drug dependency in offenders (drug courts)
• Mental health problems and offending (mental health
courts)
• Indigenous over-representation (Indigenous courts)
• Family and domestic violence (family violence court)
Can serve 1 of 3 roles:
• Court as case manager – ongoing
• Diversionary operators and case monitors – alternatives
• Specialist adjudicator – sentences
Key approaches to offender rehabilitation
Key approaches can inform treatment in custodial
and community settings:
• The Risk-Need-Responsivity (RNR) model –
psychological (offender deficit) model
• The Good Lives Model (GLM) –psychosocial
(desistence) model
Risk-Need-Responsivity Model (RNR)
The Risk-Need-Responsivity (RNR) model is a correctional
intervention model based on the factors of risk, need, and
responsivity
• Usually specific tools are used to assess the 3 levels (e.g the LSI-R)
Criminogenic needs might include
- antisocial attitudes, values, and beliefs (rationalising
“everybody does it, so what’s the problem”, “I have the
right to do what I want” or denial of responsibility “I was
framed”, “I’ve already been punished enough”)
• low self control
• criminal peers
• substance abuse
• lack of employment
• dysfunctional family
Non-Criminogenic Needs
Non-criminogenic needs can also be assessed and
treated. If changed these may have an indirect impact
on criminal behaviour and recidivism: Noncriminogenic
needs might include:
• low self-esteem
• anxiety
• lack of parenting skills
• medical needs
• victimisation issues
• learning disability